← 4.1
Act 4, Scene 2 — A Room in Olivia’s House.
on stage: —
Next: 4.3 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Maria gives the Clown (Feste) a gown and beard to impersonate Sir Topas, a curate. Sir Toby watches from outside a darkened room where Malvolio has been locked away — everyone believes he's gone mad. The Clown, disguised as Sir Topas, visits Malvolio and interrogates him about 'the fiend' that possesses him. Sir Toby and Maria enjoy the cruelty. Malvolio, still convinced of his earlier fantasies, insists he's sane. The scene ends with the Clown offering to fetch Malvolio a light, though he makes no move to do so.
Enter Maria and Clown.
MARIA [hurriedly setting up the prank]

Nay, I prithee, put on this gown and this beard; make him believe thou

art Sir Topas the curate. Do it quickly. I’ll call Sir Toby the whilst.

Please, put on this gown and beard. Make him think you're Sir Topas the curate. Do it quickly. I'll get Sir Toby while you do this.

Come on, put on this robe and beard. He'll think you're Sir Topas, a clergyman. Hurry up. I'll go get Sir Toby while you're getting ready.

put on this gown & beard make him think you're a priest hurry i'll get sir toby

[_Exit Maria._]
CLOWN [wryly amused at playing a parson]

Well, I’ll put it on, and I will dissemble myself in’t, and I would I

were the first that ever dissembled in such a gown. I am not tall

enough to become the function well, nor lean enough to be thought a

good student, but to be said, an honest man and a good housekeeper goes

as fairly as to say, a careful man and a great scholar. The competitors

enter.

I'll put on the disguise, and I wish I were the first person to ever disguise myself in such a robe. I'm not tall enough to look right as a clergyman, nor lean enough to look like a scholar, but being called an honest man and a good householder is just as respectable as being called a careful man and a great scholar.

Okay, I'll put this on. I wish I could be the first guy ever to disguise himself in a cassock like this. I'm not tall enough to look right as a priest, and I'm definitely not skinny enough to pass as an intellectual. But honestly, being a solid, honest guy who runs his household well is just as good as being called a scholar.

gonna put this on. wish i was first to ever wear fake outfit like this. not tall/skinny enough 4 priest look but honest + responsible > scholar anyway

"dissemble myself" To disguise oneself — to pretend. The Clown is acknowledging that he's about to lie and deceive.
Enter Sir Toby and Maria.
SIR TOBY [playing along, amused]

Jove bless thee, Master Parson.

May the gods bless you, Master Parson.

God bless you, Parson.

bless u parson

CLOWN [hamming up the disguise]

_Bonos dies_, Sir Toby: for as the old hermit of Prague, that never saw

pen and ink, very wittily said to a niece of King Gorboduc, ‘That that

is, is’: so I, being Master Parson, am Master Parson; for what is

‘that’ but ‘that’? and ‘is’ but ‘is’?

Good day, Sir Toby. As the ancient hermit of Prague, who never saw writing, cleverly said to a niece of King Gorboduc: 'Whatever is, is' - so I, being Master Parson, am Master Parson. For what is 'that' but 'that'? And what is 'is' but 'is'?

Good day, Sir Toby. The old hermit of Prague, who'd never even seen writing, made a brilliant point to a niece of King Gorboduc: 'Whatever is, is.' So I'm Master Parson because I'm Master Parson. 'That' is 'that' and 'is' is 'is.' It's obvious.

hey sir toby. like the hermit said: whatever is, is. im parson bc im parson lol. thats that

"Bonos dies" The Clown is mangling 'Buenos días' (Spanish for good day) — suggesting Sir Topas is a fraud with pretentious education.
"old hermit of Prague" A fictional reference the Clown is inventing to sound learned. There is no such hermit. He's making it up as he goes.
SIR TOBY [encouraging the prank]

To him, Sir Topas.

Address him, Sir Topas.

Speak to him now, Sir Topas.

speak to him

CLOWN [booming with mock authority]

What ho, I say! Peace in this prison!

Greetings! There must be peace in this prison!

Hey there! I want to see order and peace in this prison!

yo! chill out in here

SIR TOBY ≋ verse [delighted at the performance]

The knave counterfeits well. A good knave.

Malvolio within.

The rogue is doing an excellent job faking it. He's a good rogue. Malvolio calls from inside.

The guy's playing his part really well. Good rogue. (Malvolio calls from inside.)

hes doing great at faking it lol. malvolio's inside

MALVOLIO [desperate for rescue]

Who calls there?

Who calls there?

who calls there?

Who calls there?

CLOWN [mock-solemn introduction]

Sir Topas the curate, who comes to visit Malvolio the lunatic.

I am Sir Topas the clergyman, who is here to visit Malvolio the madman.

I'm Sir Topas the priest, and I'm here to visit Malvolio, the lunatic.

im sir topas the priest here to visit malvolio the crazy guy

MALVOLIO [pleading, desperate]

Sir Topas, Sir Topas, good Sir Topas, go to my lady.

Sir Topas, Sir Topas, good Sir Topas, go visit my lady.

Sir Topas, Sir Topas, I beg you Sir Topas, go see my lady.

sir topas pls visit my lady

CLOWN [taunting him as a devil]

Out, hyperbolical fiend! how vexest thou this man? Talkest thou nothing

but of ladies?

Get away, you exaggerating demon! How are you tormenting this man? Do you talk about nothing but ladies?

Back off, you over-the-top demon! How are you messing with this guy? Is all you ever talk about ladies?

back off demon! ur always going on about ladies

SIR TOBY [enjoying the cruelty]

Well said, Master Parson.

Well spoken, Master Parson.

Good job there, Parson.

good one parson

MALVOLIO [insisting on his sanity]

Sir Topas, never was man thus wronged. Good Sir Topas, do not think I

am mad. They have laid me here in hideous darkness.

Sir Topas, no man was ever wronged as I have been. Good Sir Topas, do not think I am mad. They have imprisoned me here in terrible darkness.

Sir Topas, I've never been treated so badly in my life. Sir Topas, I'm not crazy. They've locked me in this horrible darkness.

never been wronged like this. im not mad. theyre keeping me in the dark

CLOWN [mockingly pious, needling him]

Fie, thou dishonest Satan! I call thee by the most modest terms, for I

am one of those gentle ones that will use the devil himself with

courtesy. Say’st thou that house is dark?

Shame on you, deceitful Satan! I address you in the mildest terms because I am one of those kind people who would treat even the devil with respect. Do you claim that this house is dark?

Shame on you, you lying Satan! I'm calling you names as politely as I can, because I'm one of those nice people who's even courteous to the devil himself. Are you really saying this house is dark?

stop lying satan. im being super polite about it. is the house dark?

MALVOLIO [miserable in the dark]

As hell, Sir Topas.

Darker than the deepest part of hell, Sir Topas.

It's blacker than hell itself, Sir Topas.

darker than hell itself

CLOWN [gaslighting him for sport]

Why, it hath bay windows transparent as barricadoes, and the

clerestories toward the south-north are as lustrous as ebony; and yet

complainest thou of obstruction?

On the contrary, it has bay windows as clear as barricades, and those high windows facing south-north shine like ebony. Yet you still complain about darkness?

Come on, it has bay windows as clear as barricades and those high windows facing south shine like ebony. How can you complain about darkness?

nah it has clear bay windows n bright upper ones. stop complaining

MALVOLIO [frustrated, insisting on truth]

I am not mad, Sir Topas. I say to you this house is dark.

I am not mad, Sir Topas. I am telling you plainly: this house is dark.

I'm not crazy, Sir Topas. I'm telling you: this house is dark.

im not mad. the house is dark.

CLOWN [feigning learned scorn]

Madman, thou errest. I say there is no darkness but ignorance, in which

thou art more puzzled than the Egyptians in their fog.

You are mistaken, madman. I say there is no darkness except ignorance, and in that you are more confused than the Egyptians were in their thick fog.

You're wrong, madman. There's no real darkness except ignorance, and you're more confused by it than the Egyptians ever were in their fog.

youre wrong. theres no darkness just ignorance n youre more lost in it than egyptians in fog

"no darkness but ignorance" Sir Topas is playing with philosophy — suggesting that Malvolio's problem isn't the dark room but his lack of understanding. It's intellectually vicious because it frames Malvolio's reasonable complaints as symptoms of madness.
MALVOLIO [desperate to prove his sanity]

I say this house is as dark as ignorance, though ignorance were as dark

as hell; and I say there was never man thus abused. I am no more mad

than you are. Make the trial of it in any constant question.

I say this house is as dark as ignorance, though ignorance were as dark as hell. I say no man was ever abused as I have been. I am no more mad than you are. Test me on any question you want.

This house is dark as ignorance, even if ignorance were as dark as hell. No one's ever been treated as badly as me. I'm not any more crazy than you are. Ask me any question - test me.

this house is dark. ive been treated worse than anyone. im not crazier than u. test me

CLOWN [springing an absurd test]

What is the opinion of Pythagoras concerning wildfowl?

What is Pythagoras's teaching about birds?

What did Pythagoras believe about birds?

whats pythagoras say about birds

MALVOLIO [earnestly answering the test]

That the soul of our grandam might haply inhabit a bird.

That our grandmother's soul might possibly live inside a bird.

That our grandmother's soul could live in a bird.

grandmas soul could be in a bird

CLOWN [pressing the trap further]

What think’st thou of his opinion?

What do you think of his teaching?

What do you think about that idea?

what u think bout that

MALVOLIO [confidently asserting his reason]

I think nobly of the soul, and no way approve his opinion.

I have high regard for the soul, and I completely reject his teaching.

I think the soul is too important for that, and I completely disagree with him.

soul is too important. i disagree

CLOWN [pronouncing mock judgment, gleeful]

Fare thee well. Remain thou still in darkness. Thou shalt hold the

opinion of Pythagoras ere I will allow of thy wits, and fear to kill a

woodcock, lest thou dispossess the soul of thy grandam. Fare thee well.

Goodbye. Stay in darkness. You must believe in Pythagoras's teaching before I will think you are sane, and be afraid to kill a woodcock for fear of releasing your grandmother's soul. Goodbye.

Goodbye. Stay in the dark. You have to believe in Pythagoras before I'll think you're sane, and you need to be afraid to kill any birds in case your grandmother's soul is in them. Goodbye.

bye. stay in the dark. gotta believe pythagoras or youre mad. dont kill birds or grandmas soul dies. bye

MALVOLIO [calling out in despair]

Sir Topas, Sir Topas!

Sir Topas! Please, Sir Topas!

Sir Topas! Sir Topas, come back!

topas! come back!

SIR TOBY [delighted praise]

My most exquisite Sir Topas!

My most excellent Sir Topas!

My most wonderful Sir Topas!

amazing parson work!

CLOWN [boasting of his versatility]

Nay, I am for all waters.

No, I can handle anything.

No, I can do anything. I'm adaptable.

nah i got this lol. im versatile

MARIA [pointing out the pointless disguise]

Thou mightst have done this without thy beard and gown. He sees thee

not.

You could have done this without your beard and robe. He cannot see you.

You could've done this without the costume. He can't see you anyway.

didnt need the outfit. he cant see u

SIR TOBY [growing uneasy about the prank]

To him in thine own voice, and bring me word how thou find’st him. I

would we were well rid of this knavery. If he may be conveniently

delivered, I would he were, for I am now so far in offence with my

niece that I cannot pursue with any safety this sport to the upshot.

Come by and by to my chamber.

Talk to him in your normal voice and come back and tell me how you find him. I wish we could get rid of this trickery. If we can get him released without trouble, I want that to happen, because I have offended my niece so much that I cannot safely continue this prank to its end. Come to my room soon.

Talk to him in your real voice and come tell me how he's doing. I want to stop all this fooling around. If we can get him out of there without problems, we should, because I've really upset my niece and I can't keep playing pranks safely. Come to my room in a bit.

talk to him normal n tell me how hes doing. i wanna stop this. if we can release him safely, lets. upset my niece too much. come to my room soon

[_Exeunt Sir Toby and Maria._]
[_Singing._]
CLOWN ≋ verse [teasingly singing to torment him]

_Hey, Robin, jolly Robin,

Tell me how thy lady does._

Hey, Robin, cheerful Robin, tell me how your lady is doing.

Hey Robin, merry Robin, tell me: how's your sweetheart doing?

hey robin tell me how ur lady is

MALVOLIO [calling out, ignored]

Fool!

Fool!

fool!

Fool!

CLOWN [continuing the taunting song]

_My lady is unkind, perdy._

My lady is cruel, by God.

My lady is cold to me, I swear.

my lady is mean

MALVOLIO [growing more desperate]

Fool!

Fool!

fool!

Fool!

CLOWN [playing deaf to his calls]

_Alas, why is she so?_

Alas, why is she that way?

Why is she like that?

why shes like that

MALVOLIO [shouting in frustration]

Fool, I say!

Fool, I say!

fool, i say!

Fool, I say!

CLOWN ≋ verse [feigning to just now notice him]

_She loves another_—

Who calls, ha?

She loves someone else - Who is calling there?

She loves another guy - Who's calling?

she loves someone else - who there

MALVOLIO [humbly begging for help]

Good fool, as ever thou wilt deserve well at my hand, help me to a

candle, and pen, ink, and paper. As I am a gentleman, I will live to be

thankful to thee for’t.

Good fool, if you ever want me to treat you well, help me get a candle and pen, ink, and paper. As I am a gentleman, I will spend my life being grateful to you for it.

Listen, if you want me to reward you well, get me a candle, pen, ink, and paper. I promise you as a gentleman, I'll spend the rest of my life thanking you for it.

if u want me to treat u good get me candle n pen n ink n paper. ill owe u 4 life

CLOWN [mock-surprised recognition]

Master Malvolio?

Master Malvolio?

master malvolio?

Master Malvolio?

MALVOLIO [relieved, pleading]

Ay, good fool.

Ay, good fool.

ay, good fool.

Ay, good fool.

CLOWN [mock sympathy, needling]

Alas, sir, how fell you besides your five wits?

Alas, sir, how did you lose your mind?

Alas, sir, how did you lose your senses?

how'd u lose ur mind

"five wits" The five senses (in medieval psychology). To lose one's five wits is to go mad.
MALVOLIO [insisting he's sane]

Fool, there was never man so notoriously abused. I am as well in my

wits, fool, as thou art.

Fool, no man was ever so shamefully mistreated. I am as sane as you are, fool.

Fool, I've never been treated so badly. I'm just as sane as you are.

ive never been treated this bad. im as sane as u

CLOWN [twisting his words cruelly]

But as well? Then you are mad indeed, if you be no better in your wits

than a fool.

As sane as me? Then you really are mad if you are no more intelligent than a fool.

As sane as me? If that's all, then you really are crazy, because I'm a fool.

if thats all then ur definitely mad lol

MALVOLIO [describing his torment, indignant]

They have here propertied me; keep me in darkness, send ministers to

me, asses, and do all they can to face me out of my wits.

They have treated me like a possession here; they keep me in darkness, send tormentors to me, and do everything they can to drive me insane.

They're treating me like property here. They keep me locked in darkness, send people to torture me, and try everything to drive me crazy.

theyre treating me like property. locked in dark. people torturing me. trying to make me go crazy

CLOWN [switching back into the mock-parson voice]

Advise you what you say: the minister is here. [_As Sir Topas_]

Malvolio, Malvolio, thy wits the heavens restore. Endeavour thyself to

sleep, and leave thy vain bibble-babble.

Be careful what you say: the minister is here. (As Sir Topas) Malvolio, Malvolio, may the heavens restore your mind. Try to sleep and stop your pointless babbling.

Watch what you say - the priest is here now. (As the priest) Malvolio, Malvolio, I hope heaven will restore your senses. Try to sleep and stop this senseless prattle.

shh ministers here. (as priest) malvolio hope heaven fixes ur brain. try to sleep stop babbling

MALVOLIO [desperate, calling out from the dark]

Sir Topas!

Sir Topas!

sir topas!

Sir Topas!

CLOWN [relishing the trick, voicing both roles]

[_As Sir Topas_] Maintain no words with him, good fellow. [_As

himself_] Who, I, sir? not I, sir. God buy you, good Sir Topas. [_As

Sir Topas_] Marry, amen. [_As himself_] I will sir, I will.

[As Sir Topas] Do not speak to him, good fellow. [As himself] Me, sir? Absolutely not, sir. Goodbye, Sir Topas. [As Sir Topas] Indeed, amen. [As himself] I will, sir, I will.

[Pretending to be Sir Topas] Don't talk to this guy, buddy. [Back to himself] Me? No way, not me, sir. See you, Sir Topas. [As Sir Topas] Sure, amen. [Back to himself] I'll do it, I'll do it.

don't talk to him. me? nope not me. bye topas. amen. yep i will

MALVOLIO [frustrated, pleading for the fool's help]

Fool, fool, fool, I say!

Fool, Fool, Fool—I'm calling you!

Hey! Listen! I'm calling for you!

hey hey hey listen to me!

CLOWN [feigning meekness, mocking]

Alas, sir, be patient. What say you, sir? I am shent for speaking to

you.

Please, sir, be patient. What are you saying, sir? I will be scolded for speaking to you.

Please, sir, calm down. What are you saying? I'll get in trouble for talking to you.

chill sir. im gonna get in trouble for talking to u

MALVOLIO [pleading again for help]

Good fool, help me to some light and some paper. I tell thee I am as

well in my wits as any man in Illyria.

Good fool, help me get some light and some paper. I am telling you I am as sane as any man in Illyria.

Good fool, get me some light and paper. I'm telling you I'm as sane as anyone in Illyria.

get me light n paper. im as sane as any1 in illyria

CLOWN [doubting him mockingly]

Well-a-day that you were, sir!

I wish that were the case, sir!

I only wish that were really true, sir!

wish that was true lol

MALVOLIO [swearing earnestly to his sanity]

By this hand, I am. Good fool, some ink, paper, and light, and convey

what I will set down to my lady. It shall advantage thee more than ever

the bearing of letter did.

I swear by this hand, I am. Good fool, get me some ink, paper, and light, and deliver to my lady what I will write. It will benefit you more than any letter delivery ever did.

I swear it, I'm as sane as them. Good fool, get me ink, paper, and light, and deliver what I write to my lady. It'll do you more good than any letter you've ever delivered.

i swear im sane. get me ink paper n light. deliver my letter to my lady. better deal than usual

CLOWN [toying with him before helping]

I will help you to’t. But tell me true, are you not mad indeed? or do

you but counterfeit?

I will help you get them. But tell me honestly: are you really not mad? Or are you just pretending?

I'll help you get them. But be honest with me: are you really not crazy? Or are you just faking it?

ill help. but r u actually not mad or r u faking

MALVOLIO [imploring him to believe]

Believe me, I am not. I tell thee true.

Believe me, I am not mad. I am telling you the truth.

Believe me, I'm not. I'm telling you the truth.

im not mad. im serious

CLOWN [teasing skepticism]

Nay, I’ll ne’er believe a madman till I see his brains. I will fetch

you light, and paper, and ink.

No, I will not believe a madman until I see actual proof. I will get you light, paper, and ink.

No, I won't believe you're sane till I see proof. I'll get you light, paper, and ink.

nah ill get u light paper n ink

MALVOLIO [urgently sending him off]

Fool, I’ll requite it in the highest degree: I prithee be gone.

Fool, I will repay you to the greatest extent: go now, please.

Fool, I will reward you greatly for this. Please go.

ill reward u big time. go pls

[_Singing._]
CLOWN ≋ verse [singing a mocking farewell]

_I am gone, sir, and anon, sir,

I’ll be with you again,

In a trice, like to the old Vice,

Your need to sustain;

Who with dagger of lath, in his rage and his wrath,

Cries ‘ah, ha!’ to the devil:

Like a mad lad, ‘Pare thy nails, dad.

Adieu, goodman devil.’_

I am leaving, sir, and soon, sir, I will be back with you again. In a moment, like the old Vice character, to meet your need. The Vice who with his wooden dagger, in his rage and anger, yells 'Ha ha!' at the devil: Like a mad boy, 'Trim your nails, father. Farewell, good devil.'

I'm leaving now, sir, and I'll be back with you soon. In just a moment, like that old Vice character, to help you out. The Vice with his wooden dagger, raging and angry, yelling 'Ha ha!' at the devil: Like a crazy kid, 'Trim your nails, dad. Goodbye, good devil.'

im gone. be back soon with ur stuff. like the old vice guy with his wooden dagger lol. bye good devil

[_Exit._]

The Reckoning

This is where the prank turns darker. Earlier, everyone was having fun watching Malvolio humiliate himself. Now he's locked in the dark, terrified, and people are pretending he's possessed. He's still convinced of the letter and of his imminent marriage to Olivia, but nobody is listening to him — they're just tormenting him for entertainment. The tragedy is that Malvolio is right about most of what he says (the letter was genuine, Olivia is interested in 'Cesario'), but because he's been set up to look mad, nobody believes him.

If this happened today…

You've been pranked into wearing ridiculous clothes to impress someone. Now you're locked in a dark room and someone in a priest's outfit is interrogating you about demons, insisting you're insane. Everyone outside is laughing. You try to defend yourself, but the more you protest, the crazier you sound.

Continue to 4.3 →