← 4.1
Act 4, Scene 2 — The same
on stage: —
Next: 4.3 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Adriana demands to know everything Luciana observed in her apparent husband's behaviour. When Luciana confesses that he declared his love for her, Adriana erupts — first with a catalogue of her husband's faults, then immediately walking it all back: she loves him more than she's saying, like a lapwing crying away from its nest to protect its chicks. Dromio of Syracuse bursts in with the arrest news — he has come straight from Antipholus E's instructions in 4-1 (though Adriana doesn't know he's the wrong Dromio). A series of quick exchanges about arrest, time, and debt follows before Luciana fetches the money. Adriana sends Dromio to pay bail and bring her husband home.
Enter Adriana and Luciana.
ADRIANA ≋ verse [anxious, jealously probing]

Ah, Luciana, did he tempt thee so?

Might’st thou perceive austerely in his eye

That he did plead in earnest, yea or no?

Look’d he or red or pale, or sad or merrily?

What observation mad’st thou in this case

Of his heart’s meteors tilting in his face?

Oh Luciana, did he try to seduce you that much? Could you tell from his expression whether he was pleading earnestly or not? Did he look flushed or pale, sad or cheerful? What did you notice about the way his emotions showed in his face?

So Luciana, did he really try it with you? Could you tell if he was being serious about it from his eyes? Did he look flushed, pale, happy, or sad? What was your read on him?

did he really try it was he serious what did his face say

""
""
Why it matters Adriana's opening question is telling: she doesn't ask what he said, she asks what his face showed. She wants to know if it was real. This is not a woman who simply wants ammunition against her husband — she wants to understand him.
↩ Callback to Act 3, Scene 2 This scene is a direct continuation of 3-2 from Adriana's perspective — she never witnessed what happened, only hears Luciana's account now.
🎭 Dramatic irony Adriana believes her husband propositioned Luciana. The audience knows: It was Antipholus of Syracuse, not Antipholus of Ephesus. Her husband never met Luciana. The man who wooed Luciana is a complete stranger who happens to share her husband's face. What the character does not know: Adriana has no idea there are two Antipholuses. Her jealousy and grief are entirely misdirected.
LUCIANA [hesitant to report it fully]

First he denied you had in him no right.

At first he denied that you had any claim on him.

First he said you didn't have any hold over him.

he said u had no claim on him

ADRIANA [bitterly hurt]

He meant he did me none; the more my spite.

He meant he didn't owe me anything; which makes me even angrier.

So he's saying he doesn't owe me anything—which just makes me madder.

he doesn't owe me nothing makes me so mad

LUCIANA [carefully recounting his words]

Then swore he that he was a stranger here.

Then he swore he was a stranger in this city.

Then he claimed he was a stranger here.

he said he was a stranger here

ADRIANA [bitterly ironic]

And true he swore, though yet forsworn he were.

And he was telling the truth about that, even though he's broken other oaths.

That's the only thing he told the truth about, even though he's lying about everything else.

he was right about that even tho he lied about everything else

""
Why it matters One of the play's best lines. Antipholus of Syracuse was genuinely a stranger — and Adriana correctly hears this as a repudiation of their marriage. Both readings are simultaneously true, for different reasons.
LUCIANA [recounting her plea for Adriana]

Then pleaded I for you.

Then I argued on your behalf.

Then I stuck up for you.

then i defended u

ADRIANA [anxiously eager to know]

And what said he?

And what did he say?

So what'd he say in response?

what'd he say

LUCIANA [reluctant, embarrassed confession]

That love I begg’d for you he begg’d of me.

He said that instead of showing you the love I asked him to have, he asked me for that love.

He said instead of giving you love like I asked, he wanted it from me.

he wanted love from me not from u

Why it matters This is the most delicate line Luciana could deliver to her sister. She is not gloating; she's reporting a fact as gently as possible. The line structure — 'love I begg'd for you he begg'd of me' — mirrors the exchange perfectly, amplifying the irony.
ADRIANA [jealous, probing question]

With what persuasion did he tempt thy love?

How did he try to win your affection?

How'd he try to get with you?

how'd he try to get u

LUCIANA ≋ verse [uneasily recalling his flattery]

With words that in an honest suit might move.

First he did praise my beauty, then my speech.

With words that would be persuasive in an honest courtship. First he praised my beauty, then my way of speaking.

With words that would work if he actually meant them. He complimented my looks, then the way I talk.

he said i was beautiful then praised my voice

""
ADRIANA [suspiciously testing her]

Did’st speak him fair?

Did you respond kindly to him?

Did you encourage him?

u encourage him

LUCIANA [trying to calm her sister]

Have patience, I beseech.

Please be patient with me.

Can you just let me finish?

chill, let me talk

ADRIANA ≋ verse [furious]

I cannot, nor I will not hold me still.

My tongue, though not my heart, shall have his will.

He is deformed, crooked, old, and sere,

Ill-fac’d, worse bodied, shapeless everywhere;

Vicious, ungentle, foolish, blunt, unkind,

Stigmatical in making, worse in mind.

I can't and won't stay quiet. My tongue, unlike my heart, will say what it wants. He's deformed, crooked, old and withered, ugly-faced, badly built, misshapen everywhere. He's mean, rude, foolish, blunt, and unkind, marked by vice in body and worse in mind.

I can't help it, I won't shut up. My tongue is going to say what my heart won't. He's twisted, old, decrepit, ugly, badly put together, just wrong everywhere. He's cruel, rude, stupid, tactless, and mean—his whole body is messed up but his mind is even worse.

i gotta say it he's ugly, old, mean totally twisted body AND mind

""
""
Why it matters Adriana's catalogue of her husband's faults is the emotional inverse of a love sonnet — each attribute is the dark mirror of what a lover would celebrate. And she knows she's lying, which is why she immediately takes it all back. The speech is grief performing as anger.
LUCIANA ≋ verse [gently reasoning with her]

Who would be jealous then of such a one?

No evil lost is wail’d when it is gone.

Who would be jealous over someone like that? No one mourns when something bad disappears.

Why would anyone be jealous of him? Nobody cries when evil goes away.

who'd be jealous of him no one misses evil

Why it matters Luciana's response is perfectly calibrated: she takes Adriana's insults at face value and draws the logical conclusion. The implication — 'if he's that bad, let me have him' — is left completely unstated but hangs in the air.
ADRIANA ≋ verse [torn between love and anger]

Ah, but I think him better than I say,

And yet would herein others’ eyes were worse:

Far from her nest the lapwing cries away;

My heart prays for him, though my tongue do curse.

But the truth is I think he's better than these words suggest. And I wish I saw him as badly as I'm making him sound. Like a lapwing crying away from her nest to protect it, my heart stays true to him even though my tongue curses him.

But actually I think better of him than I'm saying. I wish I could hate him as much as I sound like I do. My heart's loyal to him even though I'm tearing him apart with my words—like a mother bird calling away from where her nest really is.

he's better than i'm saying my heart's loyal but i curse him anyway

""
Why it matters This is the most honest moment Adriana has in the play. She knows exactly what she's doing — being a lapwing — and she names it. It's sophisticated self-awareness that makes her sympathetic rather than merely jealous. The lapwing image is one of Shakespeare's great metaphors for protective love.
Enter Dromio of Syracuse.
DROMIO OF SYRACUSE [frantically urging haste]

Here, go; the desk, the purse, sweet now, make haste.

Here, go. The desk, the purse—come on now, hurry.

Go get it—the desk, the money—come on, move!

go get the money hurry up

Why it matters Dromio S arrives having memorised Antipholus E's instructions. 'The desk, the purse' — but he bursts in so breathlessly that Luciana's first instinct is to ask about his health, not his news.
LUCIANA [concerned at his breathlessness]

How hast thou lost thy breath?

How did you lose your breath?

Why are you so out of breath?

why u so winded

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE [deadpan comic understatement]

By running fast.

By running fast.

By running fast.

By running fast.

ADRIANA [worried inquiry]

Where is thy master, Dromio? is he well?

Where's your master, Dromio? Is he all right?

Where's your master, Dromio? Is he okay?

where's your master is he ok

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE ≋ verse [wild, comic terror]

No, he’s in Tartar limbo, worse than hell.

A devil in an everlasting garment hath him,

One whose hard heart is button’d up with steel;

A fiend, a fairy, pitiless and rough;

A wolf, nay worse, a fellow all in buff;

A back-friend, a shoulder-clapper, one that countermands

The passages of alleys, creeks, and narrow lands;

A hound that runs counter, and yet draws dryfoot well,

One that, before the judgement, carries poor souls to hell.

No, he's in hell, or worse. An officer is holding him—someone with a hard heart, cruel and rough. Like a wolf, or worse—a man in a leather uniform. He's a false friend, an officer who arrests you when you least expect it. He blocks the passages through alleys and narrow streets. He's like a hunting dog that goes the wrong direction but still follows the trail, dragging poor souls to hell before judgment day.

No, he's in hell. An officer's got him—some guy with a heart of steel, totally merciless. Like a wolf, but worse. He's wearing that buff uniform and acting all official. He's a total fake, pops up out of nowhere to arrest you. He blocks all the back alleys and side streets. He's like a crazy hunting dog that goes backward but still catches you. He's dragging people to hell before they even get judged.

he's in hell an officer got him cruel guy in uniform no way out

""
""
""
""
Why it matters Dromio's description of a sergeant-bailiff is one of the play's great set speeches — a sustained metaphorical demolition of the officer of the law. Each image builds: devil, wolf, hound, hunter, carrier to hell. Shakespeare's audiences knew this figure well; debtors' prisons and their agents were familiar urban nightmares.
↩ Callback to Act 4, Scene 1 Dromio S's 'man all in buff' is the sergeant from 4-1 — the Officer who arrested Antipholus E at Angelo's instigation. The extended sergeant metaphor here is the scene-linking device.
ADRIANA [impatient for a straight answer]

Why, man, what is the matter?

What on earth is going on?

What's going on?

what happened

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE [evasive, punning deflection]

I do not know the matter. He is ’rested on the case.

I don't know the details. He's been arrested in the matter.

I don't know all the details. He got arrested over this whole thing.

arrested over the whole thing

""
ADRIANA [alarmed, demanding details]

What, is he arrested? Tell me at whose suit?

He's been arrested? Tell me who filed the suit against him.

He's arrested? Who sued him?

no who arrested him who sued

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE [still punning, dodging the question]

I know not at whose suit he is arrested, well;

But he’s in a suit of buff which ’rested him, that can I tell.

Will you send him, mistress, redemption, the money in his desk?

I don't know which lawsuit arrested him, but I can tell you he's wearing a buff uniform that's keeping him locked up. Will you send him bail, mistress? The money's in his desk.

I don't know whose suit—I mean lawsuit—he's in. But I know it's that buff uniform the officer's wearing that's got him stuck. Will you send him some bail money, ma'am? He said it's in his desk.

i dunno whose suit but the officer's got him send bail money

""
""
ADRIANA [directing]

Go fetch it, sister. This I wonder at,

Go get it, sister. This surprises me,

Go grab it. This is weird—

get the money this is wild

[_Exit Luciana._]
ADRIANA ≋ verse [puzzled, pressing for answers]

Thus he unknown to me should be in debt.

Tell me, was he arrested on a band?

So he's in debt without my knowledge? Tell me, was the arrest based on a bond?

How could he owe money and I wouldn't know about it? Was he arrested over some debt agreement?

he owes money i didn't know was it on a bond

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE ≋ verse [riddling, drawing out the joke]

Not on a band, but on a stronger thing;

A chain, a chain. Do you not hear it ring?

Not arrested by a band or ribbon, but by something stronger. A chain! A chain! Can't you hear it ringing?

Not some little band—something way worse. A chain! A chain! Can you hear it?

not a band a chain hear it ring

ADRIANA [confused, seizing on the word]

What, the chain?

What, the chain?

What, the chain?

What, the chain?

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE ≋ verse [playfully correcting her]

No, no, the bell, ’tis time that I were gone.

It was two ere I left him, and now the clock strikes one.

No, no, the bell—it's time I was leaving. It was two o'clock when I left him, and now the clock strikes one.

No, it's just the bell. It's time I got out of here. When I left him it was two, and now it's only one.

it's the bell i gotta go it was 2, now it's 1

ADRIANA [incredulous at his wordplay]

The hours come back! That did I never hear.

The hours are going backward? I've never heard of that.

Time's going backward? That's new to me.

time goes backward never heard that

DROMIO OF SYRACUSE [relishing his own joke]

O yes, if any hour meet a sergeant, ’a turns back for very fear.

Oh yes, any hour will turn back if it meets a sergeant—they're so frightening that even time runs away from them.

Oh yeah, if time meets up with a sergeant it runs the other way. Even hours are scared of them.

yeah time runs from sergeants even hours are scared

ADRIANA [exasperated at his logic]

As if time were in debt. How fondly dost thou reason!

As if time itself owed money. How foolishly you're reasoning!

Like time owes somebody money. You're being ridiculous.

like time's in debt lol u're trippin

""
DROMIO OF SYRACUSE [spinning an elaborate excuse]

Time is a very bankrupt, and owes more than he’s worth to season.

Nay, he’s a thief too. Have you not heard men say

That time comes stealing on by night and day?

If he be in debt and theft, and a sergeant in the way,

Hath he not reason to turn back an hour in a day?

Time is bankrupt and owes more than he's worth. He's also a thief—haven't you heard people say time steals everything? If time is in debt and guilty of theft, and a sergeant is in his way, doesn't he have good reason to turn back an hour?

Time's broke—broke and in debt. Plus he's a thief. You know how people say time steals everything? If time's poor and criminal and there's a sergeant after him, wouldn't he turn back just to avoid getting arrested?

time's broke and steals if a sergeant's looking time would run backward

""
""
Why it matters This exchange is Shakespeare at his most playful. The time-banter seems like digression but it holds a thematic point: in this play, time itself has gone wrong. Hours run backwards, things happen out of sequence, cause and effect are decoupled. Dromio is accidentally diagnosing Ephesus.
Enter Luciana.
ADRIANA ≋ verse [weary, oppressed by grief]

Go, Dromio, there’s the money, bear it straight,

And bring thy master home immediately.

Come, sister, I am press’d down with conceit;

Conceit, my comfort and my injury.

Go, Dromio, there's the money—take it right now and bring your master home as fast as you can. Come, sister. I'm weighed down by thoughts of him. My feelings about him are both my comfort and my pain.

Go, Dromio—here's the money. Take it and get your master back here immediately. Come on, sister. I'm crushed by all this—thinking about him is both what keeps me going and what's destroying me.

take the money get him home i'm torn up thinking about him

""
""
Why it matters The final couplet is quietly devastating. 'Conceit, my comfort and my injury' — the same thought that keeps Adriana functioning (she loves him, she'll fight for him) is also what's tearing her apart (her imagination shows her the worst). It's a line that captures the psychological reality of jealous love in four words.
🎭 Dramatic irony Adriana sends bail money with Dromio, expecting it to free her husband. The audience knows: Dromio S will deliver the money to Antipholus S — still the wrong twin. Antipholus E remains in prison (or custody). The bail money will do nothing to resolve the actual arrest. What the character does not know: Adriana has no idea she is sending the bail to the wrong man via the wrong servant.
[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

The scene serves two functions: emotional and logistical. The emotional work — Adriana's alternating fury and love — is the most psychologically complex writing in the play for any character. The lapwing image (a bird that cries away from its nest to distract predators) is a beautiful gloss on her own behaviour: she insults her husband loudly to protect the love she cannot quite express. The logistical work — Dromio arriving with arrest news, money fetched, bail sent — keeps the plot moving. The Dromio time-banter in the middle is Shakespeare's tonal palate-cleanser between those two jobs.

If this happened today…

Your sister comes home and tells you that your husband (who you've been furious at for days) was flirting with her. You immediately list every single flaw you've ever seen in him — ugly, old, rude, useless. Your sister points out that if he's that bad, maybe it's not worth being upset. And then you say: 'Yeah but I actually love him way more than I'm letting on. I'm just protecting myself.' Then the doorbell rings and it's his assistant saying he's been arrested. You shift from heartbreak to logistics in four seconds flat.

Continue to 4.3 →