← 3.2
Act 3, Scene 3 — The same. A street.
on stage: —
Next: 4.1 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument The poet Cinna, walking to Caesar's funeral with a premonition of danger, is stopped by the mob. He gives his name — Cinna — and is immediately set upon by citizens who confuse him with Cinna the conspirator. He pleads that he is a poet, not the other Cinna. The mob decides it doesn't matter: they will tear him for his bad verses if nothing else. He is killed.
Enter Cinna, the poet, and after him the citizens.
CINNA ≋ verse [uneasy, haunted by a bad omen]

I dreamt tonight that I did feast with Caesar,

And things unluckily charge my fantasy.

I have no will to wander forth of doors,

Yet something leads me forth.

Last night I dreamed I had a feast with Caesar, and bad omens are weighing on my imagination. I have no desire to go outside, yet something is driving me out the door.

I had this dream about feasting with Caesar last night, and now I've got this bad feeling stuck in my head. I don't even want to leave the house, but something's making me go anyway.

weird dream about caesar bad vibes stuck in my head dont wanna go out but something's pulling me

"I dreamt tonight that I did feast with Caesar" Shakespeare gives Cinna the exact warning that Caesar was given — a dream the night before — and Cinna ignores it for the same reasons Caesar did: he feels compelled forward by something he can't name. The parallel is precise and devastating.
Why it matters Cinna's opening speech is a micro-version of the play's whole pattern of ignored warnings. He knows something is wrong. He has a premonition. He goes out anyway. In fifteen lines he will be dead.
FIRST CITIZEN [suspicious, interrogating a stranger]

What is your name?

Tell us your name.

What's your name?

who r u

SECOND CITIZEN [pressing him, growing hostile]

Whither are you going?

Where are you going?

Where are you headed?

where u going

THIRD CITIZEN [terse, demanding answers]

Where do you dwell?

Where do you live?

Tell us where you're from.

where do u live

FOURTH CITIZEN [mocking, needling the stranger]

Are you a married man or a bachelor?

Are you married or single?

Got a wife, or are you free?

married or single

SECOND CITIZEN [impatient, pressing for answers]

Answer every man directly.

Answer each man directly.

Answer each of us straight up.

answer us straight

FIRST CITIZEN [curt, losing patience]

Ay, and briefly.

Yes, and be brief.

Yeah, and keep it short.

and keep it short

FOURTH CITIZEN [taunting, egging him on]

Ay, and wisely.

Yes, and be wise.

Yeah, and think before you speak.

and be smart

THIRD CITIZEN [veiled threat in his voice]

Ay, and truly, you were best.

Yes, and truly, you'd better do it.

Yeah, and honestly, you should just do it.

yeah u better

CINNA [nervously joking to appease them]

What is my name? Whither am I going? Where do I dwell? Am I a married

man or a bachelor? Then, to answer every man directly and briefly,

wisely and truly. Wisely I say I am a bachelor.

What is my name? Where am I going? Where do I live? Am I married or single? So, to answer each man directly, briefly, wisely and truthfully: wisely I say I am a bachelor.

What's my name? Where am I going? Where do I live? Am I married or single? Okay, to answer you all straight, quick, and honest: I'm single.

name? where going? where i live? married? straight answer: im a bachelor

Why it matters Cinna's careful echoing of their exact requirements — 'directly and briefly, wisely and truly' — is the behavior of someone trying to survive a frightening situation through scrupulous compliance. It is also faintly comic. And it is about to be completely useless.
SECOND CITIZEN [jeering, half-amused menace]

That’s as much as to say they are fools that marry; you’ll bear me a

bang for that, I fear. Proceed, directly.

That's the same as saying married people are fools; I'm afraid you'll hit me for that. Keep going, directly.

That's like saying people who marry are dumb, and I'm scared you're gonna punch me for it. Go on, keep talking straight.

so married ppl are fools? maybe punch me keep going tho

CINNA [anxious, trying to sound innocent]

Directly, I am going to Caesar’s funeral.

To give you a direct answer: I'm heading to Caesar's funeral.

Straight up, I'm going to Caesar's funeral.

going to caesars funeral

FIRST CITIZEN [sharp, testing his loyalty]

As a friend, or an enemy?

Are you going as a friend or as an enemy?

You heading there as someone who supports us or against us?

friend or enemy

CINNA [quick, hoping to reassure them]

As a friend.

As a friend.

As a friend.

as a friend

SECOND CITIZEN [grudgingly satisfied, still wary]

That matter is answered directly.

That question is answered directly.

Okay, that's a straight answer.

answered

FOURTH CITIZEN [brusque, pressing on]

For your dwelling, briefly.

As for where you live, tell us briefly.

And where do you live? Just tell us quickly.

where u live

CINNA [compliant, anxiety mounting]

Briefly, I dwell by the Capitol.

Briefly, I live by the Capitol.

I live near the Capitol.

capitol area

THIRD CITIZEN [demanding, closing in]

Your name, sir, truly.

Your name, sir, tell us truthfully.

Your name, sir, and be truthful.

your name

CINNA [fatally honest, unaware of danger]

Truly, my name is Cinna.

Truthfully, my name is Cinna.

It's Cinna, honestly.

im cinna

Why it matters He could have lied. He doesn't. He follows the injunction they gave him — 'truly' — and tells the truth. His honesty is what kills him.
🎭 Dramatic irony The crowd demanded truth — 'answer truly, you were best' — and Cinna answers with the exact truth. His truth kills him. The audience watches a man destroyed by honesty, knowing that a single lie ('My name is Marcus') would have saved him.
FIRST CITIZEN [erupting into violent mob fury]

Tear him to pieces! He’s a conspirator.

Rip him apart! He's one of the conspirators.

Tear him to shreds! He's with the conspirators!

tear him up hes a conspirator

Why it matters One word — 'Cinna' — is sufficient for the verdict, the sentence, and the execution. No trial. No verification. The name is the crime.
CINNA [desperately pleading his innocence]

I am Cinna the poet, I am Cinna the poet.

My name is Cinna, a poet! Cinna the poet, that's who I am!

I'm a poet! My name is Cinna! A poet!

im cinna the poet not a conspirator

"I am Cinna the poet, I am Cinna the poet" The repetition isn't rhetorical — it's panic. Cinna is saying the same thing twice because it isn't working the first time. This is the opposite of persuasion: words failing completely in real time.
Why it matters Cinna the poet is the play's most innocent victim — a man destroyed not for what he did but for what his name sounds like. His desperate repetition ('I am Cinna the poet, I am Cinna the poet') is one of Shakespeare's most quietly devastating moments: words that should save him, failing entirely.
↩ Callback to Act 3, Scene 2 This is 'mischief afoot' — Antony's two-line coda after the mob left. He called it by its name and released it. This scene is what it looks like when it arrives.
FOURTH CITIZEN [savagely mocking, bloodlust rising]

Tear him for his bad verses, tear him for his bad verses.

Tear him apart for his bad poetry, tear him apart for his bad poetry.

Rip him up for his terrible poems! Rip him up!

tear him for bad poetry

"Tear him for his bad verses" One of the darkest comic lines in Shakespeare. When the mob is told he's the wrong Cinna, they don't back down — they find a new charge. His poetry is bad, therefore he deserves death. The charge is absurd, the violence is real, and the joke makes it worse.
Why it matters This line reveals the deeper logic of mob violence: the mob doesn't actually need a legitimate reason, only a reason that sounds like a reason. 'Bad verses' is the citizen admitting that the original charge was wrong and inventing a replacement. The humor makes it more disturbing, not less.
CINNA [terrified, grasping at distinctions]

I am not Cinna the conspirator.

I'm not the Cinna who plotted against Caesar.

I'm not Cinna the conspirator!

wrong guy im just a poet

FOURTH CITIZEN [coldly indifferent to his innocence]

It is no matter, his name’s Cinna; pluck but his name out of his heart,

and turn him going.

It doesn't matter; his name is Cinna. Just tear the name Cinna out of his chest and send him on his way.

Doesn't matter. His name is Cinna. Just rip that name out of him and let him go.

doesnt matter hes cinna rip it out let him go

"It is no matter, his name's Cinna; pluck but his name out of his heart" The most chilling line in the scene — almost philosophical in its clarity about what mob justice is. The citizen isn't confused; he knows this is the wrong Cinna. He has decided it doesn't matter. The logic: the name 'Cinna' is associated with guilt; this man has that name; therefore this man is guilty. It is pure categorical violence.
Why it matters This is the scene's moral statement: in mob violence, the individual no longer exists. Only the category matters. 'Cinna' is the category; this man holds the name; the name condemns him. Shakespeare understands that most historical atrocities operate this way — not through individual hatred but through the erasure of the individual in favor of the label.
THIRD CITIZEN [whipping the mob toward arson]

Tear him, tear him! Come; brands, ho! firebrands. To Brutus’, to

Cassius’; burn all. Some to Decius’ house, and some to Casca’s, some to

Ligarius’. Away, go!

Tear him, tear him! Come on, get torches, get firebrands! Go to Brutus's house, to Cassius's house, burn it all! Some to Decius's house, some to Casca's, some to Ligarius's house. Let's go!

Tear him up! Get the torches! Get the fire! Go to Brutus's place, Cassius's place, burn everything! Some go to Decius's, some to Casca's, some to Ligarius's. Move!

tear him get torches get fire to brutus cassius decius casca ligarius burn it all go

Why it matters The mob ends with a complete list of conspirators' addresses — exactly the same names Artemidorus listed in his warning letter in 2-3. The names that Artemidorus tried to use to save Caesar are now being used by the mob to organize arson. The same information, inverted.
↩ Callback to Act 2, Scene 3 The mob's final list — Brutus, Cassius, Decius, Casca, Ligarius — is exactly the list in Artemidorus's warning letter. In 2-3, those names were evidence of a conspiracy to kill Caesar. Here, they are addresses for arson and murder. The same names, used by two opposite forces, for opposite purposes.
[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

This is the shortest scene in the play and one of the cruelest. Its job is to show what Antony's 'mischief afoot' actually looks like at ground level: the death of a completely innocent man for the crime of having the wrong name. The scene is darkly comic for a few lines — the mob's interrogation is almost bureaucratic — and then it is horrifying. Cinna the poet knows he is in danger, says his name anyway because he must, and is destroyed for it. The wrong Cinna dies. The right Cinna — the conspirator — will appear again later.

If this happened today…

A man named Harvey Weinstein — a teacher, completely unconnected to the producer — is walking down the street when a social media pile-on about the other Harvey Weinstein reaches fever pitch. Someone recognizes his name from a shared post. He explains repeatedly that he is a different Harvey Weinstein. The explanation makes no difference. The name is enough.

Continue to 4.1 →