← 4.6
Act 4, Scene 7 — London. Smithfield
on stage: —
Next: 4.8 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument After killing Matthew Gough at Smithfield, Cade orders the burning of legal records and proclaims himself parliament; then conducts a mock trial and executes Lord Saye and his son-in-law, parading their heads on poles.
Alarums. Matthew Gough is slain, and all the rest. Then enter Jack Cade
with his company.
CADE [gleefully ordering more destruction]

So, sirs. Now go some and pull down the Savoy; others to th’ Inns of

Court; down with them all.

So, my men. Now some of you go and tear down the Savoy; others go to the Inns of Court; tear them all down.

Alright, listen up. I want some of you to go tear down the Savoy, and others hit the Inns of Court. Destroy everything.

tear down the savoy and the inns of court tear it all down

DICK [playfully petitioning 'Lord' Cade]

I have a suit unto your lordship.

I have a request to make of your lordship.

I've got a favor to ask you, my lord.

i have a request for u

CADE [mockingly generous, playing the lord]

Be it a lordship, thou shalt have it for that word.

Be it a lordship, you shall have it just for saying that.

If it's a lordship you want, you've got it—just for asking.

u can have it whatever u want

DICK [absurdly demanding literal law from his mouth]

Only that the laws of England may come out of your mouth.

All I ask is that your orders become England's laws.

All I want is for your word to be the law in England.

make ur word the law

HOLLAND [punning grimly on Cade's wound]

[_Aside_.] Mass, ’twill be sore law, then; for he was thrust in the

mouth with a spear, and ’tis not whole yet.

Good Lord, that will be harsh law then; for he was stabbed in the mouth with a spear, and it hasn't fully healed.

Oh man, that'll be some tough law then. He got stabbed in the mouth with a spear and it's still not all the way healed.

that'll be harsh law he got stabbed in the mouth still healing

SMITH [joking crudely about his breath]

[_Aside_.] Nay, John, it will be stinking law, for his breath stinks

with eating toasted cheese.

No, John, it will be disgusting law, for his breath reeks from eating toasted cheese.

Nah man, it'll be revolting law. His breath stinks from eating toasted cheese all the time.

it'll be gross law his breath stinks from cheese

CADE [decreeing his own tyrannical law]

I have thought upon it, it shall be so. Away, burn all the records of

the realm. My mouth shall be the parliament of England.

I have considered it, and it shall be done. Go, burn all the records of the realm. My word will be the parliament of England.

I've thought about it, and that's exactly what we'll do. Now go burn all the official records of this kingdom. My command will be the only law in England.

burn all the records my word is the law now

"burn all the records of the realm. My mouth shall be the parliament of England" This is Cade's political program at its most logical and most terrifying: destroy the written record (which requires literacy to access) and replace institutional law with personal fiat. It's the anti-literacy program carried to its conclusion — in a purely oral polity, the man who speaks loudest rules.
Why it matters Cade's 'my mouth shall be the parliament of England' is the scene's most directly political line — a single sentence that abolishes all law, governance, and record-keeping and replaces them with one man's word.
HOLLAND [mocking pun on his rotten teeth]

[_Aside_.] Then we are like to have biting statutes, unless his teeth

be pulled out.

Then we're likely to have laws that cut harshly, unless his teeth are pulled out.

So we're gonna get some really biting laws unless we pull his teeth out.

we'll get harsh biting laws unless we pull his teeth

CADE [proclaiming utopian common ownership]

And henceforward all things shall be in common.

And from now on all things shall be shared by everyone.

And from now on, everything will belong to everybody.

everything belongs to everyone now

Enter a Messenger.
MESSENGER [excitedly announcing Saye's capture]

My lord, a prize, a prize! Here’s the Lord Saye, which sold the towns

in France; he that made us pay one-and-twenty fifteens, and one

shilling to the pound, the last subsidy.

My lord, we have captured him, we have captured him! Here's Lord Saye, who sold the towns In France; he who made us pay enormous taxes, Twenty-one times the fifteenth tax, and one shilling per pound in the last tax.

My lord, we got him! Here's Lord Saye, the one who sold off our towns In France. He's the one who squeezed us for outrageous taxes— Twenty-one times over, plus an extra shilling per pound.

we got saye he sold french towns he taxed us like crazy

Enter George Bevis with the Lord Saye.
CADE [mockingly indicting Saye's 'crimes']

Well, he shall be beheaded for it ten times. Ah, thou say, thou serge,

nay, thou buckram lord! Now art thou within point-blank of our

jurisdiction regal. What canst thou answer to my majesty for giving up

of Normandy unto Mounsieur Basimecu, the Dauphin of France? Be it known

unto thee by these presence, even the presence of Lord Mortimer, that I

am the besom that must sweep the court clean of such filth as thou art.

Thou hast most traitorously corrupted the youth of the realm in

erecting a grammar school; and whereas, before, our forefathers had no

other books but the score and the tally, thou hast caused printing to

be used, and, contrary to the King, his crown, and dignity, thou hast

built a paper-mill. It will be proved to thy face that thou hast men

about thee that usually talk of a noun and a verb, and such abominable

words as no Christian ear can endure to hear. Thou hast appointed

justices of peace, to call poor men before them about matters they were

not able to answer. Moreover, thou hast put them in prison, and because

they could not read, thou hast hanged them, when indeed only for that

cause they have been most worthy to live. Thou dost ride on a

foot-cloth, dost thou not?

Well, he deserves to be beheaded ten times over. You worthless merchant, you fake nobleman! Now you're within my reach. What can you say to answer for giving away Normandy to the Dauphin of France? Let it be known to you in my presence, in the presence of Lord Mortimer, that I Am the broom that will sweep this court clean of garbage like you. You have most treacherously corrupted the youth of the kingdom by building a grammar school; And whereas before our ancestors had only tally marks for records, You have introduced printing, and against the King's interests, you have built a paper mill. It will be shown that you have people around you who talk about nouns and verbs—words So foul no Christian can bear to hear them. You have appointed judges of the peace who haul poor men before them to answer questions They cannot understand. What's worse, you've thrown them in prison, and because they couldn't read, You've hanged them—when really only for being illiterate they should have been most fit to live. You ride on a fancy saddle cloth, don't you?

Well, he deserves to lose his head ten times. You worthless merchant, you fake nobleman! Now you're face to face with me. What do you have to say about giving away Normandy To the French Dauphin? Let me be clear about this—in my presence, before Lord Mortimer, I am the one who's going to clean out this corrupt court, and you're the garbage. You've corrupted our young people by building schools; Our grandfathers didn't have any books except account records, but you brought in printing, And against the King's honor, you built a paper factory. I've got proof you've got people around you who use fancy grammar terms—nouns and verbs— Words so disgusting no Christian should hear them. You've appointed judges who drag poor people to court to answer questions they don't understand. And when they throw them in prison and can't read the charges, you hang them— When actually being unable to read is the only reason they should have lived. You even ride on a horse with an expensive fancy cloth. Don't you?

u deserve to die u sold normandy u corrupted our youth with schools u brought printing and paper mills u use fancy grammar u appointed corrupt judges u hang illiterate people u ride fancy horses

"thou hast most traitorously corrupted the youth of the realm in erecting a grammar school" Grammar schools were the primary path to literacy and social mobility in Elizabethan England. Cade makes education itself a treasonous act — the most direct statement of his program's underlying logic: an illiterate population cannot resist legal and clerical exploitation, but it also cannot be corrupted by learning.
"because they could not read, thou hast hanged them, when indeed only for that cause they have been most worthy to live" Cade's most pointed paradox: men were hanged because they couldn't claim 'benefit of clergy' (literacy exemption from death penalty), which means literacy saved lives — but Cade inverts this, saying their illiteracy proved their worth. He has a real grievance about an unfair system and a monstrous solution.
SAYE [defiantly unbowed under accusation]

What of that?

What difference does that make?

So what?

so what

CADE [stoking class resentment against Saye]

Marry, thou ought’st not to let thy horse wear a cloak when honester

men than thou go in their hose and doublets.

Well, you shouldn't let your horse wear a cloak when more honest men than you wear only pants and shirts.

You shouldn't dress your horse better than decent people dress themselves— while better men than you are running around in just pants and shirts.

ur horse wears better clothes than honest people

DICK [proudly claiming common labor]

And work in their shirt too; as myself, for example, that am a butcher.

And work in just their shirts too; like me, for example—I'm a butcher.

And we work in just our shirts, like me here—I'm a butcher.

we work in just shirts like me i'm a butcher

SAYE [attempting to appeal to the crowd]

You men of Kent—

You people from Kent—

You people from Kent—listen up—

u kentish men

DICK [aggressively challenging his words]

What say you of Kent?

What are you saying about Kent?

What's wrong with Kent?

what u say about kent

SAYE [wry defiance even facing death]

Nothing but this; ’tis _bona terra, mala gens_.

Nothing but this: it's good land, but bad people.

Just this: it's good land, but the people there are terrible.

good land bad people

CADE [mocking outrage at his Latin]

Away with him, away with him! He speaks Latin.

Get rid of him, get rid of him! He speaks Latin.

Take him away, take him away! He's speaking Latin!

get him away he speaks latin

SAYE ≋ verse [eloquent, desperate plea for his life]

Hear me but speak, and bear me where you will.

Kent, in the Commentaries Caesar writ,

Is termed the civil’st place of all this isle.

Sweet is the country, because full of riches;

The people liberal, valiant, active, wealthy;

Which makes me hope you are not void of pity.

I sold not Maine, I lost not Normandy,

Yet to recover them would lose my life.

Justice with favour have I always done;

Prayers and tears have moved me, gifts could never.

When have I aught exacted at your hands

Kent to maintain the King, the realm, and you?

Large gifts have I bestowed on learned clerks,

Because my book preferred me to the King.

And seeing ignorance is the curse of God,

Knowledge the wing wherewith we fly to heaven,

Unless you be possessed with devilish spirits,

You cannot but forbear to murder me.

This tongue hath parleyed unto foreign kings

For your behoof—

Listen to me, and do with me as you will. Kent is written of as the most civilized place in all of this island in Caesar's Commentaries. The country is beautiful because it's full of wealth; the people are generous, brave, active, and rich; which makes me hope you have some pity. I didn't sell Maine, and I didn't lose Normandy, yet I would lose my life to recover them. I have always shown justice with mercy; prayers and tears have moved me, but never gifts. When have I ever demanded anything from you to maintain the King, the realm, and yourselves? I have given large gifts to learned scholars, because my education advanced me to the King's favor. Since ignorance is God's curse and knowledge is the wing with which we fly to heaven, unless you are possessed by devilish spirits, you cannot help but spare my life. This tongue has negotiated with foreign kings for your benefit—

Please, just listen to me, and then do what you want. Caesar wrote about Kent as the most civilized place in the entire island. It's a beautiful country, full of wealth, and the people are generous, brave, and strong—which makes me hope you have some compassion. I didn't sell Maine, and I didn't lose Normandy. I'd be willing to die to get those places back. I've always tried to be fair and merciful; I've been moved by people's prayers and tears, but never by bribes. Have I ever squeezed money out of you to pay for the King or the kingdom? No. I've given huge donations to educated people because my education got me ahead. And think about it: ignorance is a curse from God, but knowledge is what lets us reach heaven. So unless you're pure evil, you have to let me live. I've used my voice to negotiate with foreign kings for your own good—

kent is the best place in the world i didnt lose normandy i tried to be fair i helped foreign kings for u unless ur devils u cant kill me knowledge is divine

Why it matters Lord Saye's defense is the play's most eloquent speech in favor of education, good governance, and the rule of law — and it fails completely. Shakespeare gives the losing side the best argument.
CADE [dismissively mocking his courage]

Tut, when struck’st thou one blow in the field?

Nonsense! When did you ever strike one blow in battle?

Please! When have you ever fought in battle?

when did u ever fight

SAYE ≋ verse [proudly defending his indirect service]

Great men have reaching hands; oft have I struck

Those that I never saw, and struck them dead.

Powerful men have far-reaching power; often I have ordered strikes against enemies I never saw, and destroyed them.

Powerful men don't fight in person—I've ordered attacks on enemies I've never even seen, and destroyed them.

great leaders give orders not fight i've destroyed enemies i never saw

GEORGE [scornfully mocking his cowardice]

O monstrous coward! What, to come behind folks?

Oh, you're a terrible coward! You attack people from behind?

What a coward! You stab people in the back?

ur a coward u attack from behind

SAYE [wounded, defending his sleepless service]

These cheeks are pale for watching for your good.

These cheeks are pale from losing sleep worrying for your welfare.

I look pale because I've been up all night working for your benefit.

i'm pale from staying up for u

CADE [cruelly mocking his pale cheeks]

Give him a box o’ th’ ear, and that will make ’em red again.

Slap him on the ear, and that will make his cheeks red again.

Hit him in the face, and that'll put some color back in those cheeks.

punch him that'll make him red

SAYE ≋ verse [wearily pleading his failing health]

Long sitting to determine poor men’s causes

Hath made me full of sickness and diseases.

Sitting for long hours to judge poor men's cases has made me sick and diseased.

I've spent so much time sitting in court judging poor people's cases that I've gotten sick from it.

judging cases all day made me sick

CADE [grimly threatening him with hanging]

Ye shall have a hempen caudle then, and the help of hatchet.

Then you'll get a rope and the help of an ax to end your suffering.

Well, then we'll give you a rope to cure your sickness, and an ax to help.

we'll give u a rope and an ax

DICK [taunting his visible trembling]

Why dost thou quiver, man?

Why are you shaking, man?

Why are you trembling?

y u shaking

SAYE [proudly denying that he's afraid]

The palsy, and not fear, provokes me.

A nervous condition, not fear, is making me shake.

It's a medical condition, not fear, that's making me tremble.

it's a medical thing not fear

CADE [mockingly ordering his beheading]

Nay, he nods at us, as who should say, “I’ll be even with you.” I’ll

see if his head will stand steadier on a pole or no. Take him away, and

behead him.

No, he's nodding at us like he's saying 'I'll get revenge.' Let's see if his head will stand more steadily on a pole than it does now. Take him away and behead him.

Look, he's nodding at us like he's threatening revenge. Let's see how well his head balances on a pike. Take him away and cut off his head.

he's threatening us let's see how his head looks on a pole kill him

SAYE ≋ verse [desperate plea for his life]

Tell me, wherein have I offended most?

Have I affected wealth or honour? Speak.

Are my chests filled up with extorted gold?

Is my apparel sumptuous to behold?

Whom have I injured, that ye seek my death?

These hands are free from guiltless bloodshedding,

This breast from harbouring foul deceitful thoughts.

O, let me live!

Tell me, what is my greatest crime? Have I sought wealth or glory? Tell me. Are my chests overflowing with stolen gold? Is my clothing extravagant and ornate? Who have I harmed that you want me dead? These hands have never shed innocent blood, And this heart has harbored no foul, deceitful thoughts. Oh, please let me live!

Tell me what I've done wrong. Have I been greedy or power-hungry? Say it. Are my treasuries full of stolen money? Do I dress in fancy clothes? Who did I hurt that deserves death? I've never killed an innocent person, And I've never harbored evil intentions. Please, let me live!

what did i do wrong i didn't steal i didn't hurt anyone let me live

CADE [suppressing pity, then ordering execution]

[_Aside_.] I feel remorse in myself with his words, but I’ll bridle it.

He shall die, an it be but for pleading so well for his life. Away with

him! He has a familiar under his tongue; he speaks not i’ God’s name.

Go, take him away, I say, and strike off his head presently; and then

break into his son-in-law’s house, Sir James Cromer, and strike off his

head, and bring them both upon two poles hither.

I feel compassion for myself hearing his words, but I'll hold it back. He shall die, even if only for pleading so well for his life. Away with him! He has a demon spirit under his tongue; he doesn't speak in God's name. Go, take him away, I say, and strike off his head immediately; and then break into his son-in-law's house, Sir James Cromer, and strike off his head, and bring both of them on two poles here.

I feel some pity hearing what he's saying, but I'm gonna suppress it. He's gonna die, if only because he spoke so well for himself. Get him out of here! He's got a demon under his tongue doing the talking, not God. Take him away and cut off his head right now. Then break into his son-in-law's house, Sir James Cromer, cut off his head too, and bring both heads here on poles.

i feel bad for him but i'll suppress it he's gotta die for being so persuasive he's got a demon under his tongue behead him now get his son-in-law too put both heads on poles

🎭 Dramatic irony Cade's stated reason for executing Saye — 'for pleading so well for his life' — reveals the logical endpoint of his program: eloquence is treasonous because it might persuade. The most articulate man in the scene dies because he was too articulate.
ALL [eager mob compliance]

It shall be done.

It will be done.

We'll do it.

it's done

SAYE ≋ verse [resigned, appealing to their conscience]

Ah, countrymen, if when you make your prayers,

God should be so obdurate as yourselves,

How would it fare with your departed souls?

And therefore yet relent, and save my life.

Ah, my countrymen, if when you pray, God were as stubborn and unyielding as you are, How would it go for your souls after death? So please, change your minds and save my life.

Listen, people of my country, if God refused to listen to your prayers the way you're refusing to listen to me, How would your souls fare after death? So please, have mercy and let me live.

if god ignored your prayers like u ignore me how would ur souls fare have mercy

CADE [curtly dismissing his final plea]

Away with him! And do as I command ye.

Get him out of here! And carry out my orders!

Get him out of here! And do what I told you!

get him out do what i said

[_Exeunt some with Lord Saye._]
The proudest peer in the realm shall not wear a head on his shoulders
unless he pay me tribute; there shall not a maid be married but she
shall pay to me her maidenhead ere they have it. Men shall hold of me
_in capite;_ and we charge and command that their wives be as free as
heart can wish or tongue can tell.
DICK [eager to loot Cheapside]

My lord, when shall we go to Cheapside and take up commodities upon our

bills?

My lord, when will we go to Cheapside and seize goods by force?

My lord, when do we get to go to Cheapside and start looting?

when do we loot cheapside

CADE [casually granting the mob its plunder]

Marry, presently.

Well, immediately.

Right now.

right now

ALL [delighted at the promise of plunder]

O, brave!

Oh, excellent!

Yes, excellent!

yes

Enter one with the heads.
CADE [gleeful, macabre mockery of the dead]

But is not this braver? Let them kiss one another, for they loved well

when they were alive. Now part them again, lest they consult about the

giving up of some more towns in France. Soldiers, defer the spoil of

the city until night; for with these borne before us instead of maces

will we ride through the streets, and at every corner have them kiss.

Away!

But isn't this even better? Let them kiss each other, since they got along well when they were alive. Now separate them again, so they can't plot to give away more French towns. Soldiers, save your looting for the night; because with these bodies carried before us instead of ceremonial staffs, we will ride through the streets, And at every corner make them kiss each other. Let's go!

But isn't this even better? Let the heads kiss each other—they got along fine when they were alive. Now pull them apart so they can't conspire to lose more French towns. Soldiers, don't start looting yet—wait until tonight. First, we'll ride through the streets Carrying these heads on poles instead of fancy staffs, and at every corner, we'll make them kiss each other. Let's move!

even better let them kiss they got along ride through streets with their heads make them kiss at every corner

"Let them kiss one another, for they loved well when they were alive" Cade's final theatrical gesture — making the severed heads 'kiss' on poles — is the most grotesque moment in the scene, but it follows a horrible logic: in life, the connection between Saye and Cromer was their target (family ties that represented the corruption Cade claimed to oppose). In death, he makes that connection literally obscene.
Why it matters The image of Cade riding through London with severed heads on poles, made to 'kiss' at every corner, is the Cade sequence's most disturbing visual — and the point at which the comedy has definitively ended.
[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

This is the Cade sequence's darkest scene — and the one where the comedy stops protecting the audience. Lord Saye's defense of education and governance is genuinely eloquent, and Cade feels remorse (he says so, in an aside) before ordering the execution anyway. The scene ends with Cade making the severed heads kiss each other on poles. The grotesque theater of his rule is in full display, and the laughter has curdled into something else.

If this happened today…

The strongman who seized the capital is on live TV ordering the national archives burned, declaring his mouth the new parliament. A respected minister is dragged in — he's been building schools and running courts for thirty years. He speaks well. The strongman briefly feels it, then has him killed for speaking too well. The execution clip goes viral with the faces blurred, but the bodies are real.

Continue to 4.8 →