← 2.2
Act 2, Scene 3 — Rome. The Forum
on stage: —
Next: 3.1 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument In the Forum, Coriolanus appears in the gown of humility to petition the people for their votes. Citizens discuss whether they'll support him. When he appears, he makes brief individual requests but his contempt for the ritual bleeds through in asides. The people are wavering until Coriolanus finally speaks his true mind, insulting them openly. By the end, the tribunes have turned the crowd against him.
Enter seven or eight Citizens.
FIRST CITIZEN [Tentative acknowledgment of obligation]

Once, if he do require our voices, we ought not to deny him.

Once he asks for our votes, we're obligated not to refuse him.

If he asks for our votes, we pretty much have to give them to him.

if he asks we have to say yes

SECOND CITIZEN [Asserting free will; pushing back]

We may, sir, if we will.

We can refuse him if we want to, sir.

But we can say no if we want to.

we can refuse

THIRD CITIZEN [Logical paradox about obligation and gratitude]

We have power in ourselves to do it, but it is a power that we have no

power to do; for, if he show us his wounds and tell us his deeds, we

are to put our tongues into those wounds and speak for them. So, if he

tell us his noble deeds, we must also tell him our noble acceptance of

them. Ingratitude is monstrous, and for the multitude to be ingrateful

were to make a monster of the multitude, of the which we being members,

should bring ourselves to be monstrous members.

We have the power to do it, but in a way we don't. If he shows us his wounds and tells us his deeds, we're supposed to put our voices into those wounds and speak for them—meaning we owe him vocal support. If he tells us his noble deeds, we must tell him our noble approval. To be ungrateful would be monstrous, and if the crowd were ungrateful, it would make the crowd itself monstrous—and since we're part of the crowd, we'd make ourselves monstrous members.

We can do it, but we can't—you know? If he shows us his scars and talks about what he did, we're supposed to use our voices to back him up in return. If he tells us his great deeds, we have to tell him we appreciate them. Being ungrateful would be sick, and it would turn all of us into sick people—monsters—since we're part of the crowd.

we can but can't if he shows wounds we owe him our voices ungrateful = monstrous

FIRST CITIZEN [Recalling past contempt; hardening resolve]

And to make us no better thought of, a little help will serve; for once

we stood up about the corn, he himself stuck not to call us the

many-headed multitude.

And to keep us feeling worse about ourselves, a small reminder will do: when we stood up about the grain shortage, he himself didn't hesitate to call us the many-headed mob.

And just so we remember how he really feels, when we complained about food prices, he straight-up called us a mindless mob.

when we complained about grain he called us the many-headed mob

THIRD CITIZEN [Self-deprecating humor; explaining the 'many-headed' insult]

We have been called so of many; not that our heads are some brown, some

black, some auburn, some bald, but that our wits are so diversely

coloured; and truly I think if all our wits were to issue out of one

skull, they would fly east, west, north, south, and their consent of

one direct way should be at once to all the points o’ th’ compass.

We've been called that by many—not that our heads are different colors, brown or black or auburn or bald, but that our minds are so diversely directed. Truly, if all our minds came out of one skull, they'd fly east, west, north, south—our agreement would scatter to all compass points at once.

Yeah, people call us that—not because of our hair color, but because our thoughts go in a million directions. Honestly, if all our brains came out of one head, they'd scatter in every direction at once—north, south, east, west.

many-headed not hair color our thoughts scatter east west north south

SECOND CITIZEN [Testing; joking, pulling the speaker deeper]

Think you so? Which way do you judge my wit would fly?

What do you think? Which direction do you imagine my wit would go?

You think so? So where do you reckon my mind would head?

where would my mind go then?

THIRD CITIZEN [Vicious wit directed at the questioner]

Nay, your wit will not so soon out as another man’s will; ’tis strongly

wedged up in a blockhead. But if it were at liberty, ’twould, sure,

southward.

Your wit won't escape as quickly as another man's—it's wedged too firmly in a blockhead. But if it could get out, it would go south, I think.

Yours would take forever to get out because it's stuck in a thick skull. But if it did, it'd head south.

stuck in blockhead would go south

SECOND CITIZEN [Curious; walking into the trap]

Why that way?

Why that way?

Why south?

why

THIRD CITIZEN [Cruel punch line; the speaker lands the joke]

To lose itself in a fog, where being three parts melted away with

rotten dews, the fourth would return for conscience’ sake, to help to

get thee a wife.

To lose itself in a fog, where being three parts melted away by rotten dampness, the fourth part would return for conscience's sake—to help you find a wife.

To get lost in a swamp where it'd rot away, and the tiny bit that's left would come back just to do charity work: finding you a wife.

get lost in fog melt away come back to get you a wife

SECOND CITIZEN [Defeated; playing along]

You are never without your tricks. You may, you may.

You never stop with your jokes. Go ahead, you can if you want.

You always have a quip. Fine, say what you want.

you always joke go ahead

THIRD CITIZEN [Returning to seriousness; summarizing the group's position]

Are you all resolved to give your voices? But that’s no matter; the

greater part carries it. I say, if he would incline to the people,

there was never a worthier man.

Are you all ready to give him your votes? Doesn't matter—the majority will decide. But I say, if he would just be favorable to the people, there was never a worthier man.

Are we all voting for him? Doesn't matter, the majority wins anyway. But honestly, if he'd just be nice to the people, he'd be the best.

we vote for him majority decides if he'd be nice he'd be the best

Enter Coriolanus in a gown of humility, with Menenius.
THIRD CITIZEN [briskly directing the citizens' approach]

Here he comes, and in the gown of humility. Mark his behaviour. We are

not to stay all together, but to come by him where he stands, by ones,

by twos, and by threes. He’s to make his requests by particulars,

wherein everyone of us has a single honour in giving him our own voices

with our own tongues. Therefore follow me, and I’ll direct you how you

shall go by him.

Here he comes, wearing the robe of humility. Pay attention to how he behaves. We shouldn't all approach him together, but in small groups—ones, twos, and threes at a time. He has to ask for votes individually, and each of us gets the honor of giving our own vote with our own voice. So follow me, and I'll show you how to approach him.

Here he is, dressed in that humble robe. Watch how he acts. We can't all mob him at once—we'll go in small groups, one or two or three at a time. He wants to ask us individually for our votes, and it gives each of us a chance to see he cares about our support. Come on, I'll show you the way.

here he comes in humble robe watch him go in small groups he asks for votes one at a time follow me i'll show u

ALL [readily agreeing to the plan]

Content, content.

Content, content.

Content, content.

content, content.

🎭 Dramatic irony The citizen offers Coriolanus their love; Coriolanus responds in an aside that their love 'tastes false in my mouth' and wishes them plague. They give him what he asks for, and he curses them for it. By 5-3, he's leading an army against them because of exactly this kind of rejection.
[_Exeunt._]
MENENIUS ≋ verse [gently reproving his refusal to beg]

O sir, you are not right. Have you not known

The worthiest men have done’t?

Sir, I'm surprised. Haven't the most respected men done this before?

Sir, I'm confused. Doesn't every decent man do this?

havent good men done this before?

CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [disgusted at the words he must speak]

What must I say?

“I pray, sir”—plague upon’t! I cannot bring

My tongue to such a pace. “Look, sir, my wounds!

I got them in my country’s service when

Some certain of your brethren roared and ran

From th’ noise of our own drums.”

What should I say? 'I beg you, sir'—I hate this! I can't make my tongue work this way. 'Look, sir, at my wounds! I got them fighting for my country, while some of your own people screamed and ran from the sound of our own drums.'

What am I supposed to say? 'Please, sir'—ugh, I can't do this! 'Look at my wounds, sir. I got them defending our country while your people were running and screaming from our own soldiers.'

what do i say? i got these wounds for you guys while your people ran from our own drums

MENENIUS ≋ verse [alarmed, hastily correcting him]

O me, the gods!

You must not speak of that. You must desire them

To think upon you.

My god, don't mention that! You must ask them to think well of you instead.

Don't do that! You need to make them think you're great.

dont do that. make them think ur good

CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [spitting contempt for the crowd's memory]

Think upon me! Hang ’em!

I would they would forget me, like the virtues

Which our divines lose by ’em.

Think of me! Forget them! I'd rather they'd forget me, the way they abandon the virtues their clergy teaches.

Forget about them! I wish they'd forget me just like they forget all those virtues their priests talk about.

id rather they forget me like they forget everything good

MENENIUS ≋ verse [exasperated, giving up on coaching him]

You’ll mar all.

I’ll leave you. Pray you speak to ’em, I pray you,

In wholesome manner.

You'll ruin everything. I'm leaving you now. Please, I'm asking you, speak to them properly and respectfully.

You're going to ruin this. I'm going to leave. Please, just talk to them decently.

ur gonna ruin this. talk to them right

[_Exit Menenius._]
CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [sneering contempt disguised as instruction]

Bid them wash their faces

And keep their teeth clean.

Tell them to wash their faces and brush their teeth.

Just tell them to wash up and brush their teeth.

tell them to wash and brush teeth

Enter three of the Citizens.
CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [curtly going through the motions]

So, here comes a brace.

You know the cause, sirs, of my standing here.

So, here comes a pair of you. You know why I'm standing here, sirs.

Alright, here come a couple of you. You know what this is about, right?

here come two of u—u know y i'm here

THIRD CITIZEN [plainly prompting him to explain]

We do, sir. Tell us what hath brought you to’t.

Yes, sir. Tell us what brought you to ask for this office.

Yeah, sir. Tell us why you want this job.

why do u want consul?

CORIOLANUS [curtly proud, refusing to beg]

Mine own desert.

What I've earned through my own achievements.

What I've earned for myself.

what i earned

SECOND CITIZEN [taken aback, echoing his boast]

Your own desert?

Your own achievements?

You earned it yourself?

u earned it?

CORIOLANUS [grudgingly qualifying his pride]

Ay, but not mine own desire.

Yes, but not because I actually want it.

Yeah, but I don't really want it myself.

but i dont really want it

THIRD CITIZEN [puzzled by his odd distinction]

How, not your own desire?

What? You don't really want it?

What do you mean you don't really want it?

you dont want it?

CORIOLANUS [stiffly distancing himself from begging]

No, sir, ’twas never my desire yet to trouble the poor with begging.

No, sir. I've never wanted to beg from poor people for office.

No. I've never liked asking poor people to vote for me.

i dont like begging from poor ppl

THIRD CITIZEN [bluntly naming the transactional terms]

You must think if we give you anything, we hope to gain by you.

You should understand that if we give you our support, we expect to gain something from you.

You should know that if we're voting for you, we expect you to do something for us.

u gotta do something for us in return

CORIOLANUS [mockingly haggling like a merchant]

Well then, I pray, your price o’ th’ consulship?

So what's the price of this position? What do you want from me?

So what's the going rate? What do you want?

whats the price then?

FIRST CITIZEN [earnestly naming the simple price]

The price is to ask it kindly.

The price is simply to ask for it politely.

Just ask nicely.

be polite when asking

CORIOLANUS [forcing courtesy through clenched teeth]

Kindly, sir, I pray, let me ha’t. I have wounds to show you, which

shall be yours in private.—Your good voice, sir. What say you?

Politely, sir? Fine, then. I have wounds to show you privately. Give me your vote, sir. What do you say?

Nicely, sir? Okay then. I've got wounds I can show you privately. Give me your vote. What do you think?

ok i got wounds to show. vote for me?

SECOND CITIZEN [sincerely granting his voice]

You shall ha’ it, worthy sir.

You'll have it, worthy sir.

You got my vote, sir.

u got my vote

CORIOLANUS [brusquely dismissing the transaction]

A match, sir. There’s in all two worthy voices begged. I have your

alms. Adieu.

It's a deal, sir. That's two good votes I've earned. I have what I came for. Goodbye.

Deal, sir. That's two votes. I got what I wanted. See you later.

good. two votes. bye

THIRD CITIZEN [uneasily sensing something amiss]

But this is something odd.

That's pretty strange behavior, though.

That's actually pretty weird.

thats kinda weird tho

SECOND CITIZEN [quietly having second thoughts]

An ’twere to give again—but ’tis no matter.

Well, if we had to do it again—but it doesn't matter now.

Yeah, if we had to vote again—but whatever.

if we did it again maybe different

[_Exeunt two citizens._]
Enter two other Citizens.
CORIOLANUS [wearily reciting the ritual plea]

Pray you now, if it may stand with the tune of your voices that I may

be consul, I have here the customary gown.

I ask you now: if your votes will permit it, I would like to be consul. I have here the proper gown for it.

If you guys are okay with it, I'd like to be your consul. I've got the gown.

if u vote for me ill wear the gown

FOURTH CITIZEN [posing a pointed riddle to test him]

You have deserved nobly of your country, and you have not deserved

nobly.

You've earned great honor for your country, and you haven't earned it.

You've earned real glory for the country, and you also haven't.

u earned honor and u didnt?

CORIOLANUS [impatiently demanding the riddle's point]

Your enigma?

Your enigma?

Your enigma?

your enigma?

FOURTH CITIZEN [explaining the accusation pointedly]

You have been a scourge to her enemies; you have been a rod to her

friends. You have not indeed loved the common people.

You've been a weapon against our enemies; you've been a weapon against our friends. You've never truly loved the common people.

You've beaten our enemies, but you've also beaten our friends. You don't actually care about regular people.

u beat enemies and friends. u dont love us

CORIOLANUS [twisting the insult into mock virtue]

You should account me the more virtuous that I have not been common in

my love. I will, sir, flatter my sworn brother, the people, to earn a

dearer estimation of them; ’tis a condition they account gentle. And

since the wisdom of their choice is rather to have my hat than my

heart, I will practise the insinuating nod and be off to them most

counterfeitly. That is, sir, I will counterfeit the bewitchment of some

popular man and give it bountiful to the desirers. Therefore, beseech

you, I may be consul.

You should think of me as better because I haven't been common in my affection. I will, sir, flatter my sworn brother, the people, to gain more respect from them—it's something they consider polite. Since their wisdom prefers to see my hat rather than know my heart, I will practice the fake friendly nod and behave most falsely to them. That is, I will pretend to be like some popular politician and distribute fake warmth generously. Therefore, I ask you, let me be consul.

You should respect me more because I don't go around loving everyone equally. I'll butter up the people, my supposed brothers, to get more respect—that's what they think is nice. Since they'd rather see my hat than understand my heart, I'll smile and nod like a fake politician and pretend to like everyone. So please, let me be consul.

im more virtuous cuz i havent faked love i can fake it tho for consul please vote for me

FIFTH CITIZEN [hopefully granting his voice]

We hope to find you our friend, and therefore give you our voices

heartily.

We hope to find you as our ally, and so we give you our votes freely.

We hope you'll be on our side, and that's why we're voting for you.

we hope ur our friend so we vote for u

FOURTH CITIZEN [prompting him to prove his service]

You have received many wounds for your country.

You've suffered many wounds for your country.

You've been wounded a lot for us.

u got hurt for us

CORIOLANUS [curtly refusing to display his wounds]

I will not seal your knowledge with showing them. I will make much of

your voices and so trouble you no farther.

I won't prove it by showing them. I'll value your votes greatly and won't trouble you any further.

I'm not going to show you my scars. I'm grateful for your votes and I'll let you go.

wont show scars. thanks for votes. bye

BOTH CITIZENS [warmly wishing him joy]

The gods give you joy, sir, heartily.

The gods bless you, sir, truly.

May the gods bless you, sir, sincerely.

gods bless u

[_Exeunt citizens._]
CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [seething with self-disgust at the charade]

Most sweet voices!

Better it is to die, better to starve,

Than crave the hire which first we do deserve.

Why in this wolvish toge should I stand here

To beg of Hob and Dick that does appear

Their needless vouches? Custom calls me to’t.

What custom wills, in all things should we do’t?

The dust on antique time would lie unswept

And mountainous error be too highly heaped

For truth to o’erpeer. Rather than fool it so,

Let the high office and the honour go

To one that would do thus. I am half through;

The one part suffered, the other will I do.

Such wonderful voices! Better to die, better to starve, than to have to beg for the very honor I've already earned. Why should I stand here in this common cloak begging Hob and Dick for their meaningless endorsements? Custom demands this. But should we follow custom in everything? Then the wisdom of ancient times would be buried, and massive errors would tower too high for truth to see over. Rather than act like a fool this way, let that high office and honor go to someone willing to do it. I'm halfway through; I've suffered half of this, and I'll finish the other half.

What wonderful votes! It's better to die, better to starve, than to beg for honors I've already earned in war. Why am I standing here in this cheap cloak begging ordinary people for their worthless approval? This is just how it's done. But should we keep doing everything the old way? Then ancient wisdom would be forgotten and huge mistakes would tower over the truth. I'd rather not make a fool of myself like this. Let someone else who's willing to do it take the job. I've done the hard part, and I can do this part too.

id rather die than beg for what i earned but ok im half done i can finish this

Enter three Citizens more.
CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [mockingly hammering the word 'voices']

Here come more voices.

Your voices! For your voices I have fought;

Watched for your voices; for your voices bear

Of wounds two dozen odd. Battles thrice six

I have seen and heard of; for your voices have

Done many things, some less, some more. Your voices!

Indeed, I would be consul.

Here come more of you seeking to vote. Your votes! For your votes I have fought; waited for your votes; for your votes I bear two dozen wounds. I've been in eighteen battles or heard about them; for your votes I've done many things, some less important, some more. Your votes! I truly do want to be consul.

Here comes another group looking for votes. Your votes! I've fought for your votes, waited for your votes, I'm carrying all these wounds for your votes. I've been in battle after battle for your votes. Done all kinds of things—some big, some small—all for your votes. Your votes! Yeah, I genuinely want to be consul.

more ppl for votes i fought for ur votes bleeding for ur votes battle after battle whatever it takes for ur votes i want to be consul

SIXTH CITIZEN [approvingly vouching for his merit]

He has done nobly, and cannot go without any honest man’s voice.

He's earned great honor, and no honest person could refuse to vote for him.

He's done amazingly, and any good person would vote for him.

he earned it. any honest guy would vote

SEVENTH CITIZEN [enthusiastically endorsing his election]

Therefore let him be consul. The gods give him joy, and make him good

friend to the people!

So let him be consul. May the gods give him happiness and make him care about the people!

So make him consul. May the gods make him happy and make him love us!

make him consul. may he care about us

ALL THREE CITIZENS [joyfully hailing the new consul]

Amen, amen. God save thee, noble consul.

Yes, yes. God protect you, noble consul.

Yes, yes. God bless you, great consul.

yes. bless u consul

[_Exeunt citizens._]
CORIOLANUS [relieved the ordeal is finally over]

Worthy voices!

Worthy voices!

Worthy voices!

worthy voices!

Enter Menenius with Brutus and Sicinius.
MENENIUS ≋ verse [formally confirming the process complete]

You have stood your limitation, and the Tribunes

Endue you with the people’s voice. Remains

That in th’ official marks invested, you

Anon do meet the Senate.

You've completed the required process, and the Tribunes grant you the people's voice. Now you must go meet the Senate.

You've done what you need to do, and we're giving you the people's vote. Now go meet the Senate.

u got the votes. go meet senate

CORIOLANUS [eager disbelief that it's finished]

Is this done?

Is this done?

Is this done?

is this done?

SICINIUS ≋ verse [coolly formal, masking his resentment]

The custom of request you have discharged.

The people do admit you, and are summoned

To meet anon upon your approbation.

You've fulfilled the custom of asking. The people accept you, and they've been called to meet when you're approved.

You've done the traditional thing. The people accept you, and they'll meet when you're confirmed.

ppl accept u. theyll meet when u approved

CORIOLANUS [brisk question, ready to move on]

Where? At the Senate House?

Where? In the Senate House?

The Senate building?

at the senate?

SICINIUS [curtly confirming the place]

There, Coriolanus.

There, Coriolanus.

There, Coriolanus.

there, coriolanus.

CORIOLANUS [impatient to shed the humble gown]

May I change these garments?

Can I change out of these clothes?

Can I get out of these clothes?

can i change?

SICINIUS [flatly granting permission]

You may, sir.

You may, sir.

You may, sir.

you may, sir.

CORIOLANUS ≋ verse [relieved to feel himself again]

That I’ll straight do and, knowing myself again,

Repair to th’ Senate House.

I'll do that right away and, once I'm dressed properly, go to the Senate House.

I'll change right now and head to the Senate House.

ill change and go

MENENIUS [warmly offering his company]

I’ll keep you company.—Will you along?

I'll go with you. Will you come along?

I'll keep you company. You coming?

ill come with u

BRUTUS [coolly holding back to work the crowd]

We stay here for the people.

We're staying here for the people.

We're staying here with the people.

we stay here

SICINIUS [curtly dismissive, scheme already forming]

Fare you well.

Goodbye.

Take care.

bye

[_Exeunt Coriolanus and Menenius._]
SICINIUS ≋ verse [sneering at his secret pride]

He has it now; and by his looks, methinks,

’Tis warm at his heart.

He has it now; and from the look on his face, I'd say it warms his heart.

He's got what he wanted now; and the way he's looking, you can tell he's happy about it.

he got it looks happy

BRUTUS ≋ verse [contemptuous of his false humility]

With a proud heart he wore

His humble weeds. Will you dismiss the people?

He wore his humble clothes with a proud heart. Will you send the people away?

He wore that humble outfit like he was king. Should we dismiss the people?

he wore it with pride. dismiss them?

Enter the Pebleians.
SICINIUS [probing the crowd's true feelings]

How now, my masters, have you chose this man?

So, common folk, have you chosen this man?

So, people, did you pick this guy?

so u picked him?

FIRST CITIZEN [plainly reporting the vote]

He has our voices, sir.

He has our votes, sir.

He's got our votes.

he got our votes

BRUTUS [insincerely planting a seed of doubt]

We pray the gods he may deserve your loves.

We pray the gods grant that he deserves your affection.

We hope the gods make him worthy of your love.

hope he deserves ur love

SECOND CITIZEN ≋ verse [uneasily voicing his suspicion]

Amen, sir. To my poor unworthy notice,

He mocked us when he begged our voices.

Yes, sir. From my understanding, he mocked us when he was asking for our votes.

Yeah, sir. To me, he was making fun of us while asking for our votes.

he mocked us when asking

THIRD CITIZEN [indignantly agreeing he was mocked]

Certainly, he flouted us downright.

For sure, he insulted us directly.

Yeah, he definitely insulted us.

total disrespect

FIRST CITIZEN [defending his blunt manner]

No, ’tis his kind of speech. He did not mock us.

No, that's just his way of speaking. He didn't mock us.

No, that's just how he talks. He wasn't mocking us.

no its just how he talks

SECOND CITIZEN ≋ verse [pressing the charge of scorn]

Not one amongst us, save yourself, but says

He used us scornfully. He should have showed us

His marks of merit, wounds received for’s country.

Everyone except you is saying he treated us with contempt. He should have shown us his wounds—his battle scars earned for his country.

Everyone but you says he was rude to us. He should have shown us his scars from fighting for us.

everyone says he was mean. should show scars

SICINIUS [feigning certainty to stoke their doubt]

Why, so he did, I am sure.

Well, that's what I'm sure he did.

Well, that's what he definitely did.

yeah he did do that

ALL [realizing they'd been played]

No, no. No man saw ’em.

No, no. Nobody saw them.

No way. Nobody actually saw his wounds.

no one saw them

THIRD CITIZEN ≋ verse [mimicking his words with scorn]

He said he had wounds, which he could show in private,

And with his hat, thus waving it in scorn,

“I would be consul,” says he; “aged custom,

But by your voices, will not so permit me;

Your voices therefore.” When we granted that,

Here was “I thank you for your voices. Thank you.

Your most sweet voices! Now you have left your voices,

I have no further with you.” Was not this mockery?

He said he had wounds which he could show in private, and waving his hat in mockery, he said 'I would be consul,' he said; 'custom requires I follow this tradition, but with your votes; your votes therefore.' When we agreed to that, he said 'I thank you for your votes. Thank you. Your most wonderful voices! Now that you've given your votes, I'm done with you.' Wasn't that mocking?

He said he had wounds he could show privately. Then he waved his hat like he was joking and said 'I want to be consul, but only because of your votes; so, give me your votes.' Then when we did, he was like 'Thanks for your votes. Thanks. Wonderful votes! Now that you've voted, I'm done with you.' Wasn't that making fun of us?

he mocked us: 'ill show wounds privately' 'give me ur votes' then 'thanks bye. done with u' thats mocking

SICINIUS ≋ verse [scolding their naive generosity]

Why either were you ignorant to see’t

Or, seeing it, of such childish friendliness

To yield your voices?

Why either didn't you notice it, or, seeing it, were you so simple-minded that you'd just go along with it?

So either you're blind, or you saw it and were too dumb to care?

so u didnt see or didnt care?

BRUTUS ≋ verse [rebuking their missed opportunity]

Could you not have told him

As you were lessoned? When he had no power,

But was a petty servant to the state,

He was your enemy, ever spake against

Your liberties and the charters that you bear

I’ th’ body of the weal; and, now arriving

A place of potency and sway o’ th’ state,

If he should still malignantly remain

Fast foe to th’ plebeii, your voices might

Be curses to yourselves. You should have said

That as his worthy deeds did claim no less

Than what he stood for, so his gracious nature

Would think upon you for your voices, and

Translate his malice towards you into love,

Standing your friendly lord.

Couldn't you have told him, as we instructed you? When he was powerless and just a servant to the state, he spoke against your rights and freedoms. Now that he's reached a position of power and influence in government, if he remains hostile to the common people, your votes could become curses against yourselves. You should have said that his worthy deeds demand his gracious nature will think of you for your votes, and he'll turn his hostility toward you into friendship, becoming your loyal leader.

Why didn't you tell him what we taught you? When he was nobody, he was against you. Now he has power. If he stays your enemy, your votes will hurt you. You should have told him his great deeds mean his good nature will remember you favorably, and he'll stop hating you and start helping you.

why didnt u use what we taught u? he was against u when weak now hes strong. he'll still hate u. you should've made him promise to help

SICINIUS ≋ verse [laying out the strategy they bungled]

Thus to have said,

As you were fore-advised, had touched his spirit

And tried his inclination; from him plucked

Either his gracious promise, which you might,

As cause had called you up, have held him to;

Or else it would have galled his surly nature,

Which easily endures not article

Tying him to aught. So putting him to rage,

You should have ta’en th’ advantage of his choler

And passed him unelected.

If you'd said that, as we prepared you to, you would have tested his spirit and seen his true feelings. You might have gotten his sincere promise, which you could later hold him to. Or else it would have angered his stubborn nature, which doesn't tolerate conditions. By making him angry this way, you should have taken advantage of his rage and voted against his election.

If you'd said what we told you, you would have seen what he's really like. You might have gotten him to promise something to you, or you could have made him so mad that he'd refuse and you wouldn't have voted for him.

if u said it hed promise or hed get mad and refuse either way better than voting yes

BRUTUS ≋ verse [pressing home their foolishness]

Did you perceive

He did solicit you in free contempt

When he did need your loves, and do you think

That his contempt shall not be bruising to you

When he hath power to crush? Why, had your bodies

No heart among you? Or had you tongues to cry

Against the rectorship of judgment?

Did you see that he was asking you with total contempt when he needed your votes? Don't you think that his contempt will crush you when he has power to do it? Why, didn't you have any heart? Or did you lose the ability to think clearly?

You saw he was treating you like dirt while asking for your help, right? You think that's going to change now that he's got power? Didn't you have any sense at all?

he disrespected u asking for votes wont he crush u when powerful? where was ur brain?

SICINIUS ≋ verse [accusing them of backward generosity]

Have you ere now denied the asker, and now

Again, of him that did not ask but mock,

Bestow your sued-for tongues?

Haven't you refused people before who asked politely? Now you're giving your hard-won vote to someone who didn't ask but mocked you?

Haven't you refused people who asked nicely before? Now you're voting for a guy who made fun of you?

u refused nice ppl before now voting for a mocker?

THIRD CITIZEN ≋ verse [seizing on a chance to refuse him]

He’s not confirmed.

We may deny him yet.

He hasn't been confirmed yet. We can still deny him.

He's not confirmed yet. We can still vote against him.

hes not confirmed yet. we can deny

SECOND CITIZEN ≋ verse [vowing to rally votes against him]

And will deny him.

I’ll have five hundred voices of that sound.

And we will deny him. I'll get five hundred votes like ours to do it.

And we will. I can get five hundred people to vote against him.

we will. i got 500 votes against

FIRST CITIZEN [topping him with an even bigger number]

I twice five hundred, and their friends to piece ’em.

I have double that many, plus their supporters.

I've got a thousand, plus all their friends.

i got 1000 plus support

BRUTUS ≋ verse [urgently dispatching them to spread alarm]

Get you hence instantly, and tell those friends

They have chose a consul that will from them take

Their liberties, make them of no more voice

Than dogs that are as often beat for barking

As therefore kept to do so.

Go right now and tell your allies they've chosen a consul who will strip away their liberties, make them voiceless like dogs that are beaten as often for barking as they're kept to do it.

Go right now and tell your friends they've picked a consul who's going to take away their rights. He'll silence them like dogs—they get hit whether they bark or not.

tell ppl they chose a consul whos gonna take rights and silence them like beaten dogs

SICINIUS ≋ verse [coaching them to twist the story]

Let them assemble

And, on a safer judgment, all revoke

Your ignorant election. Enforce his pride

And his old hate unto you. Besides, forget not

With what contempt he wore the humble weed,

How in his suit he scorned you; but your loves,

Thinking upon his services, took from you

Th’ apprehension of his present portance,

Which most gibingly, ungravely, he did fashion

After the inveterate hate he bears you.

Let them meet and think this over carefully, then take back your vote. Remember his pride and his old hatred for you. Also, don't forget how scornfully he wore the humble gown, how he treated your request for votes with contempt. But your affection for his service made you overlook how he's actually behaving now, which he's performed in a mocking, ungraceful way that comes from the deep hatred he's always had for you.

Let them gather and reconsider and change your votes. Think about his arrogance and how much he hates you. Remember how much he hated wearing that humble outfit and how rude he was when you asked him for votes. You only voted for him because you remembered his service, but you're ignoring how he's really acting—all fake and disrespectful and full of his hatred for you.

gather up and change ur votes remember his pride and hate he wore the gown with contempt he disrespected u remember that not just his service

BRUTUS ≋ verse [offering himself as a convenient scapegoat]

Lay

A fault on us, your tribunes, that we laboured,

No impediment between, but that you must

Cast your election on him.

Blame it on us, your tribunes, that we didn't prevent you from voting for him without obstruction.

Blame us, the tribunes. We should have stopped you from voting for him.

blame us. we should have stopped u

SICINIUS ≋ verse [scripting the excuse for them]

Say you chose him

More after our commandment than as guided

By your own true affections, and that your minds,

Preoccupied with what you rather must do

Than what you should, made you against the grain

To voice him consul. Lay the fault on us.

Say you chose him more because we ordered you than because you truly wanted to. Say your minds were so focused on what you had to do that you acted against your own nature to vote for him consul. Blame us for it.

Say you only voted for him because we told you to, not because you wanted to. Say you were forced to vote against what you actually believe. Blame us.

say u voted cuz we ordered u not ur real choice blame us

BRUTUS ≋ verse [feeding them more of the cover story]

Ay, spare us not. Say we read lectures to you,

How youngly he began to serve his country,

How long continued, and what stock he springs of,

The noble house o’ th’ Martians, from whence came

That Ancus Martius, Numa’s daughter’s son,

Who, after great Hostilius here was king,

Of the same house Publius and Quintus were,

That our best water brought by conduits hither;

And Censorinus, that was so surnamed,

And nobly named so, twice being censor,

Was his great ancestor.

Yes, don't hold back. Say we gave you lectures about how young he was when he started fighting for Rome, how long he's served, what noble family he comes from—the Martian house, which gave us Ancus Martius, Numa's grandson, who became king after the great Hostilius. From that same house came Publius and Quintus, who built the water systems that bring water here to us. And Censorinus, who was honored for it, served twice as censor and was his great ancestor.

Yes, go ahead. Say we told you he started fighting young, served a long time, and comes from a great family—the Martians. That's Numa's grandson's family, who was king, and from them came the guys who built the water systems we use. Censorinus served as censor twice and was his ancestor.

we told u hes from great family ancestors built water systems his ancestors were important

SICINIUS ≋ verse [wrapping up the manufactured narrative]

One thus descended,

That hath beside well in his person wrought

To be set high in place, we did commend

To your remembrances; but you have found,

Scaling his present bearing with his past,

That he’s your fixed enemy, and revoke

Your sudden approbation.

One from such a distinguished line, who has also proven himself through his deeds and earned a position of power and influence, we recommended to your remembrance. But when you look at his past accomplishments and compare them to his current behavior, you can see he's your permanent enemy. Withdraw your sudden approval now.

We recommended someone from such an important family, someone who's earned power. But when you look at who he really is now compared to what he's done, you see he hates you. Change your vote.

we said hed earned it but looking at him now vs his past he hates u. take back vote

BRUTUS ≋ verse [hurrying them off to finish the plot]

Say you ne’er had done’t—

Harp on that still—but by our putting on.

And presently when you have drawn your number,

Repair to th’ Capitol.

Say you never did it—keep saying that—except that we pushed you into it. Once you've gathered your number, go to the Capitol.

Say you never would have done it except we forced you. Get everyone together and go to the Capitol.

say we forced u. gather up and go to capitol

ALL ≋ verse [regretfully agreeing to recant]

We will so. Almost all

Repent in their election.

We will. Most everyone regrets their vote now.

We will. Almost everyone's changing their mind.

we will. most regret voting yes

[_Exeunt Plebeians._]
BRUTUS ≋ verse [coldly calculating the risk worth taking]

Let them go on.

This mutiny were better put in hazard

Than stay, past doubt, for greater.

If, as his nature is, he fall in rage

With their refusal, both observe and answer

The vantage of his anger.

Let them go on with this. It's better to risk this uprising now than to wait for a much bigger one later. If he reacts with rage to their refusal, as his nature would have him do, both watch carefully and respond to his anger. Take advantage of his temper.

Let them do this. It's better to deal with this problem now than to wait for something worse later. If he gets angry when they refuse, which he probably will, watch him and use his anger against him.

let them do it now better than waiting for worse if he rages use his anger

SICINIUS ≋ verse [quietly satisfied at engineering the revolt]

To th’ Capitol, come.

We will be there before the stream o’ th’ people,

And this shall seem, as partly ’tis, their own,

Which we have goaded onward.

Let's go to the Capitol. We'll get there before the crowd, and this will look like it came from them, which in a way it did—but we've secretly pushed them there.

Let's head to the Capitol. We'll beat them there, so it'll look like they started this—even though we've been steering them all along.

go to capitol. well get there first so it looks like theyre doing it

[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

Scene 2-3 is the play's hinge: the moment Coriolanus's refusal to perform humility becomes active contempt, and the moment the tribunes successfully deploy that contempt against him. The citizens are inclined to give him their votes out of respect for his service. The tribunes don't change their minds — Coriolanus does it himself, by speaking exactly what he thinks. This is the play's crucial observation: the people aren't inherently against him, but they have tribunes who know how to turn their gratitude into resentment by showing them his disdain.

If this happened today…

A war hero appears at a town hall wearing a suit instead of his uniform. He's supposed to say a few gracious things, shake hands, thank them for their support. But he keeps muttering asides — 'this gown is stupid,' 'I hate this room,' 'why are these people here' — loud enough for them to hear. The crowd hears his contempt through the flattery. By the time he speaks openly, they're angry. He lost a sure thing by being honest about how much he despises the process.

Continue to 3.1 →