Sonnet 69

The young man's outward beauty is universally praised, yet when people examine his inner character through his actions, they find his reputation contradicted—his beauty suggests virtue, but his behavior hints at base nature ('thou dost common grow').

Original

Modern

1 Those parts of thee that the world’s eye doth view,

The parts of you that the world's eye sees,

2 Want nothing that the thought of hearts can mend:

lacks nothing that people's thoughts could improve,

want: lack; thought of hearts: deepest desires, ideals.

3 All tongues, the voice of souls, give thee that due,

All voices, speaking from the heart, give you your due,

all tongues: everyone; voice of souls: authentic expression of the deepest self.

4 Uttering bare truth, even so as foes commend.

Speaking plain truth—even enemies admire you.

bare truth: plain, unadorned truth; foes commend: enemies praise.

5 Thy outward thus with outward praise is crowned,

Your outer self is crowned with outer praise,

6 But those same tongues that give thee so thine own,

But those same voices that give you your due,

7 In other accents do this praise confound

in other contexts spoil and twist this praise

in other accents: in other contexts, with other voices; confound: undermine, contradict.

8 By seeing farther than the eye hath shown.

by seeing deeper than appearance has revealed.

Volta The volta shifts from external praise to internal scrutiny: 'They look into the beauty of thy mind, / And that in guess they measure by thy deeds.'

9 They look into the beauty of thy mind,

They examine the beauty of your mind,

10 And that in guess they measure by thy deeds,

and they estimate that by looking at your actions,

in guess: by guessing, by inference; measure: judge, assess.

11 Then churls their thoughts (although their eyes were kind)

Then their thoughts turn crude (although their eyes were gentle),

churls: base, mean people; their eyes were kind: their vision was favorable.

12 To thy fair flower add the rank smell of weeds:

Fair flower with the rank smell of weeds beneath

they add the stink of weeds to your beautiful flower,

fair flower: your beautiful appearance; rank smell of weeds: low, base nature.

13 But why thy odour matcheth not thy show,

But why your real self doesn't match your appearance,

odour: essential nature, character; show: appearance.

14 The soil is this, that thou dost common grow.

The revelation that the young man has become common

The reason is that you've become common and ordinary.

soil: cause, reason; dost common grow: are becoming common, lowborn; lose nobility.

The Gap Between Appearance and Essence

Sonnet 69's central mechanism is the distinction between 'outward' and 'mind,' between what the 'eye hath shown' and what is 'farther' than the eye can see. The sonnet's first half unifies appearance and judgment—the world's praise matches the world's vision. Yet the volta introduces a psychologically devastating reversal: those very people who praise externally simultaneously form different judgments internally. Their 'thoughts' become 'churls' (base, lowborn), contradicting their 'eyes' which 'were kind.' This split consciousness—kind eyes, churlish thoughts—describes the experience of seeing beauty undermined by behavior. The young man's appearance remains perfect ('thy fair flower'), but his deeds introduce discord into perception, forcing the speaker and others to hold contradictory assessments simultaneously.

The Smell of Corruption

The metaphor of odor—'thy odour matcheth not thy show'—is particularly effective because smell is involuntary and visceral. One cannot choose what to smell the way one can choose what to praise aloud. The image suggests that beneath the visual beauty (flower) lies something base and corrupting (rank weeds). Yet the couplet's diagnosis—'thou dost common grow'—is ambiguous. Does 'common' mean he is becoming common, or does it mean he is frequenting common places and people? The suggestion of promiscuity or degradation lurks beneath the surface. His beauty remains transcendent, but something essential—his character, his behavior, his essence—has become debased, 'common,' ordinary. This loss of aristocratic distinction is more devastating to reputation than physical aging would be.

If this happened today

Like when someone is stunningly beautiful but then you discover through their actions that they're mean, vain, or shallow. People overlook a lot because of looks, but once behavior is known, beauty becomes complicated. He's gorgeous but 'common.'

← Sonnet 68 All Sonnets Sonnet 70 →