← 5.1
Act 5, Scene 2 — The same. A room in the Duke’s palace
on stage: —
Next: 5.3 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Thurio pesters Proteus for Silvia's opinion of him, and Proteus serves up polite evasions while the disguised Julia mocks Thurio in asides. The Duke bursts in: Silvia has fled toward Mantua with Eglamour to find Valentine. All three men, and Julia, ride after her, each for a different reason.
Enter Thurio, Proteus and Julia.
THURIO [Proteus's lackey, asking about progress with Silvia]

Sir Proteus, what says Silvia to my suit?

Sir Proteus, is Silvia responding to my marriage proposal?

So is Silvia warming up to my proposal or what?

is silvia into me

PROTEUS ≋ verse [Proteus lying smoothly, betraying both Thurio and Julia]

O, sir, I find her milder than she was,

And yet she takes exceptions at your person.

Well, sir, she seems nicer than before, but she still finds problems with everything about you.

She's being warmer, but honestly she's got issues with you.

she's softening but she hates everything about you

THURIO [Thurio mishearing, thinking about his physical appearance]

What? That my leg is too long?

You mean to say my leg is too long?

What? You mean my leg is too long?

wait my leg is too long?

PROTEUS [Proteus twisting the knife]

No, that it is too little.

No, too short.

Too short.

nope too short

THURIO [Thurio immediately accepting fashion advice]

I’ll wear a boot to make it somewhat rounder.

I'll wear a boot with a thick heel to make my leg look thicker.

I'll get a chunky boot then.

i'll wear a boot make it look thicker

JULIA [bitterly certain Silvia scorns him]

[_Aside_.] But love will not be spurred to what it loathes.

[Aside.] But love cannot be forced toward what it despises.

[Aside.] But you can't make love work with someone it hates.

[to self] can't force love to like what it hates

THURIO [Thurio still trying to understand what Silvia wants]

What says she to my face?

What does she say about my face?

What's her opinion on my face?

what about my face?

PROTEUS [Proteus complimenting while scheming]

She says it is a fair one.

She says you have a handsome face.

She says you're good-looking.

she says you're handsome

THURIO [Thurio contradicting the compliment, honest about himself]

Nay, then, the wanton lies; my face is black.

No, she's lying. My face is dark—I'm not handsome at all.

Come on, I'm dark-skinned. I'm not good-looking.

nah i'm not pretty i'm too dark

PROTEUS ≋ verse [Proteus inverting the insult into compliment]

But pearls are fair; and the old saying is,

“Black men are pearls in beauteous ladies’ eyes.”

But pearls are white and beautiful, and the old saying is that dark men are like pearls to beautiful ladies.

But pearls are valuable and beautiful, and people say dark skin is like pearls to women.

pearls are beautiful and dark men are pearls to beautiful women

JULIA ≋ verse [mocking Proteus's flattery under her breath]

[_Aside_.] ’Tis true, such pearls as put out ladies’ eyes,

For I had rather wink than look on them.

[Aside.] True, such pearls as damage ladies' eyes, for I would rather close my eyes than look at them.

[Aside.] Sure, pearls that actually hurt ladies' eyes - I'd rather shut my eyes than look at him.

[to self] pearls that hurt eyes. id rather not look

THURIO [Thurio trying every angle to win Silvia]

How likes she my discourse?

How does she like the way I talk?

Does she like how I talk?

does she like my voice

PROTEUS [Proteus delivering another insult disguised as advice]

Ill, when you talk of war.

Poorly, when you talk about war.

Not great when you talk about war.

not when you talk war

THURIO [Thurio misunderstanding, thinking he has a chance]

But well when I discourse of love and peace.

But she likes it well when I talk about love and peace.

But she probably enjoys it when I talk about love and peace.

i'm good at talking love and peace

JULIA [cutting him down under her breath]

[_Aside_.] But better, indeed, when you hold your peace.

[Aside.] But better, truly, when you remain silent.

[Aside.] Better yet when you just stay quiet.

[to self] better when ur silent

THURIO [Thurio trying one more attribute]

What says she to my valour?

What does she say about my bravery?

What does she think about my courage?

what about my bravery?

PROTEUS [Proteus reassuring him with false hope]

O, sir, she makes no doubt of that.

Oh, she's not worried about that.

She's not questioning that.

no doubts there

JULIA [contemptuous, exposing his cowardice]

[_Aside_.] She needs not, when she knows it cowardice.

[Aside.] She need not, since she knows it is cowardice.

[Aside.] She doesn't need to doubt when she already knows he's a coward.

[to self] she knows he's a coward

THURIO [Thurio moving to his social status]

What says she to my birth?

What does she say about my family background?

What does she say about my origins?

what about my family?

PROTEUS [Proteus giving genuine praise]

That you are well derived.

That you come from a good family.

That you're from good stock.

you're from a good family

JULIA [biting pun on his 'good breeding']

[_Aside_.] True, from a gentleman to a fool.

[Aside.] Indeed, his lineage runs from an honorable ancestor to this ridiculous man.

[Aside.] Right, from a nobleman down to this complete idiot.

[to self] from nobleman to this fool

THURIO [Thurio asking about his wealth]

Considers she my possessions?

Does she think about my wealth?

Is she impressed by my money?

what about my wealth

PROTEUS [Proteus with a cutting joke]

O, ay, and pities them.

Oh yes, and she feels sorry for you.

Yeah, she pities you for it.

yeah she pities you

THURIO [Thurio confused by the pity]

Wherefore?

Pities me? Why?

She pities my money?

why does she pity me

JULIA [scornful aside at Thurio's vanity]

[_Aside_.] That such an ass should owe them.

[Aside.] That such a fool should own them.

[Aside.] That an idiot like him should own anything at all.

[to self] that such a fool owns things

PROTEUS [Proteus: your wealth is rented, not owned]

That they are out by lease.

Because it's only temporary—you're renting it, not owning it.

Because you're renting everything—you don't actually own it.

because you're renting not owning

JULIA [Julia spotting the Duke approaching]

Here comes the Duke.

The Duke is coming here.

The Duke is approaching.

the duke's coming

Enter Duke.
DUKE ≋ verse [Duke brusquely asking after Eglamour]

How now, Sir Proteus! How now, Thurio!

Which of you saw Sir Eglamour of late?

How are you both? Has anyone seen Sir Eglamour recently?

Hey you two. Anyone seen Eglamour?

have you seen eglamour

THURIO [Thurio denying knowledge]

Not I.

I haven't.

Not me.

no

PROTEUS [Proteus also denying, lying]

Nor I.

Neither have I.

Me neither.

me neither

DUKE [The Duke getting to his real question]

Saw you my daughter?

Have you seen my daughter?

What about Silvia?

what about your daughter

PROTEUS [Proteus lying directly about Silvia]

Neither.

Neither.

Nope.

no

DUKE ≋ verse [The Duke realizing the truth]

Why then, she’s fled unto that peasant Valentine,

And Eglamour is in her company.

’Tis true, for Friar Lawrence met them both

As he in penance wandered through the forest;

Him he knew well, and guessed that it was she,

But, being masked, he was not sure of it.

Besides, she did intend confession

At Patrick’s cell this even, and there she was not.

These likelihoods confirm her flight from hence.

Therefore, I pray you, stand not to discourse,

But mount you presently and meet with me

Upon the rising of the mountain foot

That leads toward Mantua, whither they are fled.

Dispatch, sweet gentlemen, and follow me.

Then she must have run away to that peasant Valentine, and Eglamour is with her. It's true, because Friar Lawrence met them both as he wandered through the forest doing penance; he recognized Eglamour, and guessed it was her, but being masked, he couldn't be certain of it. Besides, she was supposed to go to confession at Patrick's cell this evening, and she was not there. These clues confirm her flight from here. Therefore, I ask you, don't waste time talking, but get on your horses immediately and meet me where the mountain road rises toward Mantua, where they have fled. Hurry, gentlemen, and follow me.

So she's run off with that peasant Valentine, and Eglamour went with them. It's definitely true—Friar Lawrence saw them both in the forest while he was doing penance. He recognized Eglamour and figured it was her, but couldn't be sure because she was wearing a mask. She was supposed to go to confession at Patrick's cell tonight, but she never showed up. All this proves she's definitely escaped. So don't sit here talking about it—get on your horses right now and meet me where the road goes up the mountain toward Mantua, where they've gone. Move fast and come with me.

she ran away w valentine eglamour w them too friar lawrence saw them she was masked so he wasnt sure she missed confession tonight so shes def gone get ur horses now meet me on mountain road 2 mantua hurry

[_Exit._]
THURIO ≋ verse [Thurio angry and moralistic about Silvia's escape]

Why, this it is to be a peevish girl

That flies her fortune when it follows her.

I’ll after, more to be revenged on Eglamour

Than for the love of reckless Silvia.

This is what happens when a stubborn girl throws away her luck. She had a good chance with me and she's throwing it away. I'm going after her to get revenge on Eglamour.

This is ridiculous. She had a great guy and she threw it away. I'm gonna catch her and get back at Eglamour.

stupid girl throwing away her chance i'm going after them get revenge on eglamour

[_Exit._]
PROTEUS ≋ verse [Proteus claiming he's going for revenge but really for Silvia]

And I will follow, more for Silvia’s love

Than hate of Eglamour that goes with her.

And I'll follow too, more because I love Silvia than because I hate Eglamour.

I'm going too—but honestly more for Silvia than to get at Eglamour.

i'm going too for silvia more than revenge on eglamour

[_Exit._]
JULIA ≋ verse [Julia as a boy, voicing her real motives]

And I will follow, more to cross that love

Than hate for Silvia, that is gone for love.

And I'll follow, more to stop that love than because I hate Silvia, though she's gone for love.

I'm going too—to break up whatever's happening between them more than anything else.

i'm going to stop this love thing more than anything

[_Exit._]

The Reckoning

A short comic interlude snaps into a chase that launches the play toward its forest climax. The first half is a fool's interrogation: Thurio fishes for compliments about his legs, face, talk and fortune, and Proteus gives double-edged answers while Julia, disguised as his page, slips in sharp asides that say what everyone thinks. Then the Duke's news of Silvia's flight scatters them. Notice the closing triplet of exits. Thurio goes for revenge, Proteus for love, Julia to wreck that love. Each speech mirrors the one before it, so the lines show the play's love triangle almost as a formula, and send everyone into the forest.

If this happened today…

Your rich, clueless roommate keeps asking the friend who set him up whether his crush likes him. Does she like my hair? My jokes? The friend tells him soothing half-truths, while you, sitting on the couch, mutter what she really thinks. Then her dad calls in a panic: she has left town with a friend to go find her ex. Everyone grabs their car keys at once. The roommate wants to settle a score, the friend wants the girl for himself, and you want to stop him.

Continue to 5.3 →