← prev
Act 1, Scene 1 — London. A street
on stage: —
Next: 1.2 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Richard, Duke of Gloucester, reveals his plan to destroy his brother Clarence and clear his path to the throne, then greets the newly freed Hastings with false warmth.
Enter Richard, Duke of Gloucester, alone.
First appearance
RICHARD

Richard speaks in two registers simultaneously: polished public performance and brutal private honesty. Watch for how he shifts from warm, elaborate courtesy to blunt villainy the moment he's alone — the gap between the two is where his genius lives.

RICHARD ≋ verse [Bitter resentment masked as wicked charm. Richard turns his exclusion into ambition, his ugliness into focus.]

Now is the winter of our discontent

Made glorious summer by this son of York;

And all the clouds that loured upon our house

In the deep bosom of the ocean buried.

Now are our brows bound with victorious wreaths,

Our bruised arms hung up for monuments,

Our stern alarums changed to merry meetings,

Our dreadful marches to delightful measures.

Grim-visaged war hath smoothed his wrinkled front;

And now, instead of mounting barbed steeds

To fright the souls of fearful adversaries,

He capers nimbly in a lady’s chamber

To the lascivious pleasing of a lute.

But I, that am not shaped for sportive tricks,

Nor made to court an amorous looking-glass;

I, that am rudely stamped, and want love’s majesty

To strut before a wanton ambling nymph;

I, that am curtailed of this fair proportion,

Cheated of feature by dissembling nature,

Deformed, unfinished, sent before my time

Into this breathing world scarce half made up,

And that so lamely and unfashionable

That dogs bark at me as I halt by them—

Why, I, in this weak piping time of peace,

Have no delight to pass away the time,

Unless to spy my shadow in the sun,

And descant on mine own deformity.

And therefore, since I cannot prove a lover

To entertain these fair well-spoken days,

I am determined to prove a villain,

And hate the idle pleasures of these days.

Plots have I laid, inductions dangerous,

By drunken prophecies, libels, and dreams,

To set my brother Clarence and the King

In deadly hate the one against the other;

And if King Edward be as true and just

As I am subtle, false, and treacherous,

This day should Clarence closely be mewed up

About a prophecy which says that “G”

Of Edward’s heirs the murderer shall be.

Dive, thoughts, down to my soul. Here Clarence comes.

Peace has come to our side after the war ended through this son of York, and all the troubles for our family are buried away. Now we wear crowns for victory instead of carrying weapons. War has changed from being a fearful thing to playful entertainment in ladies' chambers. But I'm not made for love and flirtation. I'm deformed, incomplete, sent into the world half-finished and so misshapen that dogs bark at me. In this peaceful time, I have no way to enjoy myself except to look at my twisted shadow and think about my deformity. Since I can't be a lover, I've decided to become a villain instead and hate these peaceful times. I've made plots to turn my brother Clarence and the King against each other through prophecies and rumors. If the King is as just as I am cunning and false, Clarence should be locked up because of a prophecy saying someone whose name starts with G will murder the King's heirs.

Now that the war is over and this son of York has brought us peace, our side is happy. All the bad times for our family are gone. Now we get to wear victory crowns instead of carrying weapons. War has turned from something dangerous into something fun and playful. But I can't enjoy any of that because I'm deformed. I was born twisted and incomplete, sent into the world before I was finished, so warped that dogs bark when they see me. In this peaceful time, there's nothing I can do for fun except look at my twisted reflection and think about how ugly I am. Since I can't be a lover like these other guys, I'm going to be a bad guy instead. I hate these peaceful times. I've been working on plots to turn my brother Clarence and the King against each other, using fake prophecies and rumors. If the King is as honest as I am sneaky and false, Clarence should be arrested because there's a prophecy that someone with a name starting with G will kill the King's heirs.

peace came but i'm too deformed to enjoy it i decided to become a villain instead i've been plotting to turn my brother & the king against each other a prophecy says someone named G will kill the king's heirs

"Now is the winter of our discontent" The most famous opening line in Shakespeare. 'Our' is key — Richard speaks as a Yorkist, but the irony is that everyone else IS happy; only Richard is discontented. He appropriates collective language for deeply personal grievance.
"this son of York" Pun: 'son' = both son (Edward IV, son of the Duke of York) and 'sun' — the sun was the heraldic badge of the house of York. Shakespeare loves this pun, used throughout the history plays.
"mewed up" Literally to 'mew up' means to cage a hawk during molting season — to confine. The hawk image recurs: eagles and hawks are noble birds; kites and buzzards are lesser predators.
"About a prophecy which says that "G"" Richard has manufactured a prophecy that 'G' will disinherit Edward's heirs. 'G' stands for George (Clarence's first name) — but also for Gloucester, Richard's title. The trap he sets for his brother conceals a second G.
Why it matters This is one of the great opening speeches in all literature — Richard announces his villainy directly to the audience, making them his confidants, before the play has even formally begun. The theatrical tradition of the Vice character from medieval morality plays stands behind it, but Shakespeare has supercharged the convention: Richard isn't just wicked, he's brilliant, funny, and more honest with us than with anyone else in the play.
🎭 Dramatic irony Richard tells us 'G' of Edward's heirs the murderer shall be — and the G is also Gloucester, his own title. The trap he sets for Clarence points also at himself, a secret the audience holds throughout the play.
Enter Clarence, guarded and Brakenbury.
RICHARD ≋ verse [feigned surprise masking foreknowledge]

Brother, good day. What means this armed guard

That waits upon your Grace?

Brother, good day. What's the meaning of this armed guard that accompanies you?

Hey, brother. What's the deal with all these armed guards? Why do you have an escort?

brother why are guards with you

First appearance
CLARENCE

Clarence is trusting, even credulous — he accepts Richard's concern at face value, never suspecting the man who imprisoned him is his brother. His speech is straightforward and unguarded, which makes his fate all the more devastating.

CLARENCE ≋ verse [Innocent and resigned. Clarence accepts his fate without suspicion, unaware that his brother created it.]

His Majesty,

Tend’ring my person’s safety, hath appointed

This conduct to convey me to the Tower.

His Majesty, being concerned for my safety, has arranged for these guards to take me to the Tower.

The King is worried about my safety, so he's sent these guys to take me to the Tower.

the king's sending me to the tower for my own safety

RICHARD [Feigned surprise masking deep involvement.]

Upon what cause?

For what reason?

Why?

why?

CLARENCE [Resignation expressed as absurdity. Clarence cannot believe his arrest is real.]

Because my name is George.

The reason is simply that my name happens to be George.

It's because I'm named George.

cuz my name is george

RICHARD ≋ verse [Theatrical sympathy, setting up the trap. Richard performs concern while the conspiracy tightens.]

Alack, my lord, that fault is none of yours.

He should, for that, commit your godfathers.

O, belike his Majesty hath some intent

That you should be new-christened in the Tower.

But what’s the matter, Clarence? May I know?

Oh, my lord, being named George isn't your fault. He should arrest your godparents if that's the reason! Maybe His Majesty wants to have you baptized again in the Tower under a new name. But what's really going on, Clarence? Can I ask what this is about?

Oh man, that's not your fault! He should blame your godparents instead. Maybe he wants to give you a new name in the Tower. But what's really going on, Clarence? What's this actually about?

that's not your fault maybe he wants you to get a new name in the tower what's really happening

"commit your godfathers" A joke: if 'George' is the crime, imprison the godfathers who gave him the name. Richard is playing the sympathetic brother while being the actual cause of the arrest.
CLARENCE ≋ verse [Honest bewilderment. Clarence knows nothing of the real charges, only the King's irrational fear.]

Yea, Richard, when I know, for I protest

As yet I do not. But, as I can learn,

He hearkens after prophecies and dreams,

And from the cross-row plucks the letter G,

And says a wizard told him that by “G”

His issue disinherited should be.

And for my name of George begins with G,

It follows in his thought that I am he.

These, as I learn, and such like toys as these,

Hath moved his Highness to commit me now.

I wish I knew, Richard, because I honestly don't know yet myself. But from what I can learn, the King is paying attention to prophecies and dreams. He's taken the letter G from the alphabet and says a wizard told him that someone named G will disinherit his children. Since my name George starts with G, he thinks I'm the one. These silly things are what made him order me arrested.

I wish I knew, Richard, because I don't know myself yet. But from what I hear, the King is listening to prophecies and dreams. He took the letter G from the alphabet, and some wizard told him that someone named G will take away his kids' inheritance. My name starts with G, so he thinks it's me. This crazy stuff is why he had me arrested.

some wizard told the king that someone named G will steal his children's inheritance my name starts with G so he thinks it's me that's why i'm arrested

RICHARD ≋ verse [Strategic blame-shifting. Richard plants the idea that the Queen—not he—is responsible.]

Why, this it is when men are ruled by women.

’Tis not the King that sends you to the Tower;

My Lady Grey his wife, Clarence, ’tis she

That tempers him to this extremity.

Was it not she and that good man of worship,

Antony Woodville, her brother there,

That made him send Lord Hastings to the Tower,

From whence this present day he is delivered?

We are not safe, Clarence; we are not safe.

This is what happens when women rule men. It's not the King sending you to the Tower—it's his wife, the Lady Grey. She's the one pushing him to do this extreme thing. Wasn't it her and her brother Antony Woodville who also made the King send Lord Hastings to the Tower, and he was just freed today? We're in danger, Clarence. We're not safe.

This is what happens when women control men. The King isn't the one sending you to the Tower—it's his wife, Lady Grey. She's pushing him to do this crazy thing. Wasn't it her and her brother Antony Woodville who also got the King to arrest Lord Hastings? And he just got out today. We're not safe, Clarence. Neither of us.

women are controlling the king it's his wife, lady grey she got hastings arrested too we're not safe

"when men are ruled by women" A standard Elizabethan misogynistic trope — but Richard is deploying it cynically to deflect blame onto the Queen, whom he will use as a scapegoat throughout Act 1.
CLARENCE ≋ verse [bitter resentment at the Queen's faction]

By heaven, I think there is no man secure

But the Queen’s kindred, and night-walking heralds

That trudge betwixt the King and Mistress Shore.

Heard you not what an humble suppliant

Lord Hastings was to her for his delivery?

Honestly, I think the only people who are safe are the Queen's family members and anyone who carries messages between the King and Mistress Shore. Didn't you notice how much trouble Lord Hastings went through to get help from Mistress Shore for his release?

Honestly, I think the only people safe are the Queen's relatives and the messengers who run between the King and Mistress Shore. Did you notice how hard Hastings had to work to get Mistress Shore to help him get out?

only the queen's family is safe and people connected to mistress shore everyone else is in trouble

RICHARD ≋ verse [mockingly explaining court mechanics—the Queen's faction controls everything, but Richard is their real puppet master]

Humbly complaining to her deity

Got my Lord Chamberlain his liberty.

I’ll tell you what: I think it is our way,

If we will keep in favour with the King,

To be her men and wear her livery.

The jealous o’er-worn widow and herself,

Since that our brother dubbed them gentlewomen,

Are mighty gossips in our monarchy.

By humbly begging Mistress Shore's help, Lord Chamberlain got his freedom. Let me tell you—if we want to stay in the King's favor, we need to become her servants and wear her livery. The jealous old widow and Mistress Shore herself—since our brother made them into ladies—are very powerful gossips who control our whole government.

Yeah, Lord Chamberlain got his freedom by begging Mistress Shore for help. Here's what I think: if we want to stay in the King's good graces, we should become her servants and wear her badge. The jealous old widow and Mistress Shore—since our brother gave them high status—they run everything now with their gossip and influence.

to stay safe we need to serve mistress shore they run the government through gossip and influence we have no choice

First appearance
BRAKENBURY

Brakenbury is the obedient functionary doing his uncomfortable job: following orders he doesn't like, blocking conversations he'd rather not know about. His discomfort is the first sign that ordinary people are complicit in Richard's machine.

BRAKENBURY ≋ verse [dutifully enforcing the king's orders]

I beseech your Graces both to pardon me.

His Majesty hath straitly given in charge

That no man shall have private conference,

Of what degree soever, with your brother.

I beg your Graces to excuse me. His Majesty has strictly ordered that no one of any rank should have a private conversation with your brother.

I'm sorry, your Graces, but the King has given strict orders that I can't let anyone talk privately with the Duke, no matter who they are.

sorry, the king said no one can talk privately with clarence

RICHARD ≋ verse [flippant jesting to deflect suspicion]

Even so; an please your worship, Brakenbury,

You may partake of anything we say.

We speak no treason, man. We say the King

Is wise and virtuous, and his noble Queen

Well struck in years, fair, and not jealous.

We say that Shore’s wife hath a pretty foot,

A cherry lip, a bonny eye, a passing pleasing tongue;

And that the Queen’s kindred are made gentlefolks.

How say you, sir? Can you deny all this?

Fine, if it pleases you, Brakenbury, you can listen to what we say. We're not saying anything treasonous. We're just saying the King is wise and virtuous, and his noble Queen is aging well, is beautiful, and isn't jealous. We're saying Mistress Shore has pretty feet, cherry lips, a pretty eye, and a pleasant way of speaking, and that the Queen's family has been raised up to be ladies and gentlemen. Do you deny any of this?

Okay, Brakenbury, if you're okay with it, you can listen to what we're saying. We're not talking treason. We're just saying the King is smart and good, and his wife is still beautiful and not jealous. We're saying Mistress Shore is pretty and pleasant to talk to, and the Queen's relatives have been given high status. Can you argue with any of that?

the king is wise and virtuous the queen is beautiful and not jealous mistress shore is pretty that's all we're saying

"well struck in years, fair, and not jealous" Each of these is a dagger: the Queen is actually young, not 'well on in years'; 'not jealous' implies she should be, given the King's mistress; Richard is speaking obvious lies as innocent truths.
BRAKENBURY [Performative modesty hiding true indifference.]

With this, my lord, myself have naught to do.

I want nothing to do with all that, my lord.

I don't have anything to do with all that, sir.

none of that is my concern

RICHARD ≋ verse [Casual cruelty masked as gossip about the royal mistress. Richard diverts attention from himself.]

Naught to do with Mistress Shore? I tell thee, fellow,

He that doth naught with her, excepting one,

Were best to do it secretly alone.

You have nothing to do with Mistress Shore? Listen, anyone who has nothing to do with her—except for one person—would be wise to keep it completely secret.

Nothing to do with Mistress Shore? Come on, anyone who hasn't been with her—except for one guy—better keep it secret.

everyone's been with mistress shore except one keep it quiet

"He that doth naught with her, excepting one" 'Naught' means nothing but also carries a bawdy meaning. Richard's joke: if a man has nothing to do with Mistress Shore, he'd better keep it private — implying everyone else is sleeping with her (including the King, 'the one').
BRAKENBURY [wary, minimal question]

What one, my lord?

Which one is that, my lord?

Who's the one person, sir?

who's the one?

RICHARD [sharp threat disguised as jest]

Her husband, knave! Wouldst thou betray me?

Her husband, you fool! Are you trying to trap me?

Her husband, you idiot! Are you trying to make me say something I shouldn't?

her husband, duh are you trying to get me in trouble?

BRAKENBURY ≋ verse [apologetic but firm insistence]

I do beseech your Grace to pardon me, and withal

Forbear your conference with the noble Duke.

I beg your Grace to forgive me, and please stop talking to the Duke.

Please forgive me, your Grace, and please stop talking to Clarence.

forgive me, stop talking to clarence

CLARENCE [Empty agreement, both men pretending.]

We know thy charge, Brakenbury, and will obey.

We understand your orders, Brakenbury, and we will obey them.

We know what the King said, Brakenbury, and we'll do it.

we'll obey the king's orders

RICHARD ≋ verse [Explicit promise masking explicit plot. Richard will send Clarence to heaven—by drowning him.]

We are the Queen’s abjects and must obey.

Brother, farewell. I will unto the King,

And whatsoe’er you will employ me in,

Were it to call King Edward’s widow “sister,”

I will perform it to enfranchise you.

Meantime, this deep disgrace in brotherhood

Touches me deeper than you can imagine.

We are the Queen's servants and must obey. Goodbye, brother. I'll go see the King and try to help you. Whatever he asks me to do—even if it's to call the widow of King Edward 'sister'—I'll do it to free you. But this disgrace to our family cuts me deeper than you can understand.

We're the Queen's servants and have to obey. Goodbye, brother. I'm going to see the King and try to get you out. Whatever he wants me to do—even if I have to act nice to the old queen—I'll do it to free you. This disgrace to our family hurts me more than you know.

we're the queen's slaves brother, i'm going to try to free you this disgrace to our family kills me

🎭 Dramatic irony Richard's tearful promise to 'perform' whatever it takes to free Clarence is heard by the audience as the exact opposite of its surface meaning — he has just told us he plans to murder him.
CLARENCE [Gratitude and trust completely misread.]

I know it pleaseth neither of us well.

I know this situation isn't pleasant for either of us.

I know neither of us likes this situation.

i know we both hate this

RICHARD ≋ verse [double-edged vow to free his brother]

Well, your imprisonment shall not be long.

I will deliver or else lie for you.

Meantime, have patience.

Don't worry, your imprisonment won't last long. I'll get you freed, or I'll die trying. For now, be patient.

Don't worry, you won't be in there long. I'll either get you out or die in the attempt. Just hang in there for now.

you won't be locked up long i'll get you out or die trying be patient

"I will deliver or else lie for you" 'Lie' here means 'lie imprisoned' (share your confinement), but we know it also means 'lie' as in deceive — Richard is telling the truth about lying. A classic Shakespearean double meaning that Richard intends.
CLARENCE [Absolute faith in one who has just lied about everything.]

I must perforce. Farewell.

I have no choice but to accept this. Goodbye.

I guess I have to go. Goodbye.

alright, gotta head out bye

[_Exeunt Clarence, Brakenbury and guard._]
RICHARD ≋ verse [Death curse disguised as blessing. Every word is literal truth spoken as lies.]

Go tread the path that thou shalt ne’er return.

Simple, plain Clarence, I do love thee so

That I will shortly send thy soul to heaven,

If heaven will take the present at our hands.

But who comes here? The new-delivered Hastings?

Go on your way, the path from which you'll never return. I love you so much, simple plain Clarence, that I'll soon send your soul to heaven, if heaven will accept what we send from here. But who's coming now? Is that Hastings, just released?

Go ahead on your way—the road you'll never come back from. I love you so much, Clarence, that I'm going to send you to heaven soon, if heaven will take you. But wait—who's coming? Is that Hastings, just getting out?

goodbye clarence i love you so much i'll send you to heaven soon who's this coming?

Enter Lord Hastings.
First appearance
HASTINGS

Hastings speaks in the measured tones of a pragmatic nobleman — careful, politically aware, but not quite careful enough. Watch for how his confidence in reading situations repeatedly leads him astray.

HASTINGS [Formal courtesy, unaware he's already been manipulated.]

Good time of day unto my gracious lord.

Good morning to you, my lord.

Good day to you, sir.

hello my lord

RICHARD ≋ verse [Warm welcome, calculating every word.]

As much unto my good Lord Chamberlain.

Well are you welcome to the open air.

How hath your lordship brooked imprisonment?

And to you, Lord Chamberlain. You're welcome to breathe fresh air again. How did you handle being locked up?

Same to you, Lord Chamberlain. It's good to see you out in the open. How was prison treating you?

welcome back to fresh air how was prison?

HASTINGS ≋ verse [Patient strength, but with a dangerous edge of resentment.]

With patience, noble lord, as prisoners must;

But I shall live, my lord, to give them thanks

That were the cause of my imprisonment.

With patience, as prisoners must, my lord. But I'll live to thank those who were responsible for locking me up.

With patience, as we prisoners have to have. But I'm going to live long enough to thank the people who got me arrested.

i had to be patient but i'll thank those who locked me up

RICHARD ≋ verse [False comfort, strategic alliance-building.]

No doubt, no doubt; and so shall Clarence too,

For they that were your enemies are his,

And have prevailed as much on him as you.

No doubt, and Clarence will too. The same enemies who were yours are his, and they've hurt him just as much as they hurt you.

I'm sure. And Clarence will do the same. The people who were against you are against him too, and they've done the same thing to him.

clarence will too same enemies did the same to him

HASTINGS ≋ verse [Righteous indignation that Richard will exploit.]

More pity that the eagles should be mewed,

Whiles kites and buzzards prey at liberty.

It's a shame that eagles should be caged while kites and buzzards fly free.

It's terrible that noble men like us are locked up while small-minded people get to do what they want.

shame that eagles are caged while buzzards fly free

RICHARD [Strategic curiosity, shifting the conversation.]

What news abroad?

What's the news from outside?

What's happening out there?

what's the news?

HASTINGS ≋ verse [Honest concern mixed with political calculation.]

No news so bad abroad as this at home:

The King is sickly, weak, and melancholy,

And his physicians fear him mightily.

No news outside is as bad as what's happening here: the King is sick, weak, and depressed, and his doctors are very worried about him.

Nothing outside is worse than what's happening here. The King is ill, weak, and depressed, and his doctors are scared for him.

the king is sick weak and depressed his doctors are worried that's worse than any outside news

RICHARD ≋ verse [Mock concern, weaponized sympathy.]

Now, by Saint John, that news is bad indeed.

O, he hath kept an evil diet long,

And overmuch consumed his royal person.

’Tis very grievous to be thought upon.

Where is he, in his bed?

That's very bad news indeed. He's had a poor diet for a long time and has worn out his royal body through excess. It's terrible to think about. Is he in bed?

That's really bad news. He's been eating poorly for years and has used up his health through too much indulgence. It's sad to think about. Is he in his bed?

that's terrible news he's destroyed his health through excess is he in bed?

HASTINGS [Affirmation of the obvious.]

He is.

Yes, he is.

Yes, he is.

yes

RICHARD [Exit line—Richard dismisses Hastings, ready for the next move.]

Go you before, and I will follow you.

You go ahead, and I'll follow you.

You go first, and I'll be right behind you.

go ahead, i'll follow

[_Exit Hastings._]
RICHARD ≋ verse [gleeful villainy revealing his plot]

He cannot live, I hope, and must not die

Till George be packed with post-horse up to heaven.

I’ll in to urge his hatred more to Clarence

With lies well steeled with weighty arguments;

And, if I fail not in my deep intent,

Clarence hath not another day to live;

Which done, God take King Edward to his mercy,

And leave the world for me to bustle in.

For then I’ll marry Warwick’s youngest daughter.

What though I killed her husband and her father?

The readiest way to make the wench amends

Is to become her husband and her father;

The which will I, not all so much for love

As for another secret close intent,

By marrying her which I must reach unto.

But yet I run before my horse to market.

Clarence still breathes; Edward still lives and reigns.

When they are gone, then must I count my gains.

He can't live—I hope he doesn't die until George is rushed to heaven on fast horses. I'll go push Edward to hate Clarence even more with lies backed by strong arguments. If my plan works, Clarence won't see another day. Then God can take Edward to mercy, and the world is mine to work in. I'll marry Warwick's youngest daughter. What does it matter that I killed her husband and father? The best way to make amends to the girl is to become her new husband and her new protector. I'll do it—not for love but for another secret purpose I must achieve through this marriage. But I'm getting ahead of myself. Clarence still breathes, Edward still reigns. When they're gone, then I'll count my power.

He can't live long—George has to get to heaven. I'll go make Edward hate Clarence even more with my lies. If my plan works, Clarence doesn't see tomorrow. Then Edward's gone to God, and the world is mine. I'll marry Warwick's youngest daughter. So what if I killed her husband and father? The way to make her happy is to be her new husband and her new father. I'll do it—not for love but for what I really want. But I'm rushing ahead. Clarence still lives, Edward still rules. When they die, I win everything.

clarence has to die edward has to go i'll turn them against each other when they're gone the world is mine i'll marry warwick's daughter even though i killed her family that's my path to power but they're still alive for now

[_Exit._]

The Reckoning

We've just met the most charismatic villain in English literature, and he's told us everything. The genius of this opening is that Richard takes us into his confidence — we know his plan, we watch him lie to Clarence's face, we become his accomplices. The audience leaves unsettled: we've been charmed by a man who just announced he's going to murder his own brother.

If this happened today…

Imagine a tech startup where the CEO is dying. His younger brother — the CFO, brilliantly sharp, physically distinctive, passed over for every promotion — opens the all-hands meeting with a rousing speech about the company's bright future. Then, in a private aside to the camera, he explains exactly how he's going to get the CEO fired, the other brother framed for embezzlement, and himself into the top seat. Then the framed brother walks in, and the CFO greets him with a tearful hug and promises to fight for him. The company is LinkedIn. The CFO's name is Richard.

Continue to 1.2 →