Run to my Lord of Suffolk; let him know
We have dispatched the Duke as he commanded.
Go quickly to my Lord of Suffolk and tell him we have murdered the Duke as he ordered us to.
Run to Suffolk and tell him we killed the Duke like he wanted.
go to suffolk we killed the duke like he wanted
O that it were to do! What have we done?
Didst ever hear a man so penitent?
I wish we hadn't done it! What have we done? Did you ever hear a man so full of remorse?
I wish we hadn't done it! What did we just do? Did you hear how sorry he was?
i wish we didnt what did we do he was so sorry
Here comes my lord.
My lord approaches.
Here he comes.
heres the lord
Now, sirs, have you dispatched this thing?
1 MURDERER.
Ay, my good lord, he’s dead.
Now, gentlemen, have you completed this task? Murderer: Yes, my lord, he's dead.
So, you got it done? Murderer: Yeah, boss. He's gone.
it's done? yeah. dead.
Why, that’s well said. Go, get you to my house;
I will reward you for this venturous deed.
The King and all the peers are here at hand.
Have you laid fair the bed? Is all things well,
According as I gave directions?
1 MURDERER.
’Tis, my good lord.
Well done. Go to my house; I will reward you for this brave deed. The King and all the nobles are here now. Have you arranged the bed nicely? Is everything in order, Exactly as I instructed? Murderer: Yes, my lord.
Great work. Head to my place— I'll make it worth your while. The King's here with all his nobles. Did you set up the bed like I told you? Everything perfect? Murderer: All set, sir.
go home. i'll pay you. bed set up right? murderer: yeah all good
Away, be gone!
Go on, get out of here!
Now get out of sight.
go. now.
with attendants.
entering with his attendants.
enters with his attendants.
suffolk arrives with attendants
Go, call our uncle to our presence straight;
Say we intend to try his grace today
If he be guilty, as ’tis published.
Go, bring my uncle to me immediately; Tell him I intend to test his character today If he is guilty, as people are saying.
Go get my uncle for me right now. Tell him I'm going to see if there's any truth to these accusations.
get my uncle. now. tell him i'm checking on him
I’ll call him presently, my noble lord.
I'll bring him at once, my noble lord.
Right away, my lord.
on it
Lords, take your places; and, I pray you all,
Proceed no straiter ’gainst our uncle Gloucester
Than from true evidence of good esteem
He be approved in practice culpable.
Lords, take your seats; and I beg you all, Proceed no more harshly against our uncle Gloucester Than the true evidence of his good reputation Requires him to be proven guilty.
Everyone sit down. I'm asking you all—don't come down on my uncle any harder than what we actually know. Wait for real proof before you judge him.
sit. don't rush to blame gloucester. we need real evidence.
God forbid any malice should prevail
That faultless may condemn a nobleman!
Pray God he may acquit him of suspicion!
God forbid that any malice should win out And cause someone innocent to condemn a nobleman! Pray God he may be cleared of suspicion!
Heaven help us if hatred makes us convict an innocent man. I hope my uncle comes out clean.
god no. we can't convict an innocent guy. hope he's clear
I thank thee, Meg; these words content me much.
I thank you, Margaret; these words please me greatly.
Thank you, Margaret. That means a lot.
thanks meg. that helps
How now? Why look’st thou pale? Why tremblest thou?
Where is our uncle? What’s the matter, Suffolk?
What's happening? Why are you so pale? Why are you trembling? Where is our uncle? What's wrong, Suffolk?
What's going on? Why are you so pale? Why are you shaking? Where's our uncle? What's the matter?
whats wrong why ur pale where's gloucester
The most powerful moment in 3-2 is not dialogue but physical evidence: Warwick's detailed autopsy of Gloucester's corpse. He reads the body like a text, identifying specific signs of murder: blood settled in the face (indicating strangulation rather than natural death), bulging eyes, torn hair, spread hands (showing resistance and struggle), flared nostrils (indicating gasping for breath). This is Renaissance forensic science—accurate enough to be convincing, detailed enough to be horrifying. The corpse itself becomes the prosecution's witness. It cannot lie. Suffolk and the Cardinal cannot explain it away. They can only try to change the subject. This is also Shakespeare's most explicit statement that murder leaves evidence—that bodies tell the truth. The staging requires actual blood and makeup effects to be convincing, turning Gloucester's death from an abstraction into a physical, visible horror.
Dead in his bed, my lord; Gloucester is dead.
He lies dead in his chambers, my lord; Gloucester is no more.
He's found dead, my lord. Gloucester won't be coming back.
gloucester's gone. dead in his room.
Marry, God forfend!
Indeed, God forbid!
Oh God, no!
god no
God’s secret judgment! I did dream tonight
The Duke was dumb and could not speak a word.
God's secret judgment! I had a dream last night— The Duke was silent and couldn't speak a word.
That's God's judgment right there. I dreamed last night that the Duke couldn't talk.
i dreamed he couldn't speak. weird
How fares my lord? Help, lords! the King is dead.
How is your majesty? Somebody help! The King is collapsing!
My lord, wake up! Someone help! The King is falling!
henry wake up! someone help! king's going down!
Rear up his body; wring him by the nose.
Lift him up; pull him by the nose.
Get him up off the ground. Try pulling on his nose.
lift him. get his nose
Run, go, help, help! O Henry, ope thine eyes!
Run, help, help! Henry, open your eyes!
Hurry, someone help! Henry, wake up! Open your eyes!
help! henry wake up!
He doth revive again. Madam, be patient.
He's coming back to life. Madam, be patient.
He's waking up. Just stay calm.
he's waking up. wait
O heavenly God!
Oh God in heaven!
Oh my God!
oh god
How fares my gracious lord?
How are you feeling, my gracious lord?
Are you okay, my lord?
u ok?
Comfort, my sovereign! Gracious Henry, comfort!
Take comfort, my King! Gracious Henry, be strong!
Hang in there, my lord. You're going to be fine.
stay strong henry
What, doth my Lord of Suffolk comfort me?
Came he right now to sing a raven’s note,
Whose dismal tune bereft my vital powers,
And thinks he that the chirping of a wren,
By crying comfort from a hollow breast,
Can chase away the first-conceived sound?
Hide not thy poison with such sugared words;
Lay not thy hands on me. Forbear, I say!
Their touch affrights me as a serpent’s sting.
Thou baleful messenger, out of my sight!
Upon thy eyeballs murderous tyranny
Sits in grim majesty to fright the world.
Look not upon me, for thine eyes are wounding.
Yet do not go away; come, basilisk,
And kill the innocent gazer with thy sight.
For in the shade of death I shall find joy,
In life but double death, now Gloucester’s dead.
What, does my Lord Suffolk comfort me? He came just now to sing like a raven, Whose terrible sound drained away my life, And thinks he that a wren's chirping, Coming in hollow comfort from his chest, Can erase that first dark sound I heard? Don't hide your poison in such sweet words; Don't put your hands on me. Step back, I say! Your touch frightens me like a snake's bite. You evil messenger, out of my sight! On your eyes sits murderous cruelty In grim majesty to terrify the world. Don't look at me—your eyes are like weapons. Yet don't go away; come, you poisonous thing, And kill me with your gaze. For in the shadow of death I'll find joy, In life, only double death, now Gloucester is dead.
Are you trying to comfort me? You just came here spreading doom and gloom, draining all the life out of me. Now you think some sweet talk and fake kindness will undo that? Don't touch me. Your hands are poison to me. Get away from me. I can't even look at you without feeling stabbed. You're evil incarnate. Just stay back. In fact, kill me while you're at it. Death would be better than living without Gloucester.
ur the one who did this. u came here killing me with bad news. don't touch me. just let me die. gloucester's gone so what's the point
Why do you rate my Lord of Suffolk thus?
Although the Duke was enemy to him,
Yet he most Christian-like laments his death.
And for myself, foe as he was to me,
Might liquid tears or heart-offending groans
Or blood-consuming sighs recall his life,
I would be blind with weeping, sick with groans,
Look pale as primrose with blood-drinking sighs,
And all to have the noble Duke alive.
What know I how the world may deem of me?
For it is known we were but hollow friends.
It may be judged I made the Duke away;
So shall my name with slander’s tongue be wounded
And princes’ courts be filled with my reproach.
This get I by his death. Ay me, unhappy!
To be a queen, and crowned with infamy!
Why do you attack my Lord Suffolk like this? Although the Duke was an enemy to him, Yet he grieves for his death in the most Christian way. And for myself, even though he was my enemy, If tears or suffering or sighs Or blood-draining sighs could bring him back, I would cry myself blind, groan myself sick, Grow pale as a primrose with my weeping, And do it all to have the noble Duke alive. What do I know of what the world will say about me? We all know we were only pretend friends. They might judge that I arranged his death; So my name will be wounded by slander And royal courts filled with my shame. This is what I get from his death. Unhappy me! To be a queen, crowned with infamy!
Why are you coming at Suffolk like this? Yes, the Duke and he had their differences, but look at him—he's genuinely heartbroken. As for me, I was on the Duke's enemies list too, but if I could bring him back with tears or agony or anything else, I'd be blind from crying. But here's what kills me—everyone's going to say I had something to do with this. They'll say I got rid of him to protect myself. My name will be ruined, and I'll be remembered as a murderer, not a queen. I'm the one who's really suffering.
why blame suffolk? he's sad about it too. i'd cry till blind to get him back but everyone will say i did it i'm the one destroyed by this
Ah, woe is me for Gloucester, wretched man!
I'm miserable about Gloucester's death!
I can't believe Gloucester is gone—this is devastating!
gloucester... god this is awful
Be woe for me, more wretched than he is.
What, dost thou turn away and hide thy face?
I am no loathsome leper. Look on me.
What, art thou, like the adder, waxen deaf?
Be poisonous too and kill thy forlorn Queen.
Is all thy comfort shut in Gloucester’s tomb?
Why, then, Dame Margaret was ne’er thy joy.
Erect his statue and worship it,
And make my image but an alehouse sign.
Was I for this nigh wracked upon the sea
And twice by awkward wind from England’s bank
Drove back again unto my native clime?
What boded this, but well forewarning wind
Did seem to say “Seek not a scorpion’s nest,
Nor set no footing on this unkind shore?”
What did I then, but cursed the gentle gusts
And he that loosed them forth their brazen caves
And bid them blow towards England’s blessed shore
Or turn our stern upon a dreadful rock?
Yet Aeolus would not be a murderer,
But left that hateful office unto thee.
The pretty-vaulting sea refused to drown me,
Knowing that thou wouldst have me drowned on shore
With tears as salt as sea, through thy unkindness.
The splitting rocks cowered in the sinking sands
And would not dash me with their ragged sides,
Because thy flinty heart, more hard than they,
Might in thy palace perish Margaret.
As far as I could ken thy chalky cliffs,
When from thy shore the tempest beat us back,
I stood upon the hatches in the storm,
And when the dusky sky began to rob
My earnest-gaping sight of thy land’s view,
I took a costly jewel from my neck—
A heart it was, bound in with diamonds—
And threw it towards thy land. The sea received it,
And so I wished thy body might my heart.
And even with this I lost fair England’s view,
And bid mine eyes be packing with my heart,
And called them blind and dusky spectacles,
For losing ken of Albion’s wished coast.
How often have I tempted Suffolk’s tongue,
The agent of thy foul inconstancy,
To sit and witch me, as Ascanius did
When he to madding Dido would unfold
His father’s acts commenced in burning Troy!
Am I not witched like her? Or thou not false like him?
Ay me, I can no more! Die, Margaret,
For Henry weeps that thou dost live so long.
Feel miserable for me, who is more miserable than he is. What, do you turn away and hide your face? I'm not a loathsome leper. Look at me. What, are you like the deaf adder? Be poisonous and kill your suffering Queen. Is all your comfort locked away in Gloucester's grave? Why then, Margaret was never your joy. Build his statue and worship it, And turn my image into a sign for an alehouse. Was I nearly drowned at sea And twice blown back from England's shore By terrible wind back to my native country, For what reason? But a warning wind that seemed to say "Don't seek a scorpion's nest, Don't set foot on this unkind shore?" What did I do then but curse those gentle breezes And the god that let them out of his bronze caves, And pray they'd blow toward England's blessed coast Or turn our ship toward a deadly rock? Yet even Aeolus would not be a murderer, But left that evil job for you. The pretty leaping sea refused to drown me, Knowing you would have me drowned on shore With tears as salty as the sea, because of your cruelty. The jagged rocks in the sinking sands Would not crash into me with their rough edges, Because your hard heart, harder than stone, Might kill me in your palace. As far as I could see your white cliffs, When your shore's storm pushed us back, I stood in the middle of the storm, And when the dark sky began to rob My eager eyes of your land's view, I took an expensive jewel from my neck— A heart it was, set with diamonds— And threw it toward your land. The sea took it, And so I wished my body to follow my heart. And so I lost fair England's view, And told my eyes to go along with my heart, And called them blind and dark glasses, For losing sight of England's desired coast. How often have I let Suffolk's tongue persuade me, The agent of your cruelty, To sit and enchant me, as Ascanius did When he would tell madly-in-love Dido About his father's great deeds in burning Troy! Am I not enchanted like she was? Or aren't you false like he was? I can't go on anymore! Die, Margaret, For Henry is sad that you still live.
Be sad for me. I'm the one who's really suffering. Why won't you even look at me? I'm not diseased. I'm your wife. Are you just going to ignore me? Kill me then. At least put me out of my misery. Is Gloucester the only thing that matters now? Have I become nothing? You should worship him and throw me away. I gave up everything for you—I barely survived that sea voyage to get here. Twice I was blown back, nearly drowned. The waves and rocks wouldn't even kill me because I was meant to be with you. I threw my precious jewel in the ocean hoping it would guide me to you. But you don't care. You're just like that guy from the stories who pretended to love Dido while he was really working for his father. You used me, and now you won't even look at me. I'm done. I can't take this anymore. Just let me die since you clearly wish I wasn't here.
be sad for me i came here almost died at sea took a jewel meant me to you u won't even look at me just let me die at this point
It is reported, mighty sovereign,
That good Duke Humphrey traitorously is murdered
By Suffolk and the Cardinal Beaufort’s means.
The commons, like an angry hive of bees
That want their leader, scatter up and down
And care not who they sting in his revenge.
Myself have calmed their spleenful mutiny,
Until they hear the order of his death.
It is reported, mighty sovereign, That good Duke Humphrey has been traitorously murdered By Suffolk's and Cardinal Beaufort's doing. The common people, like an angry swarm of bees That have lost their leader, scatter everywhere And strike whoever they can in revenge. I myself have calmed their furious anger, Until they hear how he died.
My lord, word's going around that Duke Humphrey was murdered—Suffolk and the Cardinal did it. The people are going crazy about it. Like a beehive without a queen, they're all over the place looking for revenge. I've managed to hold them back so far, but they're demanding to know exactly what happened.
suffolk & cardinal killed humphrey crowd's furious like bees w/o a queen i've held them back but they want answers
That he is dead, good Warwick, ’tis too true;
But how he died God knows, not Henry.
Yes, Warwick, it's certain he's gone from this world; But the manner of his death remains unknown to me—only God understands what happened.
You're right, Warwick, he's definitely gone. But I have no idea how it happened. Only God knows what really went on.
yeah he's gone. no idea how. only god knows.
And comment then upon his sudden death.
And then comment on the cause of his sudden death.
And explain what caused his sudden death.
explain his death
Margaret enters 3-2 as a successful conspirator: Gloucester is dead, the threat is removed, her husband is King. By the end of the scene, she has nothing: Suffolk is exiled, she herself is effectively banished (threatened with death if found in England), her reputation is destroyed, and Henry—who should be grateful for her 'care'—has turned away from her to mourn the man she arranged to kill. The murder that was supposed to secure her power has destroyed it. Worse, she discovers that Henry's love for Gloucester (even in death) exceeds his love for her (while she's alive). She's been destroyed by her own cunning—she won the political game and lost everything that mattered. Margaret's final soliloquy shows a woman of extraordinary intelligence watching her entire world collapse in the space of a few hours. She's not tragic in the sense of being blameless, but she is tragic in the sense that her fall is total and self-inflicted.
That shall I do, my liege.—Stay, Salisbury,
With the rude multitude till I return.
I will do that, my king.—Stay here, Salisbury, With the rough crowd until I return.
Right away, my lord.—Salisbury, you stay here with the people till I get back.
i'll go. salisbury stay w crowd
O Thou that judgest all things, stay my thoughts,
My thoughts that labour to persuade my soul
Some violent hands were laid on Humphrey’s life.
If my suspect be false, forgive me, God,
For judgment only doth belong to Thee.
Fain would I go to chafe his paly lips
With twenty thousand kisses, and to drain
Upon his face an ocean of salt tears,
To tell my love unto his dumb deaf trunk,
And with my fingers feel his hand unfeeling;
But all in vain are these mean obsequies.
And to survey his dead and earthy image,
What were it but to make my sorrow greater?
God, who judges all things, calm my mind, My mind that struggles to believe That someone violently killed Humphrey. If my suspicion is wrong, forgive me, God, For judgment belongs only to you. I wish I could go warm his pale lips With twenty thousand kisses, and pour An ocean of salt tears on his face, To show my love to his silent lifeless body, And feel his hand with my fingers, knowing it's dead; But it's all pointless. And to look at his dead, earthly form, Wouldn't that just make my sorrow worse?
God, help me. My mind keeps going to this dark place—that someone murdered him. If I'm wrong about that, forgive me. Only you can judge the truth. I wish I could be with him, kiss him a thousand times, cry over his body, hold his hand one more time. But what's the point? It would only make the pain worse.
god help me i think someone killed him i just wanna hold him again but it'd hurt more
Come hither, gracious sovereign, view this body.
Come here, gracious sovereign, look at his body.
My lord, come look at him.
look at his body
That is to see how deep my grave is made,
For with his soul fled all my worldly solace;
For seeing him, I see my life in death.
That's like looking at how deep my own grave is, Because with his life went all my worldly comfort; Because seeing him, I see my own death.
Looking at him is like looking at my own grave. He was my comfort in this world. Now that he's gone, I might as well be dead too.
i see his death i see mine he was everything w/o him i'm dead too
As surely as my soul intends to live
With that dread King that took our state upon Him
To free us from His Father’s wrathful curse,
I do believe that violent hands were laid
Upon the life of this thrice-famed duke.
As surely as my soul will live With that great King who took our punishment on himself To free us from his Father's anger, I believe that someone violently murdered This three-times famous duke.
I swear by my soul and by Christ who died for us—I am certain that someone murdered the Duke. I'm sure of it.
i swear. someone murdered him. i'm 100% sure
A dreadful oath, sworn with a solemn tongue!
What instance gives Lord Warwick for his vow?
A serious oath, spoken with gravity! What proof does Lord Warwick have for his vow?
That's a big oath to swear. What evidence do you have?
big oath. what's your proof?
See how the blood is settled in his face.
Oft have I seen a timely-parted ghost,
Of ashy semblance, meagre, pale, and bloodless,
Being all descended to the labouring heart,
Who, in the conflict that it holds with death,
Attracts the same for aidance ’gainst the enemy,
Which with the heart there cools and ne’er returneth
To blush and beautify the cheek again.
But see, his face is black and full of blood,
His eyeballs further out than when he lived,
Staring full ghastly like a strangled man;
His hair upreared, his nostrils stretched with struggling,
His hands abroad displayed, as one that grasped
And tugged for life and was by strength subdued.
Look, on the sheets his hair, you see, is sticking;
His well-proportioned beard made rough and rugged,
Like to the summer’s corn by tempest lodged.
It cannot be but he was murdered here;
The least of all these signs were probable.
Look at how blood is pooled in his face. I have often seen a body that died naturally— Ashy colored, thin, pale, and without blood, With all the blood sunk down to the struggling heart, Which, fighting against death, Draws the blood toward itself for strength against death, Which then cools with the heart and never returns To color and warm the cheek again. But look here—his face is black and full of blood, His eyes bulging further out than when he lived, Staring wide open like a strangled man; His hair standing up, his nostrils stretched from struggling, His hands spread out, as if grabbing And fighting for life but overpowered. Look, on the sheets his hair is sticking; His well-groomed beard made rough and tangled, Like summer grain beaten down by a storm. It cannot be anything but murder; Even the smallest of these signs proves it.
All the signs point to strangulation. The blood's still in his face, his eyes are bulging, his hair's standing on end, his mouth's wide open like he was gasping. His hands are torn up from fighting back. Everything shows he died violently, not peacefully in his sleep. This was definitely murder.
look at his face. blood everywhere. eyes bulging. hair standing up. clawing marks on hands. strangled. definitely murdered.
Why, Warwick, who should do the Duke to death?
Myself and Beaufort had him in protection,
And we, I hope, sir, are no murderers.
Why, Warwick, who would murder the Duke? Myself and Beaufort had him under guard, And we, I hope, sir, are not murderers.
Hold on, Warwick. Who would kill the Duke? We were watching him—Beaufort and me. We're not murderers.
who'd kill him? we were watching him. we're no murderers.
But both of you were vowed Duke Humphrey’s foes,
And you, forsooth, had the good Duke to keep.
’Tis like you would not feast him like a friend,
And ’tis well seen he found an enemy.
But you both were enemies to Duke Humphrey, And you were supposed to keep him safe. It seems you wouldn't have treated him like a friend, And it's clear he found an enemy instead.
Yeah, but you two hated him. And you were the ones guarding him? You wouldn't have protected him like a friend would. Looks like he had his enemies right there with him.
u both hated him. u were guarding him. where's the care? he had enemies right there.
Then you, belike, suspect these noblemen
As guilty of Duke Humphrey’s timeless death.
So you suspect these nobles Of killing Duke Humphrey.
So you're saying these guys murdered the Duke?
u think they killed him?
Who finds the heifer dead and bleeding fresh
And sees fast by a butcher with an axe,
But will suspect ’twas he that made the slaughter?
Who finds the partridge in the puttock’s nest
But may imagine how the bird was dead,
Although the kite soar with unbloodied beak?
Even so suspicious is this tragedy.
If someone finds a cow dead and bleeding fresh And sees a butcher standing near with an ax, Won't they think he's the one who did the slaughter? If someone finds a partridge in the hawk's nest But can imagine how the bird died, Even if the kite's beak shows no blood? This tragedy is that obvious.
It's simple. If you find a dead, bleeding cow and there's a butcher standing there with an ax, you know who did it. If you find a dead bird in a hawk's nest, you figure it out. This case is that clear. The guilty parties are standing right here.
find dead cow+butcher w ax nearby. u know who did it. this is obvious.
Are you the butcher, Suffolk? Where’s your knife?
Is Beaufort termed a kite? Where are his talons?
Are you the butcher, Suffolk? Where's your knife? Is Beaufort a hawk? Where are his claws?
So are you the butcher, Suffolk? Where's your weapon? Is Beaufort the hawk? Where are his talons?
ur the butcher? where's your knife? beaufort the hawk? where's his claws?
I wear no knife to slaughter sleeping men,
But here’s a vengeful sword, rusted with ease,
That shall be scoured in his rancorous heart
That slanders me with murder’s crimson badge.
Say, if thou dar’st, proud Lord of Warwickshire,
That I am faulty in Duke Humphrey’s death.
I don't use a knife to kill sleeping men, But here's an avenging sword, dull from disuse, That will be sharpened in the heart Of whoever slanders me with accusations of murder. Say, if you dare, proud Lord of Warwickshire, That I am guilty of Duke Humphrey's death.
I'm not the kind of man who sneaks up on sleeping people. But I've got a sword that's getting rusty from disuse, and I'd love to use it on whoever keeps calling me a murderer. Go ahead, Warwick. Say I killed the Duke. Say it to my face.
i don't sneak kill. but i got a sword for whoever accuses me. say it warwick. say i did it.
What dares not Warwick, if false Suffolk dare him?
What won't Warwick do, if cowardly Suffolk challenges him?
What wouldn't I do? You're challenging me?
u challenging me?
He dares not calm his contumelious spirit,
Nor cease to be an arrogant controller,
Though Suffolk dare him twenty thousand times.
He doesn't have the courage to control his insulting pride, Nor stop being an arrogant controller, Even if Suffolk challenged him twenty thousand times.
Warwick just keeps pushing, acting superior. He won't back down no matter what. He's too arrogant and controlling.
warwick won't stop. he's too arrogant. no matter what suffolk does
Madam, be still, with reverence may I say;
For every word you speak in his behalf
Is slander to your royal dignity.
Madam, be quiet, with your permission; Because every word you speak on his behalf Disgraces your royal dignity.
My lady, with respect, every word you say defending Suffolk makes you look bad.
ur making urself look bad defending him
The final 40 lines of 3-2 constitute one of Shakespeare's greatest love scenes—precisely because it's not a love scene but a farewell. Margaret and Suffolk are completely entangled in love that is destroying them both. They have achieved everything they wanted (power, influence, each other) and it has come to nothing. Separated by the consequences of their own actions, they exchange some of the most tender lines in the play while also expressing some of the most violent emotions (curses, despair, the wish for death). What makes this scene work is that neither Margaret nor Suffolk is self-pitying. Margaret doesn't blame Suffolk for his exile. Suffolk doesn't blame Margaret for his downfall. Instead, they blame themselves, express their love, and accept the separation as the only way to save each other. Margaret's final act of love is to force Suffolk to leave—to choose his survival over their union. This is love without the fantasy of romantic rescue: it's the love of two people who understand that they've destroyed each other and are trying, at the last moment, to salvage something from the wreckage.
Blunt-witted lord, ignoble in demeanour!
If ever lady wronged her lord so much,
Thy mother took into her blameful bed
Some stern untutored churl, and noble stock
Was graft with crab-tree slip, whose fruit thou art,
And never of the Nevilles’ noble race.
Stupid cowardly lord, ignoble in manner! If any lady ever wronged her husband so much, Your mother took into her sinful bed Some rude uncivilized man, and your noble line Was crossed with low stock, so you're the fruit Of that bad union, and never of the noble Nevilles.
You're a stupid, cowardly fool. Your mother must have slept with some peasant, because there's no way you're actually a real Neville. You're a bastard, plain and simple.
ur a coward no real neville prob some bastard
But that the guilt of murder bucklers thee
And I should rob the deathsman of his fee,
Quitting thee thereby of ten thousand shames,
And that my sovereign’s presence makes me mild,
I would, false murderous coward, on thy knee
Make thee beg pardon for thy passed speech
And say it was thy mother that thou meant’st,
That thou thyself wast born in bastardy;
And after all this fearful homage done,
Give thee thy hire and send thy soul to hell,
Pernicious blood-sucker of sleeping men!
Except that the guilt of murder protects you And I should rob the executioner of his payment, Freeing you from ten thousand shames, And except my king's presence makes me restrained, I would, false murdering coward, force you to your knees And make you beg pardon for what you just said, And make you admit it was your mother you meant, That you yourself were born of adultery; And after all this fearful humiliation, Give you your payment and send your soul to hell, Evil bloodsucker of sleeping men!
If I didn't know you were a murderer, and if the king weren't watching, and if I weren't doing his job for him, I'd get you on your knees right now. You'd beg for mercy. You'd admit your mother was a whore and you're a bastard. Then I'd kill you and send you straight to hell.
if not for king watching i'd make u beg make u admit ur a bastard then kill u
Thou shalt be waking while I shed thy blood,
If from this presence thou dar’st go with me.
You'll still be awake when I spill your blood, If you dare leave this room with me.
You'll know exactly what's happening when I cut you open. You want to step outside?
come outside. i'll kill u.
Away even now, or I will drag thee hence.
Unworthy though thou art, I’ll cope with thee
And do some service to Duke Humphrey’s ghost.
Let's go right now, or I'll drag you out of here. Even though you don't deserve it, I'll fight you And serve Duke Humphrey's ghost.
Let's go. Right now. I'll drag you out if I have to. I owe it to Humphrey's memory.
let's go NOW for humphrey
What stronger breastplate than a heart untainted?
Thrice is he armed that hath his quarrel just,
And he but naked, though locked up in steel,
Whose conscience with injustice is corrupted.
What stronger armor than a clear conscience? He who has a just cause is three times armed, But he who is naked, even in steel armor, If his conscience is corrupted by injustice.
A clean conscience is the best protection. If your cause is just, you're unstoppable. But if you're guilty, even armor won't save you.
clean conscience > armor just cause = strong guilt = nothing
What noise is this?
What's this noise?
What's all that commotion?
what's that noise?
Why, how now, lords? Your wrathful weapons drawn
Here in our presence? Dare you be so bold?
Why, what tumultuous clamour have we here?
Why, what is this, lords? Your angry weapons are drawn Here in our presence? How dare you be so bold? Why, what is all this violent commotion?
What's going on here? You're pulling swords in front of me? How dare you! What's all this fighting about?
weapons out? in front of me? u crazy?
The traitorous Warwick with the men of Bury
Set all upon me, mighty sovereign.
The treacherous Warwick and the men of Bury Attacked me, mighty sovereign.
Warwick and his gang came after me, my lord.
warwick attacked me
Sirs, stand apart; the King shall know your mind.—
Dread lord, the commons send you word by me,
Unless Lord Suffolk straight be done to death,
Or banished fair England’s territories,
They will by violence tear him from your palace
And torture him with grievous lingering death.
They say, by him the good Duke Humphrey died;
They say, in him they fear your highness’ death;
And mere instinct of love and loyalty,
Free from a stubborn opposite intent,
As being thought to contradict your liking,
Makes them thus forward in his banishment.
They say, in care of your most royal person,
That if your highness should intend to sleep
And charge that no man should disturb your rest,
In pain of your dislike or pain of death,
Yet, notwithstanding such a strait edict,
Were there a serpent seen, with forked tongue,
That slyly glided towards your majesty,
It were but necessary you were waked,
Lest, being suffered in that harmful slumber,
The mortal worm might make the sleep eternal.
And therefore do they cry, though you forbid,
That they will guard you, whe’er you will or no,
From such fell serpents as false Suffolk is,
With whose envenomed and fatal sting
Your loving uncle, twenty times his worth,
They say, is shamefully bereft of life.
Gentlemen, stand apart; the King will know your position.— My dread lord, the common people send you word through me: Unless Lord Suffolk dies right away, Or is banished from England's lands, They will forcibly take him from your palace And torture him with painful, slow death. They say he caused good Duke Humphrey's death; They say they fear he threatens your life; And pure natural love and loyalty, Free from any stubborn resistance, As if they don't want to anger you, Makes them strongly push for his banishment. They say, to protect your royal life, That if your majesty were to fall asleep And order that no one disturb your rest, On pain of your anger or pain of death, Yet, despite such a strict command, If a snake with forked tongue Were quietly sliding toward your majesty, It would be necessary to wake you, For fear sleeping would be eternal. And therefore they cry out, even though you forbid it, That they will guard you, whether you want them to or not, From such deadly snakes as false Suffolk is, Whose poisoned and deadly bite Your loving uncle, worth twenty times as much, They say, was shamefully robbed of his life.
The commons are demanding action, my lord. They want Suffolk gone—either executed or banished. They blame him for Humphrey's death and see him as a threat to you. They say they're acting out of love, like if a poisonous snake were attacking you while you slept. They won't let this go.
people want suffolk dead or banished. say he killed humphrey. say he's a threat to u. they won't back down.
[_Within_.] An answer from the King, my Lord of Salisbury!
We demand an answer from the King, Lord Salisbury!
Give us an answer from the King, Salisbury!
[offstage] answer from the king salisbury!
’Tis like the commons, rude unpolished hinds,
Could send such message to their sovereign.
But you, my lord, were glad to be employed,
To show how quaint an orator you are.
But all the honour Salisbury hath won
Is that he was the lord ambassador
Sent from a sort of tinkers to the King.
It seems the common people, rude uneducated peasants, Could send such a message to their sovereign. But you, my lord, were happy to be hired To show how clever an orator you are. But all the honor Salisbury has won Is that he was the lord ambassador Sent from a group of low craftsmen to the King.
Right, because the common people would come together like this. You just loved being the messenger, showing off how well you can speak. That's all the glory you've got—being a messenger boy for peasants.
sure the commoners would organize. u loved being their messenger boy. that's all ur worth
[_Within_.] An answer from the King, or we will all break in!
We demand an answer from the King, or we will break down these doors!
Tell us what the King says or we break in!
[offstage] answer from king or we break in
Go, Salisbury, and tell them all from me,
I thank them for their tender loving care;
And had I not been cited so by them,
Yet did I purpose as they do entreat.
For, sure, my thoughts do hourly prophesy
Mischance unto my state by Suffolk’s means.
And therefore, by His majesty I swear,
Whose far unworthy deputy I am,
He shall not breathe infection in this air
But three days longer, on the pain of death.
Go, Salisbury, and tell them all from me: I thank them for their tender loving care; And if I hadn't been urged by them, I would still have done what they ask. Because, in truth, my thoughts constantly warn me Of disaster to my rule caused by Suffolk. And therefore, by His majesty I swear, Whose weak servant I am, He will not breathe corruption in this air But three days longer, on pain of death.
Go tell them I appreciate their concern. And honestly, I was already thinking the same thing. Suffolk's been a bad influence on my rule, and I've been having dark thoughts about him. So give them my word—Suffolk has three days to get out of England or face execution.
tell them: thanks for caring. i was already suspicious of suffolk. he's got 3 days to leave or he dies.
O Henry, let me plead for gentle Suffolk!
Henry, let me speak up for gentle Suffolk!
My lord, please, let me say something for Suffolk!
plz let suffolk stay
In 3-2, political power visibly transfers from the throne to the commons. Henry begins the scene determined to give Gloucester a fair trial (demonstrating kingly authority). But by the end of the scene, he is taking orders from Salisbury, who speaks for the commons. When Henry banishes Suffolk in response to the commons' ultimatum, he is effectively admitting that his authority has been superseded by popular will. The commons have become the real power in the kingdom. This is revolutionary: the play is suggesting that when the regime becomes illegitimate (by murdering Gloucester), the people take back power. The murder of Gloucester doesn't just destroy the conspirators—it delegitimizes the entire regime. The commons recognize that if the King's courtiers can murder his uncle, they can murder anyone. Therefore they demand justice, and Henry complies. The play is showing that tyranny—even successful tyranny—contains the seeds of its own destruction.
Ungentle Queen, to call him gentle Suffolk!
No more, I say; if thou dost plead for him,
Thou wilt but add increase unto my wrath.
Had I but said, I would have kept my word;
But when I swear, it is irrevocable.
If, after three days’ space, thou here be’st found
On any ground that I am ruler of,
The world shall not be ransom for thy life.
Come, Warwick, come, good Warwick, go with me;
I have great matters to impart to thee.
Ungentle Queen, to call him gentle Suffolk! No more, I say; if you plead for him, you will only increase my anger. If I had merely spoken it, I would have kept my word; but when I swear an oath, it cannot be broken. If you are found anywhere in my realm after three days, the whole world's ransom would not save your life. Come, Warwick, come, good Warwick, go with me; I have important matters to discuss with you.
Don't call him gentle, Queen! I'm done listening. If you keep arguing for him, you're just going to make me angrier. I keep my word on everything—even casual remarks I make stick with me. And when I swear an oath, that's absolutely final. If I find you anywhere in my kingdom three days from now, nobody can pay enough money to save you. Warwick, let's go—I need to talk to you about some serious things.
dont defend him my words are absolute when i swear it's final if ur here in 3 days ur dead come warwick we need to talk
Mischance and sorrow go along with you!
Heart’s discontent and sour affliction
Be playfellows to keep you company!
There’s two of you; the devil make a third!
And threefold vengeance tend upon your steps!
Bad luck and sorrow go with you! Heartbreak and bitter pain Be your companions on your way! There's two of you; may the devil be the third! And triple curses follow your every step!
Get out of here with your bad luck! Suffering and heartbreak, that's what I wish for you both. You two are worse than the devil himself. I curse every step you take.
bad luck follow u both. suffer. hope devil joins u. cursed.
Cease, gentle Queen, these execrations,
And let thy Suffolk take his heavy leave.
Stop, gentle Queen, with these curses, And let your Suffolk say his painful goodbye.
Queen, please stop. I have to leave now.
stop. gotta go.
Fie, coward woman and soft-hearted wretch!
Has thou not spirit to curse thine enemies?
Shame, cowardly woman and weak-hearted wretch! Don't you have the will to curse your enemies?
You coward! You're just going to let him go? Don't you have any fight in you? Curse them!
ur a coward. where's ur fight? curse them!
A plague upon them! Wherefore should I curse them?
Could curses kill, as doth the mandrake’s groan,
I would invent as bitter searching terms,
As curst, as harsh and horrible to hear,
Delivered strongly through my fixed teeth,
With full as many signs of deadly hate,
As lean-faced Envy in her loathsome cave.
My tongue should stumble in mine earnest words;
Mine eyes should sparkle like the beaten flint;
Mine hair be fixed on end, as one distract;
Ay, every joint should seem to curse and ban;
And even now my burdened heart would break
Should I not curse them. Poison be their drink!
Gall, worse than gall, the daintiest that they taste!
Their sweetest shade a grove of cypress-trees!
Their chiefest prospect murdering basilisks;
Their softest touch as smart as lizards’ stings!
Their music frightful as the serpent’s hiss,
And boding screech-owls make the consort full!
All the foul terrors in dark-seated hell—
A curse upon them! Why shouldn't I curse them? If curses could kill, as the mandrake root's scream does, I would invent curses as bitter and piercing, As vicious, as harsh and horrible to hear, Delivered hard through my clenched teeth, With as many signs of deadly hate, As the lean-faced figure of Envy in her disgusting cave. My tongue would stumble over my furious words; My eyes would spark like struck flint; My hair would stand on end, as if I were mad; Every part of me would curse and condemn them; And even now my heavy heart would break Unless I cursed them. Poison for their drink! Bitterness, worse than bile, for their finest food! Their happiest rest a grove of funeral trees! Their best view deadly snakes; Their softest touch sharp as lizard bites! Their music as frightening as snake hisses, And screaming owls making the orchestra complete! All the foul horrors from the depths of hell—
I do curse them! If curses had power, I'd make them wish they'd never been born. I'd curse them with every fiber of my being, with my eyes flashing and my hair standing up. I'd curse them so hard it would break my heart. I wish poison in their cups, bitterness in their food, sadness in their rest, death in their sight, pain in every touch, screaming owls for music. I want every terrible thing from hell to follow them.
i curse them! poison in their drinks bad in all they eat death in their sight pain in every touch hell follows them
Enough, sweet Suffolk; thou torment’st thyself,
And these dread curses, like the sun ’gainst glass,
Or like an overcharged gun, recoil
And turns the force of them upon thyself.
Enough, sweet Suffolk; you're torturing yourself, And these terrible curses, like the sun hitting glass, Or like an overloaded gun, bounce back And turn their force against you.
Stop, Suffolk. You're hurting yourself. All those curses you're throwing out are just going to bounce back and hit you instead. You're only making yourself suffer.
stop suffolk. those curses r coming back on u. ur only hurting urself
You bade me ban, and will you bid me leave?
Now, by the ground that I am banished from,
Well could I curse away a winter’s night,
Though standing naked on a mountain top
Where biting cold would never let grass grow,
And think it but a minute spent in sport.
You told me to curse, and now you tell me to stop? By this ground from which I am banished, I could curse through an entire winter's night, even standing naked on a mountain top where bitter cold prevents grass from growing, and I would think it merely a moment spent in enjoyment.
You just told me to curse them, and now you want me to stop cursing? I swear by this ground I have to leave—I could curse all night long, even if I were naked on top of a freezing mountain where nothing grows, and I'd think I was just having fun the whole time.
u said curse them now u want me to stop i could curse all night even freezing naked on a mountain
O, let me entreat thee cease. Give me thy hand,
That I may dew it with my mournful tears;
Nor let the rain of heaven wet this place
To wash away my woeful monuments.
O, could this kiss be printed in thy hand,
That thou mightst think upon these by the seal,
Through whom a thousand sighs are breathed for thee!
So, get thee gone, that I may know my grief;
’Tis but surmised whiles thou art standing by,
As one that surfeits thinking on a want.
I will repeal thee, or, be well assured,
Adventure to be banished myself;
And banished I am, if but from thee.
Go; speak not to me, even now be gone!
O, go not yet! Even thus two friends condemned
Embrace and kiss and take ten thousand leaves,
Loather a hundred times to part than die.
Yet now farewell, and farewell life with thee.
Please, let me beg you to stop. Give me your hand, So I can wet it with my grieving tears; And let heaven's rain not wash away The sad monuments of my love. If I could press this kiss into your palm, You could remember through that mark All the thousand sighs I breathe for you! Go then, so I can feel my grief alone; It's only half-realized while you're here, Like wanting something you can't have. I will bring you back, or I promise you, I will get banished myself; For I am banished if you're gone. Go; don't speak to me now, just go! But wait—don't go yet! Even as condemned friends Embrace and kiss and take ten thousand farewells, Reluctant a hundred times to separate rather than die. Yet now goodbye, and goodbye to life itself when you go.
Wait, don't go yet. Let me hold your hand so I can cry on it. I want to kiss you so the mark stays with you, reminding you of all my tears and sighs for you. But go then—just go so I can feel this grief alone. Right now I can't even feel it properly because you're here. I swear I'll get you back, or I'll get banished too. Without you I'm already exiled. Go ahead, leave me! No wait—please don't yet. We're like those condemned prisoners who take forever saying goodbye, kissing and holding on. So here we are—this is it. Goodbye to you, goodbye to everything.
let me hold u kiss u so u remember go. please go. no wait don't this is goodbye to everything
Thus is poor Suffolk ten times banished,
Once by the King, and three times thrice by thee.
’Tis not the land I care for, wert thou thence.
A wilderness is populous enough,
So Suffolk had thy heavenly company;
For where thou art, there is the world itself,
With every several pleasure in the world;
And where thou art not, desolation.
I can no more. Live thou to joy thy life,
Myself no joy in nought but that thou liv’st.
This is how I am banished ten times over—once by the King and three times three times by you. I do not care for the land, if you were not there. A wilderness would be populous enough if Suffolk had your heavenly company; for where you are is the whole world itself, with every pleasure in it; and where you are not, there is only emptiness. I can say no more. Live to enjoy your life; I have joy in nothing but that you live.
I'm banished ten times over—once by the King and then nine more times by you, each time we have to part. The land doesn't matter to me if you're not there. A desert would feel crowded if I had you with me. Wherever you are, that's my whole world, with everything I could want. Anywhere else is just empty and lonely. I can't say more than this: just live your life and be happy. The only thing that makes me happy is knowing you're alive.
banished 10 times once by king 9 by you land means nothing without u where u r is the whole world without u is nothing just live & be happy that's all i need
Whither goes Vaux so fast? What news, I prithee?
Where is Vaux going in such a hurry? What news do you bring?
Vaux, where are you rushing off to? What's happened?
vaux where u going? what's wrong?
To signify unto his majesty
That Cardinal Beaufort is at point of death;
For suddenly a grievous sickness took him,
That makes him gasp and stare and catch the air,
Blaspheming God and cursing men on earth.
Sometime he talks as if Duke Humphrey’s ghost
Were by his side; sometime he calls the King
And whispers to his pillow, as to him,
The secrets of his overcharged soul.
And I am sent to tell his majesty
That even now he cries aloud for him.
To tell your majesty That Cardinal Beaufort is dying; Because suddenly a terrible sickness seized him, That makes him gasp and stare and grasp at the air, Blaspheming God and cursing men on earth. Sometimes he speaks as if Duke Humphrey's spirit Were standing beside him; sometimes he calls to the King And whispers to his pillow, as though speaking to him, Revealing the secrets of his troubled soul. And I've been sent to tell your majesty That right now he's crying out loudly for him.
The King sent me to tell you that Cardinal Beaufort is dying. He got suddenly very ill—he's gasping, his eyes are wild, he's cursing God and everyone. He keeps acting like he sees Duke Humphrey's ghost. He's calling for the King, whispering to his pillow like it's the King, confessing all his secrets. And he's crying out for the King right now.
cardinal beaufort dying. sudden sickness. cursing god. says he sees humphrey's ghost. crying for the king now.
Go tell this heavy message to the King.
Go tell this serious news to the King.
Go tell the King right away.
tell the king. now.
Ay me! What is this world? What news are these!
But wherefore grieve I at an hour’s poor loss,
Omitting Suffolk’s exile, my soul’s treasure?
Why only, Suffolk, mourn I not for thee,
And with the southern clouds contend in tears,
Theirs for the earth’s increase, mine for my sorrows’?
Now get thee hence. The King, thou know’st, is coming;
If thou be found by me thou art but dead.
Oh me! What is this world? What terrible news! But why do I grieve over such a small loss when I should be mourning Suffolk's exile—the treasure of my soul? Why am I not weeping for you alone, Suffolk, competing with the clouds to produce tears—theirs for the earth's growth, mine for my sorrow? Now go. The King, as you know, is coming. If he finds you with me, you're dead.
Oh God! What is this world? What horrible news is this! But why am I crying about this when I should be devastated about Suffolk being banished—my whole world! Why aren't I weeping endlessly for you, Suffolk, trying to match the tears of the storm clouds? Now get out of here. The King is coming, and if he finds you with me, you're dead.
oh god this world why cry about this when suffolk's banished he's my everything gotta go kings coming if he finds u here u die
If I depart from thee, I cannot live;
And in thy sight to die, what were it else
But like a pleasant slumber in thy lap?
Here could I breathe my soul into the air,
As mild and gentle as the cradle-babe
Dying with mother’s dug between its lips;
Where, from thy sight, I should be raging mad
And cry out for thee to close up mine eyes,
To have thee with thy lips to stop my mouth.
So shouldst thou either turn my flying soul,
Or I should breathe it so into thy body,
And then it lived in sweet Elysium.
To die by thee were but to die in jest;
From thee to die were torture more than death.
O, let me stay, befall what may befall!
If I leave you, I cannot live; And to die in your presence—what could be better Than sleeping peacefully in your lap? I could breathe my soul out here As softly and gently as a baby dying With its mother's breast between its lips; But being separated from you, I'd go mad And cry out for you to close my eyes, To let your lips seal my mouth. So you would either pull my departing soul back, Or I would breathe it into your body, And then it would live in that paradise. To die with you would be a joke, not death; To die away from you would be worse than torture. Please, let me stay, come what may!
If you leave me I won't survive. And if I had to die, I'd want it to be with you, resting in your lap like a baby falling asleep on his mother. But if we're separated, I'll go insane. I need you there at the end to close my eyes, to kiss me as I die. Or maybe I could breathe my soul into you and stay with you that way. Dying with you would be nothing. Dying without you would be unbearable. Please don't make me go.
if u leave me i can't live dying w you would be like falling asleep w/o u it would destroy me please let me stay
Away! Though parting be a fretful corrosive,
It is applied to a deathful wound.
To France, sweet Suffolk! Let me hear from thee,
For whereso’er thou art in this world’s globe
I’ll have an Iris that shall find thee out.
Go! Even though separation is painful, It will heal this deadly wound. To France, my beloved Suffolk! Let me hear from you, Because wherever you are in this world I'll find a way to reach you.
You have to go. Yes, separation hurts, but it's what will save your life. Go to France, my love. Write to me. Wherever you go in the world, I'll find a way to contact you.
go to france. it hurts but it'll save u. i'll find u somehow
I go.
I'm leaving.
I'm going.
ok. bye.
And take my heart with thee.
And take my heart with you.
Go. Take what's left of my heart.
you got my heart with u
A jewel, locked into the woefull’st cask
That ever did contain a thing of worth.
Even as a splitted bark, so sunder we.
This way fall I to death.
A jewel locked in the saddest container That ever held something precious. Just as a split ship breaks apart, so do we. This way I fall toward death.
Your heart is a precious jewel in a sad prison. We're splitting apart like a ship in a storm. I'm going this way to my doom.
ur heart's a jewel in a sad box we're splitting apart i'm going to death
This way for me.
And this way I go.
And I must go this way to my fate.
so i head this way. goodbye.
The Reckoning
This is Shakespeare's most powerful scene about the immediate consequences of political murder. Gloucester's death is not a satisfaction but a catastrophe. It breaks Henry's will to govern, brings down the commons' fury on the conspirators, and begins the unraveling of the faction itself. The entire enterprise of murdering Gloucester—which was supposed to stabilize the regime—instead destabilizes it completely. Meanwhile, Margaret and Suffolk's parting is Shakespeare's most sophisticated love scene: two people completely entangled in a love that is destroying them both.
If this happened today…
Imagine a government's strongman is arrested by rivals, then dies in custody. The death breaks the president's will to govern. An investigation finds clear evidence of murder. The commons demand justice. The minister responsible is forced to flee. The lover of the architect of the coup stands alone, watching her co-conspirators destroyed, unable to go after them.