← 3.3
Act 3, Scene 4 — Another part of the Forest. Before a Cottage
on stage: —
Next: 3.5 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Orlando stands Rosalind up in the Forest — and her own medicine starts working on her instead of him.
Enter Rosalind and Celia.
ROSALIND [emotional overwhelm]

Never talk to me, I will weep.

Don't speak to me; I'm going to cry.

Just leave me alone, I'm going to cry.

dont talk 2 me im gonna cry

CELIA [gentle deflation of emotion]

Do, I prithee, but yet have the grace to consider that tears do not

become a man.

Go ahead and cry, please, but do consider that tears don't suit a man.

Go ahead and cry then, but remember that tears don't look good on a man.

cry if u want but tears dont suit men

"tears do not become a man" One of the play's sharpest little jokes: Celia reminds Rosalind that she's in disguise, and that the disguise is slipping — emotionally before it slips literally. The whole comedy depends on Rosalind maintaining Ganymede, and Ganymede is currently a mess.
ROSALIND [refusal to perform masculinity]

But have I not cause to weep?

But don't I have reason to cry?

Seriously though, isn't there plenty of reason for me to fall apart?

dont i have reason to cry?

CELIA [wryly validating her grief]

As good cause as one would desire; therefore weep.

As good a reason as anyone could want; so go ahead and cry.

You have every reason in the world, so yes, cry.

u have every reason so cry

Why it matters Celia's mock-logic is perfect: she agrees with the premise and draws the most unhelpful possible conclusion. It's what a best friend does when the cause is lost and the weeping is going to happen anyway — give permission and stand back.
ROSALIND [seeking reassurance about Orlando]

His very hair is of the dissembling colour.

His hair is literally the color of deception.

His hair is the color of a liar.

his hair color = lies

"his very hair is of the dissembling colour" A folk superstition with a long pedigree: red or auburn hair was the 'Judas color,' associated with betrayal. Shakespeare's audiences would have recognized this immediately. Celia is half-mocking the convention even as she uses it — she's finding evidence for Rosalind's doubt that neither of them really believe.
↩ Callback to Act 3, Scene 2 Orlando was supposed to arrive in 3-2's aftermath; the scene before this established the love-game. His absence here is the first crack in that game.
CELIA [mocking Orlando's coldness]

Something browner than Judas’s. Marry, his kisses are Judas’s own

children.

Somewhat browner than Judas's hair. Why, his kisses are like Judas's own children.

It's browner than Judas's hair. And his kisses—they're like Judas's own children.

browner than judas his kisses r judas's children

"his kisses are Judas's own children" Celia escalates from hair color to a sweeping verdict: his affections are all betrayal. This is the most pointed thing she says in the scene — a real dart under the playful surface. Whether she means it or is simply testing Rosalind's defense of him is left beautifully ambiguous.
ROSALIND [backpedaling to defend him]

I’ faith, his hair is of a good colour.

In truth, his hair is a good color.

Actually, his hair is a nice color.

his hair is nice

Why it matters This exchange — accuse, defend, reverse — is one of the most psychologically honest moments in the play. Rosalind can't sustain any criticism of Orlando for more than ten seconds. Her love has already won. The argument is just the last surface resistance before she admits it.
CELIA [sarcastically deepening the tease]

An excellent colour. Your chestnut was ever the only colour.

Excellent color. Chestnut has always been the only color for you.

A perfect color. But chestnut is really the only color that works for you.

perfect chestnut is ur only color

"Your chestnut was ever the only colour" Celia catches Rosalind's reversal and mirrors it back to her with gentle irony — 'ever the only colour' echoes a contemporary saying, turning Rosalind's sudden pro-chestnut position into a joke about how completely she's switched sides. The audience is watching someone argue themselves into love in real time.
ROSALIND [refusal to be calmed]

And his kissing is as full of sanctity as the touch of holy bread.

And his kiss is filled with holiness, like touching sacred bread.

And his kiss is so pure, it's like touching a holy sacrament.

his kiss is holy like sacred bread

CELIA [detailed contempt for Orlando's restraint]

He hath bought a pair of cast lips of Diana. A nun of winter’s

sisterhood kisses not more religiously; the very ice of chastity is in

them.

He has obtained a pair of lips donated by Diana herself. No nun from a winter convent kisses more devoutly; pure frozen chastity lives in them.

He's got lips donated by Diana. A nun in a winter convent couldn't kiss more reverently; those lips are absolutely frozen with purity.

he got diana's lips even nuns kiss less holy ice cold chaste lips

🎭 Dramatic irony Celia's skepticism about Orlando's tears — 'the oath of a lover is no stronger than the word of a tapster' — is the play's most accurate reading of the situation in the short term. Orlando has, in fact, not shown up. But his eventual constancy will prove her wrong. For now, the evidence supports her.
ROSALIND [sarcastic observation]

But why did he swear he would come this morning, and comes not?

But why did he swear he would come this morning, and now he doesn't come?

But why did he promise to come this morning, and then he doesn't show up?

why'd he swear hed come and then he doesnt

CELIA [mocking skepticism]

Nay, certainly, there is no truth in him.

Well, certainly, there is no honesty in him.

Definitely not. He's got no honesty in him.

nah theres no truth in him

ROSALIND [doubt]

Do you think so?

You really think that?

You really think so?

u think so?

CELIA [professional skepticism about Orlando's sincerity]

Yes. I think he is not a pick-purse nor a horse-stealer, but for his

verity in love, I do think him as concave as a covered goblet or a

worm-eaten nut.

Yes. I don't think he's a pickpocket or a horse thief, but when it comes to his truthfulness in love, I think he's as hollow as a covered cup or a worm-eaten nut.

Right. I don't think he's a criminal or a thief, but when it comes to being true in love, he's as hollow as a covered goblet or a bug-eaten nut.

not a thief but for love? hollow as a cup or worm-eaten nut

ROSALIND [weary acceptance]

Not true in love?

He's not sincere about love?

He doesn't really mean what he says about love?

wait he's not actually in love?

CELIA [insistence on reality]

Yes, when he is in, but I think he is not in.

Yes, he would be if he were in love, but I don't think he is in love.

Sure, he'd be truthful if he was actually in love—but I don't believe he is.

he would b if he was in love but hes not

ROSALIND [defending Orlando]

You have heard him swear downright he was.

You have heard him swear plainly that he was.

You've heard him swear he was in love.

u heard him swear he was

🎭 Dramatic irony Rosalind says 'the sight of lovers feedeth those in love' as a simple truth — she's going to watch love and be nourished by it. What she doesn't know is that Phoebe is about to fall in love with her (as Ganymede), turning the spectator into the spectacle. Her love won't be fed; it will be complicated.
CELIA [logical demolition of love-oaths]

“Was” is not “is”. Besides, the oath of a lover is no stronger than the

word of a tapster. They are both the confirmer of false reckonings. He

attends here in the forest on the Duke your father.

Past tense is not present tense. Besides, a lover's oath is no stronger than a bartender's word. They both confirm false accounts. He is here in the forest attending on your father the Duke.

Past tense isn't present tense. Plus, a lover's promise is just as worthless as a bartender's word—they both just confirm false bills. He's here in the forest working for your father.

'was' isnt 'is' lovers lie like bartenders he's here in forest

ROSALIND [deflecting from her father, focusing on Orlando]

I met the Duke yesterday, and had much question with him. He asked me

of what parentage I was. I told him, of as good as he, so he laughed

and let me go. But what talk we of fathers when there is such a man as

Orlando?

I met the Duke yesterday and had a long conversation with him. He asked me about my family background. I told him it was as good as his, so he laughed and sent me away. But why are we discussing fathers when there is someone like Orlando?

I ran into the Duke yesterday and we had a long talk. He asked where I came from, and I told him my family was as good as his, so he laughed and let me go. But why are we talking about fathers when there's someone like Orlando?

met the duke yesterday asked my family i said better than his lol but why talk fathers when theres orlando

CELIA [bitter mockery of masculine display]

O, that’s a brave man! He writes brave verses, speaks brave words,

swears brave oaths, and breaks them bravely, quite traverse, athwart

the heart of his lover, as a puny tilter, that spurs his horse but on

one side, breaks his staff like a noble goose. But all’s brave that

youth mounts and folly guides. Who comes here?

O, that's an impressive man! He writes impressive verses, speaks impressive words, swears impressive oaths, and breaks them impressively, straight across the heart of his lover, like a weak jouster who spurs his horse on only one side, breaks his lance like a silly fool. But everything is impressive when youth rides it and folly steers it. Who is coming here?

Oh yeah, he's amazing! He writes amazing verses, says amazing things, makes amazing promises, and breaks them spectacularly right through the heart of his lover—like some weak jouster who only spurs his horse on one side and snaps his lance like an idiot. But everything is amazing when youth rides it and folly steers it. Who's coming?

hes so brave writes great stuff breaks oaths brilliantly like a bad jouster but youth is folly whos coming

Enter Corin.
CORIN ≋ verse [offering to provide entertainment]

Mistress and master, you have oft enquired

After the shepherd that complained of love,

Who you saw sitting by me on the turf,

Praising the proud disdainful shepherdess

That was his mistress.

Mistress and master, you have often asked about the shepherd who complained of love, whom you saw sitting by me on the grass, praising the proud, disdainful shepherdess who was his beloved.

Mistress and master, you've been asking a lot about that shepherd who was complaining about love—the one you saw sitting next to me on the grass, going on about the proud, stuck-up shepherdess he's in love with.

u asked bout the shepherd who complains of love the one by me praising proud shepherdess

CELIA [prompting Corin to continue]

Well, and what of him?

Well, what about him?

So what's the story with this shepherd?

whats his deal?

Why it matters Corin's description of the encounter as a 'pageant truly played' is the scene's structural hinge: Rosalind is about to watch a drama that mirrors her own situation but from the outside. The distance won't hold.
CORIN ≋ verse [setting up the spectacle]

If you will see a pageant truly played

Between the pale complexion of true love

And the red glow of scorn and proud disdain,

Go hence a little, and I shall conduct you,

If you will mark it.

If you want to see a scene truly performed between the pale appearance of genuine love and the red glow of scorn and proud disdain, go a little distance from here, and I will take you there, if you will pay attention.

If you want to see a real scene play out between what true love looks like and what scorn and pride look like, come with me a little way, and I'll take you to see it—if you'll watch.

wanna see love play out? true love pale scorn red come w me ill show u

"a pageant truly played" Corin is framing Silvius and Phoebe as a piece of theater — unknowingly using the exact language the play itself has been using about love. The Forest of Arden keeps presenting love as spectacle, and the audience watching the play is watching characters watch other characters perform love. It's deliberately layered.
ROSALIND ≋ verse [eager to witness emotional performance]

O, come, let us remove.

The sight of lovers feedeth those in love.

Bring us to this sight, and you shall say

I’ll prove a busy actor in their play.

O, come, let us go. The sight of lovers nourishes those in love. Take us to this sight, and you will say I will prove an active participant in their drama.

Oh let's go. Watching lovers feeds people who are in love. Take us there, and I'll show you I can get involved in their story.

lets go seeing lovers feeds love take us there ill be in the play

[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

Rosalind has been playing the cure for love, and the cure is backfiring. She's been waiting for Orlando and he hasn't come, and she's been crying — which is awkward because she's still dressed as a boy. Celia watches with the affectionate skepticism of someone who can see exactly what's happening. Their banter about Orlando's hair color is a delaying tactic, a way to stay in motion so neither of them has to say the obvious: Rosalind is in love, entirely, without a net. When Corin arrives to offer them a front-row seat to Silvius and Phoebe's spectacle, Rosalind leaps at it — watching other people love badly is the next best thing to being loved herself. She doesn't yet know she's about to watch something that enrages her.

If this happened today…

Your therapist assigned you homework: spend time with someone who's terrible at relationships, observe their patterns, report back. The catch is you've started doing all the things they told you to stop doing — checking your phone every five minutes, rewriting texts, crying in the bathroom. Your best friend watches you spiral and maintains a carefully neutral expression. Then a neighbor texts: want to come watch my friend make the most cringe-worthy attempts at flirting you've ever seen? You say yes immediately, because at least when you're watching someone else's disaster you're not thinking about yours. You walk over. It turns out to be more complicated than you expected.

Continue to 3.5 →