← 2.3
Act 2, Scene 4 — The Forest of Arden
on stage:
Next: 2.5 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument They arrive in Arden exhausted, stumble onto Silvius and Corin, and accidentally buy a farm.
Enter Rosalind as Ganymede, Celia as Aliena, and Touchstone.
ROSALIND [exhausted—emotional and physical]

O Jupiter, how weary are my spirits!

God, how tired I am.

I'm so tired.

so exhausted

TOUCHSTONE [pragmatic—focused on the body, not the spirit]

I care not for my spirits, if my legs were not weary.

I don't care about my spirit. If my legs weren't so sore, I'd be fine.

My spirit's fine. My legs are killing me.

my legs hurt

ROSALIND [steel—the disguise means staying strong for Celia]

I could find in my heart to disgrace my man’s apparel, and to cry like

a woman, but I must comfort the weaker vessel, as doublet and hose

ought to show itself courageous to petticoat. Therefore, courage, good

Aliena.

I want to rip off these boy's clothes and cry like a woman, but I have to be the strong one here. That's what a man is supposed to do for a woman. So come on, Aliena—be brave.

I want to drop this disguise and have a total breakdown, but I can't. Someone has to be the strong one. That's the deal when you're dressed like a man—you don't get to cry. So come on, stay with me.

want to quit want to cry

but i'm supposed to be the strong one

so keep going

CELIA [desperate—at the limit of physical endurance]

I pray you bear with me, I cannot go no further.

Please, I can't go any further.

I can't do this anymore. I have to stop.

can't go on

TOUCHSTONE [joking, but with an edge—she has no money]

For my part, I had rather bear with you than bear you. Yet I should

bear no cross if I did bear you, for I think you have no money in your

purse.

I'd rather carry you than be carried, but I wouldn't have to carry your weight if you had money to pay me for it.

I'd rather carry you than let someone carry me, but if you had money you could pay me to do it, so that would be fine.

you got cash or we're stuck walking

ROSALIND [simple statement—this is it]

Well, this is the forest of Arden.

Well, here we are in the forest of Arden.

So this is the forest of Arden.

this is it

TOUCHSTONE [sardonic—nostalgia for comfort disguised as philosophy]

Ay, now am I in Arden, the more fool I! When I was at home I was in a

better place, but travellers must be content.

Great, now I'm in Arden—which makes me a fool. I was better off at home, but that's what travelers do: they have to accept what they get.

Perfect. I'm in Arden now and that's stupid. I was way better off at home. But you know, when you're traveling, you just have to deal with it.

arden is a dump home was better

such is life

Enter Corin and Silvius.
ROSALIND [redirecting—shifting attention away from Touchstone's complaints]

Ay, be so, good Touchstone. Look you, who comes here? A young man and

an old in solemn talk.

That's right, be content. Look—who's coming? A young man and an old man in serious conversation.

Right, be happy. Look, here come two people. One young, one old, having a serious talk.

look two men coming

🎭 Dramatic irony Rosalind watches Silvius pursue Phebe with amused distance, not knowing that in a few scenes she'll be doing exactly what Silvius is doing — pursuing Orlando through a game of disguise and wit.
First appearance
CORIN

Speaks in plain, practical sentences without irony. The only character in the forest who never performs — what he says is always exactly what he means. He's the play's honest witness.

CORIN [matter-of-fact warning—old experience speaking]

That is the way to make her scorn you still.

That's exactly what makes her reject you.

That's why she keeps turning you down.

she hates it

First appearance
SILVIUS

Speaks in the elevated, suffering language of Petrarchan love poetry — everything is absolute, every feeling a crisis. Rosalind finds him absurd and recognizes herself in him simultaneously.

SILVIUS [desperate plea—needs to be heard]

O Corin, that thou knew’st how I do love her!

Oh Corin, if you only knew how much I love her!

Corin, you don't get it. I love her so much.

you don't understand

CORIN [knowing—he's been there, trying not to be condescending]

I partly guess, for I have loved ere now.

I have some idea. I've loved before.

I think I know the feeling. I've been in love.

been there

SILVIUS ≋ verse [insistent—asserting the unique intensity of his love]

No, Corin, being old, thou canst not guess,

Though in thy youth thou wast as true a lover

As ever sighed upon a midnight pillow.

But if thy love were ever like to mine—

As sure I think did never man love so—

How many actions most ridiculous

Hast thou been drawn to by thy fantasy?

You can't know because you're old now. Yes, when you were young you loved, and you sighed into pillows at midnight. But did your love ever look like mine—as pure and total as what I feel? I'm certain no man has ever loved like this.

If your love was even close to mine, how many ridiculous things did it make you do?

No, you can't understand now because you're old. Maybe when you were young you loved someone, even at midnight. But was it like this? Like mine? I don't think anyone has ever loved the way I do.

If you'd loved like I do, how many stupid things would it have made you do?

you can't understand

you're old

no one's ever loved like this

the things love makes you do

CORIN [dry, deflecting—refusing to engage]

Into a thousand that I have forgotten.

A thousand things I've forgotten.

A thousand. Probably more, honestly.

too many

SILVIUS ≋ verse [passionate, manic—spiraling into his own intensity]

O, thou didst then never love so heartily!

If thou rememb’rest not the slightest folly

That ever love did make thee run into,

Thou hast not loved.

Or if thou hast not sat as I do now,

Wearing thy hearer in thy mistress’ praise,

Thou hast not loved.

Or if thou hast not broke from company

Abruptly, as my passion now makes me,

Thou hast not loved.

O Phoebe, Phoebe, Phoebe!

Then you've never loved truly. If you'd forgotten the smallest, dumbest thing love made you do, then you've never loved at all.

And if you haven't sat like I'm sitting now—boring everyone by talking about her constantly, exhausting your listener with her praise—then you've never loved.

Or if you haven't suddenly left a gathering because your passion pulled you away, breaking the conversation like I'm doing now—then you haven't loved.

Phebe! Phebe! Phebe!

Then you haven't loved. If you forgot even the tiniest stupid thing love made you do, you weren't in love.

If you haven't sat where I'm sitting—talking about her nonstop, boring everyone with how amazing she is—you haven't loved.

Or if you haven't just walked out of a room because you had to, because your heart was pulling you, the way I'm leaving now—you haven't loved.

Phebe! Phebe!

if you forgot it wasn't real

if you didn't bore everyone talking about her

if you didn't leave without reason

then you haven't loved

[_Exit Silvius._]
ROSALIND ≋ verse [struck by recognition—seeing herself in him]

Alas, poor shepherd, searching of thy wound,

I have by hard adventure found mine own.

Poor young shepherd—watching his wound opened up like that, I've discovered my own in the process.

Watching him suffer like that just showed me what I'm suffering from too.

seeing his pain showed me mine

TOUCHSTONE [warmly cynical—love is ridiculous and universal]

And I mine. I remember when I was in love I broke my sword upon a stone

and bid him take that for coming a-night to Jane Smile; and I remember

the kissing of her batlet, and the cow’s dugs that her pretty chopped

hands had milked; and I remember the wooing of a peascod instead of

her, from whom I took two cods, and, giving her them again, said with

weeping tears, “Wear these for my sake.” We that are true lovers run

into strange capers. But as all is mortal in nature, so is all nature

in love mortal in folly.

And I know my own wound. I remember when I was in love I broke my sword on a stone and told the stone to give it to Jane Smile for visiting her at night. I remember kissing her tennis racket and her hands—those soft hands that milked cows. I remember courting her with a pea pod, and when I took two pods and gave them back to her, I said through tears: 'Wear these for my sake.' We real lovers do strange, stupid things. But it's like everything in nature—love's folly is mortal and human. Nothing lasts.

I know love. I remember being in love with Jane Smile. I actually broke my sword on a rock because the rock came to her house at night. I kissed her work glove, the one with calluses from milking. I literally courted her with a pea pod. Two peas. And I gave them back and cried and told her to keep them for me. We lovers are lunatics. But everything dies anyway, including love. That's just how it works.

broke my sword on a rock for jane smile

courted her with peas

we're all ridiculous

it all dies anyway

ROSALIND [appreciative, amused—he's wiser than he knows]

Thou speak’st wiser than thou art ware of.

You speak more wisely than you realize.

You're smarter than you think.

that was actually wise

TOUCHSTONE [self-deprecating—he only learns wisdom by stumbling]

Nay, I shall ne’er be ware of mine own wit till I break my shins

against it.

No, I won't really understand my own wit until I trip over it and break my legs.

I'll never get it until I literally fall on my face.

don't give me credit

ROSALIND ≋ verse [struck by recognition—no longer abstract]

Jove, Jove, this shepherd’s passion

Is much upon my fashion.

This shepherd's passion looks just like my own.

He's describing exactly what I'm feeling.

that's me

TOUCHSTONE [detached—it's old hat to him now]

And mine, but it grows something stale with me.

Mine too, but it's wearing off.

Same, but I'm over it.

over it now

CELIA ≋ verse [desperate—forgetting philosophy, needing food]

I pray you, one of you question yond man

If he for gold will give us any food.

I faint almost to death.

Please, one of you go ask that shepherd if he'll sell us some food for money. I'm about to faint.

Can someone ask him if he's got food to sell? I'm starving.

ask for food i can't go on

TOUCHSTONE [loud, aggressive—Touchstone's usual tactic]

Holla, you clown!

Hey, you there!

Hey, you!

hey!

ROSALIND [sharp—stopping him before he makes it worse]

Peace, fool, he’s not thy kinsman.

Quiet, fool—he's not your relative.

Shut up. He's not some clown like you.

stop

CORIN [simple—responding to being called]

Who calls?

Who's there?

What?

yes?

TOUCHSTONE [pompous—Touchstone being Touchstone]

Your betters, sir.

Your betters, sir.

Better people than you.

your betters

CORIN [dry—cutting through pretension with logic]

Else are they very wretched.

Then they must be pretty miserable.

Then they're doing pretty badly.

then they're in trouble

"Else are they very wretched" Corin's comeback is perfectly calibrated: if betters are calling out to him like this, they must be in serious need. It's dignified, not rude — and it's right.
ROSALIND [polite, kind—trying to salvage the approach]

Peace, I say.—Good even to you, friend.

Forgive me. Good evening, my friend.

Sorry about that. Hello there, friend.

hello

CORIN [warm, straightforward—genuine greeting]

And to you, gentle sir, and to you all.

And good evening to you, gentle sir, and to all of you.

Hello to you too, and to all of you.

hello all

ROSALIND ≋ verse [urgent but polite—in disguise, trying diplomacy]

I prithee, shepherd, if that love or gold

Can in this desert place buy entertainment,

Bring us where we may rest ourselves and feed.

Here’s a young maid with travel much oppressed,

And faints for succour.

My friend, if love or money can help in this wilderness, would you take us somewhere we can rest and eat? I have with me a young woman who's been worn out by travel and is about to faint from hunger.

Listen, if we can pay you, would you help us? We need food and a place to sleep. My friend here is exhausted and starving.

we need shelter we'll pay

she's starving

CORIN ≋ verse [compassionate but honest—he wants to help but can't]

Fair sir, I pity her

And wish, for her sake more than for mine own,

My fortunes were more able to relieve her.

But I am shepherd to another man

And do not shear the fleeces that I graze.

My master is of churlish disposition

And little recks to find the way to heaven

By doing deeds of hospitality.

Besides, his cote, his flocks, and bounds of feed

Are now on sale, and at our sheepcote now,

By reason of his absence, there is nothing

That you will feed on. But what is, come see,

And in my voice most welcome shall you be.

I pity her and wish—for her sake even more than mine—that I had resources to help. But I'm just a hired shepherd. I don't own what I tend. My master is a hard man, not interested in doing good deeds. Besides, his farm is for sale, and right now there's nothing to spare at the cottage.

But come see what we have. Whatever it is, you'll be welcome.

I feel bad for her. I wish I could help you both, especially her. But I'm just working for someone else. I don't own this place. And my master is a difficult guy—not the charitable type. His whole farm is being sold off anyway. There's barely anything at the cottage right now.

But you can come look. Whatever we have, you're welcome to it.

i wish i could help i'm just a hired hand

master's tough, farm's for sale nothing to share

come anyway there's something

ROSALIND [business-like—an idea forming]

What is he that shall buy his flock and pasture?

Who will be buying the farm and pasture?

Who's buying it?

who's the buyer

CORIN ≋ verse [simple fact—amused at the irony]

That young swain that you saw here but erewhile,

That little cares for buying anything.

That young shepherd you just saw—the one who doesn't care about buying anything.

That guy you just watched go crazy over his girlfriend. He doesn't care about money.

silvius he doesn't care

ROSALIND ≋ verse [quick—a plan taking shape, testing the water]

I pray thee, if it stand with honesty,

Buy thou the cottage, pasture, and the flock,

And thou shalt have to pay for it of us.

Then please—if it's an honest deal—buy the cottage, pasture, and flock for us. We'll pay you for it.

Then buy it. Buy the cottage and the land and the sheep. We'll pay you. I mean, if you want to.

buy it for us we'll pay

CELIA ≋ verse [eager—settling in, ready to stay]

And we will mend thy wages. I like this place,

And willingly could waste my time in it.

And we'll increase your wages. I like this place and would be happy to spend time here.

And we'll pay you more. I like it here. I could stay.

we'll pay more i like it here

CORIN ≋ verse [energized—life has a direction again]

Assuredly the thing is to be sold.

Go with me. If you like upon report

The soil, the profit, and this kind of life,

I will your very faithful feeder be,

And buy it with your gold right suddenly.

Yes, it's ready to be sold. Come with me. If you like what you see—the land, the profit, the way of life—I'll be your faithful servant and buy it with your money right away.

Yeah, it's up for sale. Come on, I'll show you. You like it? The place, the land, how it works? I'll buy it for you today. With your money.

it's for sale come see it

you like it? i'll buy it today

[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

The forest of Arden arrives not as paradise but as a hard road ending in an open field, with three very tired people bickering about their legs. Rosalind-as-Ganymede makes her first appearance in disguise, and immediately the comedy complicates: Silvius's lovesickness over Phebe hits Rosalind like a mirror — she sees her own feelings about Orlando in someone else's embarrassing performance. Touchstone's cynical counterpoint (he once broke a sword on a stone for Jane Smile, which is not the same as love but is what love looks like from outside) makes the scene's emotional math add up to something true. Then Corin arrives — a real shepherd with a real problem — and the practical business of survival asserts itself. By scene's end, they have a cottage, a flock, and the beginnings of a life.

If this happened today…

Three friends land in a foreign city after a red-eye flight, no hotel, phones at 3%, wallets light. They stumble on a guy in the park monologuing about his ex to an older man who is very gently trying to change the subject. Your friend recognizes the feeling. You just want coffee. The old man says: 'There's actually a little place nearby for rent — not mine, I'm just the caretaker — but the owner might sell.' And somehow, despite everything, by noon you have somewhere to stay.

Continue to 2.5 →