← 3.9
Act 3, Scene 10 — Another part of the Plain.
on stage: —
Next: 3.11 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Enobarbus, Scarus, and Canidius watch in horror as Cleopatra's fleet flees mid-battle and Antony follows her, abandoning the fight — and Canidius immediately decides to surrender to Caesar.
Canidius marching with his land army one way over the stage, and
Taurus, the Lieutenant of Caesar, with his Army, the other way. After
their going in, is heard the noise of a sea fight.
Alarum. Enter Enobarbus.
ENOBARBUS ≋ verse [horrified disbelief at the rout]

Naught, naught, all naught! I can behold no longer.

Th’ Antoniad, the Egyptian admiral,

With all their sixty, fly and turn the rudder.

To see ’t mine eyes are blasted.

All is lost, all is lost, everything is lost! I can't bear to watch any longer. The Antoniad, the Egyptian flagship, with all sixty ships, are fleeing and turning around. The sight of it has blinded my eyes with sorrow.

Everything's gone! All of it gone! I can't watch this anymore. Cleopatra's ship, the flagship, with all sixty of her ships, they're running away. The sight of it makes me want to close my eyes.

it's all gone. can't look. cleopatra's fleet fleeing. all 60 ships. can't watch this.

Enter Scarus.
First appearance
SCARUS

Scarus is the most viscerally angry voice among Antony's men — he speaks in images of violent disgust when he's outraged, but his loyalty to Antony personally is fierce. Watch for how his fury is always directed at the situation, never quite at Antony himself.

SCARUS ≋ verse [outraged, cursing the gods]

Gods and goddesses,

All the whole synod of them!

Gods and goddesses, all the entire assembly of them!

All the gods and goddesses put together!

all the gods. every single one.

ENOBARBUS [urgent, demanding to know what happened]

What’s thy passion?

What is troubling you?

What's wrong with you?

what's wrong?

SCARUS ≋ verse [bitter despair at the lost empire]

The greater cantle of the world is lost

With very ignorance. We have kissed away

Kingdoms and provinces.

The larger part of the world is lost through sheer stupidity. We have given away kingdoms and provinces.

We've lost half the world because of pure idiocy. We threw away kingdoms and provinces like they were nothing.

lost half the world 2 stupidity. gave away kingdoms & provinces.

ENOBARBUS [anxious, pressing for the full account]

How appears the fight?

How does the battle look?

How's the fighting going?

how's the fight?

SCARUS ≋ verse [disgusted, describing Cleopatra's flight]

On our side, like the tokened pestilence,

Where death is sure. Yon ribaudred nag of Egypt,

Whom leprosy o’ertake, i’ th’ midst o’ th’ fight,

When vantage like a pair of twins appeared,

Both as the same—or, rather, ours the elder—

The breeze upon her, like a cow in June,

Hoists sails and flies.

On our side it's like a plague marked by death - certain death. That disreputable ship from Egypt, cursed and wretched, in the middle of the fight when victory appeared as equal twins - or rather, we had the better chance - caught the wind and, like a cow in summer, hoisted her sails and fled.

On our side it's like a plague - death is certain. That shameful ship from Egypt, that cursed thing, right in the middle of the battle when we had victory in our grasp - two equal chances or even we had the better one - she caught a wind and just sailed away like some dumb cow in summer.

we're dying. cleopatra's ship in middle of fight when we coulda won. caught wind & sailed away like stupid cow.

ENOBARBUS ≋ verse [sickened, unable to watch further]

That I beheld.

Mine eyes did sicken at the sight and could not

Endure a further view.

I saw that. The sight made my eyes sick and I couldn't bear to look any further.

I saw it too. The sight of it made me ill - I couldn't keep watching.

i saw it. it made me sick. couldn't keep watching.

SCARUS ≋ verse [appalled at Antony's shameful pursuit]

She once being loofed,

The noble ruin of her magic, Antony,

Claps on his sea-wing and, like a doting mallard,

Leaving the fight in height, flies after her.

I never saw an action of such shame.

Experience, manhood, honour, ne’er before

Did violate so itself.

Once she turned her ship, the noble man who was enchanted by her, Antony, catches the wind and like a foolish duck, abandons the battle at its height and flies after her. I never saw such shameful behavior. Experience, manhood, honor - never before did they violate themselves so completely.

Once her ship turned, Antony - that great man she had wrapped around her finger - just catches the wind in his sails and, like some stupid duck, leaves the battle while it's still going on and chases after her. I've never seen anything so shameful. All his years of experience, his manhood, his honor - none of it means anything anymore.

her ship turns. antony catches wind & chases her like stupid duck. leaves battle. never seen such shame. experience honor all gone.

"The noble ruin of her magic" One of the most piercing three-word descriptions in Shakespeare: Antony is simultaneously 'noble' — great, magnificent — and a 'ruin' — destroyed, collapsed — and Cleopatra's spell is called 'magic,' acknowledging her power while also suggesting it has bewitched him.
"like a doting mallard" A mallard is a common duck — as far as possible from an eagle or a lion. Scarus deliberately chooses the most undignified possible animal for Antony at this moment.
Why it matters This is the moment the play turns: the Battle of Actium, lost not by military failure but by a man following a ship.
🎭 Dramatic irony Scarus calls Antony 'the noble ruin of her magic' — a phrase that captures the play's central paradox. Antony has not been destroyed by something cheap. He has been ruined by something magnificent. The audience, having witnessed Cleopatra in Acts 1-2, understands why.
ENOBARBUS [grieving, overcome by the disgrace]

Alack, alack!

Alack, alack!

Alack, alack!

alack, alack!

Enter Canidius.
CANIDIUS ≋ verse [despairing, blaming Antony's failure]

Our fortune on the sea is out of breath

And sinks most lamentably. Had our general

Been what he knew himself, it had gone well.

O, he has given example for our flight

Most grossly by his own!

Our luck at sea has run out and is sinking miserably. If our general had been true to what he knew himself to be, it would have gone well. He has set an example for our soldiers by fleeing so shamefully himself!

Our chance at victory on the sea is dead and drowning. If our general had been true to himself, we would have won. He's just shown all his troops the example they needed - by running away like a coward!

our sea luck is dead. if general stayed true we'd win. he showed troops how 2 flee by fleeing himself.

ENOBARBUS ≋ verse [grim resignation to their defeat]

Ay, are you thereabouts?

Why, then, good night indeed.

Yes, is that your thinking? Well then, it's all over.

So that's where your head's at? Well, that's it then. We're finished.

u going there? then it's over.

CANIDIUS [flat, reporting their commander's flight]

Toward Peloponnesus are they fled.

They have fled toward Peloponnesus.

They're heading toward Peloponnesus.

they're heading 2 peloponnesus.

SCARUS ≋ verse [resigned, waiting to see what follows]

’Tis easy to’t, and there I will attend

What further comes.

It's easy to do, and there I will wait to see what happens next.

It's easy to run away. I'll go there and see what comes next.

easy 2 flee. i'll wait & see what happens.

CANIDIUS ≋ verse [resolved to defect, self-justifying]

To Caesar will I render

My legions and my horse. Six kings already

Show me the way of yielding.

I will surrender my legions and cavalry to Caesar. Six kings have already shown me the way to yield.

I'm giving my army and cavalry to Caesar. Six other kings have already shown me how to surrender.

i'm giving my army 2 caesar. 6 kings already showed me how 2 surrender.

ENOBARBUS ≋ verse [torn, loyalty overruling his doubts]

I’ll yet follow

The wounded chance of Antony, though my reason

Sits in the wind against me.

I will still follow Antony's ruined fate, even though my reason argues against me.

I'm staying with Antony despite what happened, even though every logical thought in my head is telling me not to.

i'm staying w/ antony. even tho my mind's against it.

Why it matters Enobarbus stays — not because he believes Antony can win, but because he cannot yet leave. His choice here will haunt him for the rest of the play.
[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

The catastrophe arrives not with a crash but with the image of a man following a ship. Scarus's language is brutal and precise — 'a doting mallard' chasing a fleeing cow. Canidius decides to defect on the spot. Enobarbus stays with Antony not because he believes in the cause but because he cannot yet bring himself to leave. The scene is fourteen speeches and it contains the turning point of the entire play.

If this happened today…

Three executives on a glass mezzanine watch their company's stock price as the product launch fails live on stage. 'I can't watch this anymore,' says one. 'It's total collapse.' 'He just walked off the stage to follow her to the greenroom,' says another. 'I've never seen anything so embarrassing.' The third one opens his phone and emails the competitor's HR. 'I'm staying,' says the first. 'My reason says to leave. My loyalty says to stay.' He stays.

Continue to 3.11 →